5 ms·
> The results show strong correlations, but research that would prove a causal link is difficult because ethical experiments cannot deliberately expose people t
by im3w1l 7y ago
> The results show strong correlations, but research that would prove a causal link is difficult because ethical experiments cannot deliberately expose people to harm.
This is kind of my hobby horse: you don't need to subject people to harm to test causuality. You can do the opposite: Remove harm and see what happens. Maybe give people free HVAC upgrades to filter more particles.
- allovernow 7y agoIt's a lot harder to test without administering the subject in question because there are far more variables to control than (mostly) just A/B. HVAC may confound the study by removing the actual responsible substances, for example, if "air pollution" is not solely the cause.
- hyperpallium 7y agoIsn't removing the "actual responsible substances" from the air removing air pollutants?
- frank_nitti 7y agoSemantically, yes. But I assume they are referring to the what people would consider the usual suspects for "big city" pollution, i.e. exhaust, aerosols.
- wongarsu 7y ago"HEPA filters reduce depression and suicide rate" might not be quite the causality we are looking for, but it would be a big stepping stone in addition to being a very useful result on its own.
- close04 7y agoThe trick is to adjust only the parameter you were targeting. Say you also change temperature and humidity and they are the real culprits, or big contributors. This is why the unethical method would be more precise because conceivably it's easier to introduce specific pollutants in the experiment. Of course this would be irresponsible so I'm hoping that by combining data from multiple studies and getting a better grip on how to control the test environment to selectively adjust (remove) only the studied parameters (pollutants) we can still get a good idea of what's happening.
- corin_ 7y agoWould it be unethical to provide a free filter that takes out all particles, then re-adds one specific pollutant back into the air at the exact same level? On the one hand, the machine is specifically administering the pollutant to humans; on the other, without the device they'd be getting the exact same and worse.. I'd say yes if offered that for my house and it could help research.
- close04 7y agoIt would definitely be very impractical and expensive to achieve. Also the fact that you add back those particles still feels at least a bit unethical. Definitely not a simple issue. But using a filter that selectively removes just that pollutant and changes nothing[0] else would probably be the cleanest way to do it. [0] another thing that's very hard to achieve.
- corin_ 7y agoIf the result to the user (getting a machine that leaves them with clean air except 1 type of polutant at exactly the level that polutant would be without the machine), is it really different ethically based on whether the machine leaves that polutant or removes then replaces it? Seems kind of like saying (although this example is certainly less ethical to those of us who oppose murder and death penalties) that there's a difference ethically between killing someone by putting poison into their body vs. killing them by preventing food/water to go into their body. But as to achieving it, sure I wasn't proposing it as necessarily a good or feasible option - other the little bit of research I did when choosing which air purifier for my bedroom I don't know much about the technology. I was more just thinking about the ethical question if it were possible, since I can appreciate the argument against it but like I said, I personally would be completely happy for a research team to offer me the hypothetical machine.
- close04 7y agoThis is probably more of a philosophical point. But if you removed all pollutants then by putting one back in you're actually poisoning your subject. I guess it's the difference between a surgeon operating and taking out 90% of a tumor, and a surgeon taking out the whole tumor then putting a bit back in. But again, I am not an ethics expert, this is just me bouncing ideas.
- n4r9 7y agoEven when you lack this level of control it may still be possible to infer causal effects. There's some interesting work that I've seen on this, good write up here: http://www.michaelnielsen.org/ddi/if-correlation-doesnt-imply-causation-then-what-does/ http://www.michaelnielsen.org/ddi/if-correlation-doesnt-impl...
- raindeer3 7y agoCan recommend Judea Pearl's recent book on the subject. The Book of Why
- dhshahsndeisjwn 7y agoWas just about the say the same. He has an excellent chapter on the history of smoking research with an interesting anecdote (repeated here https://priceonomics.com/why-the-father-of-modern-statistics-didnt-believe/ https://priceonomics.com/why-the-father-of-modern-statistics...) that the pipe-smoking Fischer refused to believe smoking caused harm well after the evidence was clear because correlation!=causation.
- stevenwoo 7y agoThey kind of already did that experiment in southern California for schools, they just need to run the numbers before and after filters installed adjusted for regular pollution/suicide rates https://www.scpr.org/news/2018/02/05/80413/at-schools-near-freeways-air-filters-help-students/ https://www.scpr.org/news/2018/02/05/80413/at-schools-near-f...
- homulilly 7y agoOr, like, reduce air pollution since in addition to this possibility it's already known to cause asthma, lung cancer, and heart disease.
- vanderZwan 7y agoThis kind of gets into philosophical questions about what could still be considered a causal link. If the increased chance of depression is caused by significant reduction in quality of life which is caused by pollution, do we still say air pollution has a causal link with depression? I'm leaning towards yes because removing the air pollution will through multiple steps reduce depression/suicide in that case.
- icandoit 7y agoI feel that mere causation is sufficient to promote action. Waiting for causation feels like rationalizing laziness. People don't wait to determine whether school district performance is caused by the staff or the selection effect of eager parents, they just move to good school districts. Chase those good effects AND attempt to understand them. Understanding the mechanism is not necessary to select for good results. (All ethics is utilitarian in effect. Kantians stop pretending.)
