7 ms·
The article is correct in that Buddha being a prince is a myth. The use of the word myth in connection with religion always fascinates me. The entire concept o
by ggm 7y ago
The article is correct in that Buddha being a prince is a myth.
The use of the word myth in connection with religion always fascinates me. The entire concept of religion generally depends on myths. recursive use of myth in myth.
Generally I have to read these sentences as in my opinion because the 'factual' quality of statements regarding the ur-myths of religion is usually not quantifiable, its all contextually defined by interpretation, semantics, ontology, eschatology, history, culture...
- alexmingoia 7y agoWhen I say myth, I mean in the sense that it’s not actually supported by the Tripitaka, which is the first complete written account of Buddha’s teachings by a lineage of his original monastic order (mostly confirmed by historical evidence where it exists) to survive as written to the present day, and considered canonical Buddhist teaching. It is most definitely quantifiable whether something is or is not written in the Tripitaka. That is why it remains important and historically significant.
- ggm 7y agoSo its not supported by the canonical text makes it mythic. Ok, I get it now. Apocryphal.
- sls 7y agoDo you think there's a difference between "Ashoka warred with Kalinga" (contemporary and/or near-contemporary evidence survives) and "Ashoka built 84,000 stupas" (for the sake of this discussion, let's assume that there is no historical evidence for this). Because that's the distinction being drawn above.
- jaldhar 7y agoOne also has to bear in mind that the Tripitakha was compiled several centuries after the Buddha is said to have lived and has several divergent versions according to the ideological predilections of its editors. Also Pali was probably not the native language of the Buddha. The vernacular of the area where he lived and taught was call Magadhi. (The Jain Agamas are transmitted in a related language called Ardhamagadhi “half Magadhi”) Pali was prevalent in Avanti in West India (the geographical base of Sthaviravadins) not Magadha. The Sarvastivadins used Sanskrit, and Mahasanghikas used yet another language for their version. All of them claimed to have “The Original Teachings of the Buddha.” So I think attempts to find “fundamental” Buddhism are ultimately futile.
- ma2rten 7y agoI believe that some scholars actually believe that Pali is an artificial language, a mixture between different dialects that was intelligible to people from different regions. There is no question that there are some later additions. There are even some contradictions. But by comparing different passages and comparing with the Chinese Agamas, we can get a pretty good idea of what the Buddha actually thought.
- jaldhar 7y agoYes I have read that Pali could have been a trade language. Interestingly this method of textual comparison has also proven useful in tracing the history of the “Hindu” Samkhya school; one of whose early works, lost in Sanskrit, is preserved in the Chinese (Mahayana) Buddhist canon.
- nsomaru 7y agoI’m interested in the Sankhyans! Any reference?
- jaldhar 7y agoSorry for the late reply but as an introduction I suggest “Encyclopedia of Indian Philosopies Volume IV: Samkhya A Dualistic Tradition in Indian Philosophy” Gerald James Larson & Ramshankar Bhattacharya (editors), Delhi, Motilal Banarsidass, 1987.
- emptysongglass 7y agoThe "divergent versions" you refer to are really not so divergent as to exclude the discovery of a fundamental Buddhism. The Chinese collections and the Theravadin are remarkably similar and this despite being worlds apart in language of composition.
- dionian 7y agoIt turns out that myths are an incredibly powerful vessel to preserve and transmit information. Especially before we had widespread access to printing presses, books, and libraries
- wahern 7y ago"Sacred text as cultural genome: an inheritance mechanism and method for studying cultural evolution", https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/2153599X.2016.1195766 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/2153599X.2016.11...: > Sacred religious texts have the properties required for an inheritance system. They are replicated across generations with high fidelity and are transcribed into action every generation by the invocation and interpretation of selected passages. In this article we borrow concepts and methods from genetics and epigenetics to study the “expressed phenotypes” of six Christian churches that differ along a conservative–progressive axis. Their phenotypic differences, despite drawing upon the same sacred text, can be explained in part by differential expression of the sacred text. Since the invocation and interpretation of sacred texts are often well preserved, our methods allow the expressed phenotypes of religious groups to be studied at any time and place in history. An article by one of the authors on the paper: https://evolution-institute.org/religious-epigenetics/ https://evolution-institute.org/religious-epigenetics/
- acqq 7y agoA response to that paper: https://onunicornsandgenes.blog/2018/11/04/journal-club-of-one-sacred-text-as-cultural-genome-an-inheritance-mechanism-and-method-for-studying-cultural-evolution/ https://onunicornsandgenes.blog/2018/11/04/journal-club-of-o...
- chrisweekly 7y agoYour point misses the mark, given the discussion centers on history and not religion per se. The biological human life of Siddartha (not to mention Jesus of Nazareth) is a matter of historical evidence, not faith or religious belief.
- brigandish 7y agoI'm always fascinated by the use of the word religion in connection with Buddhism. I can see why, people are always mislabeling things in a way that makes sense in a quick-and-dirty way that reuses existing models of thought, but they're ultimately a drag on any deeper discussion, and this happened long ago with Buddhism. It's not a religion, it's a framework that other religions have taken on. Hence there are Buddhist religions. It makes about as much sense to call Buddhism a religion as it is to call Ruby on Rails a website (if we're being precise). Note: I can see how this could look like a rebuttal but it's not, I'm actually joining in with the discussion, riding along with it, not trying to be an arse. I liked the comment I'm replying to! :)
- zepto 7y agoThe teachings of Buddha are a framework that religions have taken on in the same sense that the teachings of Jesus are a framework that religions have taken on.
- brigandish 7y agoI would define a framework as set of methods and practices to apply to a specific problem domain, those methods based on principles/conclusions arrived at from observation of that domain. If the teachings of Jesus are a framework that religions have taken on and not a doctrine, then you should specify: 1. what the problem domain is 2. what the conclusions drawn about that domain are 3. what the principles are and how they are arrived at 4. what the methods are 5. how it can be applied to different religions, or non-religions (for example, what use does prayer to God or eternal damnation have to atheists?) You should also deal with the problem of a supernatural being that you must believe in and follow (may be covered in (5)). I don't know many frameworks like that.
- zepto 7y agoJust because the teachings of Jesus aren’t presented in the format you prefer doesn’t mean they can’t be. It’s not hard to do this, so I’ll leave that as an exercise for you. Who said the framework has to be useful for atheists?
- slothtrop 7y agoI took the usage of myth here to make a distinction when talking about what we know of the "historical" Buddah but maybe I'm wrong and his contradiction was informed by religious scripture
- Iv 7y agoThing is, it is totally appropriate in historical discussions about existing people, even if they are playing an important role in a religion. That's actually what usually happens when you dissect religions: you spot myths, inaccuracies, later inventions, exaggeration, propaganda, and once all that removed, you are left back with a much more historical account that usually looks nothing like the original religion.
- StandardFuture 7y agoThis feels pedantic and off-topic. This is clearly just as much a discussion of historical accuracy as it is one of religious accuracy. Religious documents are just as valuable to historians and archaeologists, etc. as they are to people who practice a religion.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]