3 ms·
I do not believe we should interfere with the market when it's working. The fact that gig economy companies can get away with paying people less than minimum w
by reaperducer 7y ago
I do not believe we should interfere with the market when it's working.
The fact that gig economy companies can get away with paying people less than minimum wage shows that it's not working.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd the fact that people who want to stay freelance can't shows that government involvement in the free market and taking away people's right to choose how they want to work doesn't work either.
- reaperducer 7y agoVox is still free to hire freelancers, but it has to treat them as freelancers the same way every traditional media outlet does. Vox shouldn't get a magic unicorn pass because it's digital.
- scarface74 7y agoWhy should the government get in the middle between people who want to freelance at a rate they negotiate and Vox? Both sides have intelligent adults.
- reaperducer 7y agoWhy should the government get in the middle between people who want to freelance at a rate they negotiate and Vox? Because we, as a society, decided decades ago that this is important to do for the good of the nation and that's why it was codified into law.
- scarface74 7y agoWell, society also decided at various points that government should ban interracial marriage, same sex marriage and make consensual intercourse between two adults of the same sex illegal. You’ll have to excuse me if I don’t think that we should celebrate giving the government more power over what consenting adults are allowed to do when it doesn’t invade another person’s rights.
- sundaeofshock 7y agoThe market wouldn’t exist without the government. Who do you think introduces and enforced the rules around it? The government added new rules to the market. Some players like those rules: some don’t.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd instead of letting adults exercise their free will, we need the government to "protect them"?
- kelnos 7y agoWell, yes. Do you think laws around making anti-compete clauses illegal shouldn't exist? Do you reject the notion of the minimum wage? Do you think we shouldn't have required unemployment insurance payments? Do you think we should allow companies to put onerous, life-threatening terms in contracts? Do you think we should allow companies to force workers to sign contracts banning union membership? If you answered "yes" to these, then I expect people like you and people like me will fundamentally never have a productive discussion about this, as our values just don't match up.
- scarface74 7y agoWell, yes. Do you think laws around making anti-compete clauses illegal shouldn't exist? No, at a certain level, if you are a highly compensated employee, you should be able to negotiate that you won't compete with your employer for x months after you leave the company in exchange for a certain amount of money. Do you reject the notion of the minimum wage? I reject the concept of a "livable wage". It's not the market's responsibility to provide a "livable wage" since that varies based on your situation -- a teenager staying at home vs a single mom with three kids. The "safety net" is the responsibility of government. That was the original thought behind the Earned Income Tax Credit, disability, etc. Do you think we shouldn't have required unemployment insurance payments? No, I should be able to negotiate that I want to be a 1099 employee (and I have) and know that I won't get UI in exchange for a higher hourly rate to allow me to "self insure". Do you think we should allow companies to force workers to sign contracts banning union membership? What I do outside of company's time is none of their business. However, if they pay me enough in exchange for me not being in a union (which I wouldn’t want anyway), sure I’ll take the money. If I don’t want the government coming in between negotiations between myself and my potential employer, why in the heck would I want a union? Free will is great isn't it?
- NathanKP 7y agoThe point is that there are also a few hundred people not working now, because their gig jobs were cut. At best its a zero sum game: fewer people make more money now. At worst its a net loss: the company saves money by eliminating a lot of positions and those few lucky union workers make more money individually but collectively they make less total money than the gig workers did before.
- keenmaster 7y agoEven the most left-leaning studies show that the hourly wage, taking into account all expenses (including depreciation) and basic healthcare, is around $9.50 per hour. If you have another job, that number goes up and Uber becomes much more lucrative, because you can target surge pricing in your free time. Other empirical studies show that Uber/Lyft drivers forego wages for the flexibility of Uber. It's a tradeoff that many are clearly willing to make, and Californian politicians are wagging their finger and telling them that they're being fooled.
- kelnos 7y agoPretty sure we've already decided as a state that the minimum livable wage is $15/hr, so $9.50 doesn't cut it. Are there stats on how many Uber drivers have a second job vs. for how many it's their primary source of income. Regardless, I reject the notion that someone should be required to hold down more than one job in order to make ends meet. If they like to have more than one job, and the total hours work out to something reasonable, sure, but my impression of this is that we see people working multiple jobs out of necessity, at significantly north of 40 hours per week, and are still living paycheck-to-paycheck.
- keenmaster 7y agoI was referring to the low end of nationwide estimates. Average earnings in California must be higher. Also: - As of 2015, 69% of Uber drivers drove for Uber on the side. - 97% were satisfied with the flexibility of their schedule - 16% drove for a set amount of time, as opposed to setting an earnings goal or "it just depends on my schedule" - 50% drive fewer than 10 hours a week, on average AB5 throws a wrench in all of that. The trend from 2014-2015 was towards more flexible workers, so the above numbers may have gone up since then. Source: Benenson Strategy Group, as shared via USA Today https://bit.ly/2PyO1uq https://bit.ly/2PyO1uq
- tengbretson 7y agoAn alternative theory would be that the concept of a minimum wage is not working.