- frank2 7y agoAbout 20 years ago our society gained a deep understanding of the notion of causality. (To learn more, search the web for "Judea Pearl".) According to the terminology standardized at that time, yes, if adding particulate pollution to the air makes it more likely that a person breathing that air is depressed, then that is a casual link or a cause-and-effect relationship. It might be the case however that polluting the air reduces the person's quality of life and that if it were possible to effect an identical reduction of quality of life without polluting the air, then polluting the air would have no further effect on the likelihood of depression. if that is the case, we say that quality of life "screens off" the effect of air pollution on depression.
- barney54 7y agoThis is not true of asthma. Outdoor air quality in the United States has improved over time [1] and asthma rates has increased. [1] https://www.epa.gov/air-trends https://www.epa.gov/air-trends
- AstralStorm 7y agoProblem being of estimating NNT to see the effect. If the effect size is small you will need huge numbers to detect it Plus unfiltered air is elsewhere, as a confounder.
- dhshahsndeisjwn 7y agoThis is my hobby horse! A confounder would be an unobserved (unmeasured) variable that influences both the allocation to treatment and the outcome. In this case unfiltered air elsewhere is contaminating the magnitude of the treatment effect (in a conservative direction) but wouldn't undermine the validity of a properly conducted experiment.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 7y ago>Maybe give people free HVAC upgrades to filter more particles. Or just reduce pollution in the first place! AFAIK, manufacturing and running HVAC would add more pollution and cost more than switching (for instance) from internal combustion engines to electric vehicles. Or even better, cycling within cities. etc.
- throwawaylolx 7y agoGP was probably thinking about practical solutions, not idealized solution.
- onion2k 7y agoThat would also remove other things from the air, which ruins the experiment. The only way to measure if a particular type of pollution is responsible is to only filter that one out, which is basically impossible, or to increase the amount of that one, which is unethical because it's potentially harmful.
- sooheon 7y agoYou're changing the goal. The question being asked is whether polluted air is healthier than filtered air. The health effects of individual pollutants is a separate matter.
- icandoit 7y agoI can think of 2 research questions: 1. Does adding an air filter in peoples home improve health outcomes? 2. Does pumping a suspected noxious element into a room in lab harm some small group of people in some limited testable way? Question 1 is better than 2. Why? Because there are more people like those in question 1. Answers to question 1 inform my future choices, answers to question 2 do not. I prefer answers that improve health to those that harm health. Always prefer observational studies done in the field (in situ). Demanding experimental studies done in a lab will give you less bang for your buck. Let's all do our part to drive down health care costs, please.
- sooheon 7y agoWhich they've already done, many times. Here's one study where they either gave real or fake air purifiers to people in Shanghai and measured cardiopulmonary benefits of intervention: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26022815 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26022815
- im3w1l 7y agoNice! But no mention of depression there.
- icandoit 7y agoSpousal death is a big cause of depression. Is that sufficient to convince you of a causal chain? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4119479/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4119479/ I wish I had as many advocates as the devil did.
- im3w1l 7y agoI don't think that's the kind of causal chain they are going for. Article seems to suggest that the depression comes from damage to the body from the particles.
- icandoit 7y agoI have a friend Galant who cleans his room everyday and has wealth and happiness. I have another friend Goofus whose room is a mess. I'm not suggesting that the things in a room cause depression. Correlation tells you more than strict causation ever could. An example: Income is higher among vim users than eclipse users. Does that suggest anything to you? It does to me, but that's because I'm willing to let the evidence shape my decisions. If I waited for strictly-causal proof then I'm leaving money on the table. Another tip: When will it stop being the case that vim users make more money than eclipse users? When evidence mounts and marginally push the lazy-about-evidence-people toward vim. By the time the last eclipse user switches away there won't be any more money on the table to take. Also eclipse will be dead by then. Be greedy with evidence and lazy with your attachments, not the reverse.
- icandoit 7y agoDifferences in Birth Weight Associated with the 2008 Beijing Olympics Air Pollution Reduction: Results from a Natural Experiment https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/10.1289/ehp.1408795 https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/doi/10.1289/ehp.1408795 Personally, I'm down with harm reduction even if it doesn't teach us anything. As a goal it seems pretty good on its own.
- myself248 7y agoAs the old comic goes: "What if it's all a hoax and we create a better world for nothing?"
- thinkcontext 7y ago> Maybe give people free HVAC upgrades to filter more particles. HVAC and indoor air quality (IAQ) is a fascinating topic and it takes good design to get it right. In most HVAC systems you can't just stick a higher MERV filter in and expect good results because they are designed for specific amounts of air flow. Thicker filters cause more air resistance which reduces air flow and fan efficiency which means less comfort and greater energy use. Often a better strategy in a retrofit is to increase air sealing (a good energy recommendation anyway) and install an E/HRV to exchange indoor for outdoor air with a good filter in it. PM2.5 comes from outside so this should take care of it. https://www.energyvanguard.com/blog/unintended-consequences-high-merv-filters https://www.energyvanguard.com/blog/unintended-consequences-... https://www.energyvanguard.com/blog/7-reasons-your-filter-isnt-improving-your-indoor-air-quality https://www.energyvanguard.com/blog/7-reasons-your-filter-is...