4 ms·
I don't agree that companies should have a responsibility to provide a minimum standard of living. Not because I don't think people should have a minimum stand
by kelnos 7y ago
I don't agree that companies should have a responsibility to provide a minimum standard of living. Not because I don't think people should have a minimum standard of living, but because I don't think it makes sense to push that responsibility onto tens of thousands of entities that have different financial situations and structures.
Far better would be for the government to take care of this (via single-payer health insurance, possibly even something like UBI), and tax companies an appropriately higher amount in order to fund it. This would of course require a major overhaul of the tax code in order to eliminate loopholes that allow companies to hide revenue/income and dodge paying their fair share.
Given all the issues around this in the first place, it is clear that expecting companies to provide for their employees isn't working. AB5 is just a band-aid that treats the symptoms and not the cause, and comes with a ton of negative unintended consequences.
As much as I don't like how Uber/Lyft run their businesses (and yet I still use them), they have completely revolutionized (in a good way) how I get around my city. Every driver who I've talked to about AB5 has reacted negatively to it. Either they believe it'll be the end of Uber/Lyft, or they just point out they won't want to drive for them anymore because their flexibility will be destroyed.
- hellisothers 7y agoBut to some extent this was the deal business made with government during the construction of the “military-industrial-complex”: the private sector will employ people at wages and benefits that allow them to be supported during work and retirement in exchange for the govt providing tax breaks/incentives and business/work. Unfortunately the tax breaks and business is still around but industry has slowly wheedled its way out of its social responsibility which you can see in things like contractors everywhere and pushing health and retirement responsibilities back to the govt.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoHaving employers provide health and retirement instead of just paying higher wages was always one form of scam or another. It started off as a tax dodge (wages were taxed but not benefits), and then it became a way for corporate execs (and governments!) to commit accounting fraud by attracting workers with pensions without actually funding them. We should be rid of them and just have higher wages so people can choose what they want for themselves.
- votepaunchy 7y agoNote trust employer-funded health insurance started not as a tax dodge but as a wage-cap dodge during World War II.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoInteresting. I wonder if that's why it was never purged when they did everything else. There used to be a long list of benefits companies would provide, like company cars, that all went poof right after they started getting counted as taxable income.
- keenmaster 7y ago>"Interesting. I wonder if that's why it was never purged when they did everything else." A combination of the endowment effect and inertia/status quo bias. When a Big Medicine lobbyist shows long government wait lines, that can be as effective, and as insidiously misleading, as a picture of immigrants waiting to gain admission to the country.