4 ms·
Interesting that for the 2007 financial crisis, you only had to wait until early 2012 to make up your loses. Even for the crash of the early 1930's, after 8 ye
by refurb 7y ago
Interesting that for the 2007 financial crisis, you only had to wait until early 2012 to make up your loses.
Even for the crash of the early 1930's, after 8 years you were back to where you were.
- kp98 7y agoThat would be the massive amount of QE & money injected into the system. I doubt next recession it will be so simple to sell the bonds we need to to run a massive QU campaign again
- foota 7y agoHasn't the Fed mostly rollbed back the QE by selling off the assets they bought?
- pjmorris 7y agoLooking at Fed total assets [0], the Fed's sold off only a fraction of what it took on during the crisis and QE. [0] Fed total assets from FRED: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL
- foota 7y agoWow, no kidding. I wonder how the mix has changed? Obviously I was wondering about overall going down, but I seem to recall there being like a change of short for long term assets or something?
- kp98 7y agoThe fed purchased long term assets like mortgage backed securities to provide liquidity and relief to corporations that held too much bad debt on their balance sheets. This provided immediate relief for distressed institutions. The fed also expanded the balance sheet by selling long term bonds, which offered relatively lower rates in comparison to short term notes and bills, this provided the cash infusion needed for QE to stimulate the economy.
- kp98 7y agoThe fed’s balance sheet went from roughly 4 t down to I think ? 3.5 T and now it’s ramping up again at the top of cycle + lending hundreds of billions a month to banks in the repo markets. Given the pace we’re going at now I doubt we’ll be able to sustain the pace in a recession
- throwaway2048 7y agoThat discounts businesses that collapse entirely, or under-preform enough to exit the index market. Indexes are misleading because they have a strong survivor bias. Stocks that slipped out of the S&P 500 entirely no longer register, but the money you had in them sure does. https://seekingalpha.com/article/207935-is-there-survivorship-bias-in-index-performance https://seekingalpha.com/article/207935-is-there-survivorshi... I'd like to see the S&P performance of then current index stocks over the same time period, im guessing it would be significantly worse.
- faitswulff 7y agoWhat happens to your money if you invest in an index fund and companies drop out of the index?
- stefano 7y agoWhen a company drops out of the index, the fund sells all its shares in it and buys shares of the new company that took its place.
- xxxtentachyon 7y agoBut it should be said that the price that the fund manages to sell the shares at could be far lower than the price at the time the company exited the index since many funds and others will be trying to get out at the same time.
- hash872 7y agoSo wait, is throwaway2048 correct that this type of analysis misses companies who dropped out? Or are the gross return numbers including selling the shares of 'leaving the index' companies at a loss? I would imagine the latter and so his point is wrong, but I'm open to being corrected
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]