3 ms·
Unfortunately, Red Hat has a successful "Enterprise Edition" (with its free variant being CentOS). A bunch of companies think that's somehow better to have that
by einpoklum 7y ago
Unfortunately, Red Hat has a successful "Enterprise Edition" (with its free variant being CentOS). A bunch of companies think that's somehow better to have that than to hire people to support general-use distributions.
I've had quite a bit of experience with Debian and Debian-derived distributions, a little experience with CentOS 8. I heavily disapprove of CentOS based on this experience and see it as not just restrictive, but also kind of flaky and shaky.
- technofiend 7y ago>A bunch of companies think that's somehow better to have that than to hire people to support general-use distributions. I work for a Fortune 50 and we're one of those companies that made that decision. Having someone to call when things go south is worth every penny. It's not that you can't hire completely competent people to deal with any issue, it's just outsourcing the staffing and expertise needed to do it globally is IMHO cheaper. Even if you have a large company you're still probably gonna have a kernel guy and a filesystem guy and some CEPH guys who are all familiar with the code base. Redhat has a phalanx of people in their employ both contributing code to upstream projects and backporting features to their version of Linux. There's a whole room of kernel guys, filesystem guys, etc, etc, etc. Hiring and keeping that bench of talent happy is someone else's problem when you buy Redhat. >I've had quite a bit of experience with Debian and Debian-derived distributions, a little experience with CentOS 8. I heavily disapprove of CentOS based on this experience and see it as not just restrictive, but also kind of flaky and shaky. CentOS 8 may be "flaky and shaky", dunno... haven't used it. But RHEL 5, 6, and 7 have been rock solid in my experience. If anything Redhat was too conservative and I was delighted to see Redhat adopt a different and much more aggressive patch and update lifecycle for RHEL 8. But moving faster does sometimes break things as the mantra for HN will tell you.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> A bunch of companies think that's somehow better to have that than to hire people to support general-use distributions. Why 'somehow'? Is that not conceivable? How much does a qualified person cost you? Maybe quarter of a million dollars a year or so all-in with salary, stock, benefits, recruitment cost? How many of them do you need to get 24x7 support? Five of them? That's $1.25 million. You can buy a lot of 24-hour support from RedHat for a lot less than that.
- x0x0 7y agoI think it's also having deeper expertise than is available even for that $1.25m/year. In a previous life, we paid perhaps $25k to a postgres consultancy that did support. They employed some of the core devs, and their promise was that you could escalate to a core dev within perhaps 24h. My employer hit a very weird performance regression when a database crossed a boundary size and having that deep expertise on call to diagnose, figure out a short-term fix, and help get a long-term fix deployed was invaluable and worth every penny. The type of people who have millions of dollars of hardware under management pay for support so they can get super deep expertise on hand when they need it.
- chrisseaton 7y agoRight - I presume if you pay RedHat enough and you have a serious problem with, say, JRuby, that they ping the JRuby lead and it gets fixed. What's your generalist support person that you directly employ doing? Poking around in the JRuby code base for the first time in their lives while your business is offline?
- hinkley 7y agoI would hope those 5 people have other responsibilities besides babysitting the OS all day long every day. And when you consider that those 5 people have a bigger vested interest in preventing problems than Red Hat does, their cost to value ratio gets less dire.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> their cost to value ratio gets less dire Yes I'm sure it sometimes pays off and sometimes doesn't. But it doesn't deserve a mocking 'somehow.'
- vkou 7y ago> I would hope those 5 people have other responsibilities besides babysitting the OS all day long every day. Then you are unlikely to hire 5 people with deep expertise. If you only need a deep expert two weeks out of the year (Especially when you can't predict what those two weeks are), it makes a hell of a lot of sense to pay for a support contract, then an in-house expert. You probably drive a car every day, but you're not a certified auto mechanic. You outsource that expertise, for situations when you need it.