4 ms·
If an industry can only exist if it exploits its workers and leaves them destitute then that isn't an industry we should be celebrating. A lot of people are ca
by jandrese 7y ago
If an industry can only exist if it exploits its workers and leaves them destitute then that isn't an industry we should be celebrating. A lot of people are calling this unintended consequences, but this seems like one of the goals of the law. It sucks for the workers that they'll have to find new jobs, but at least their new jobs (if they can find them) are guaranteed to be less abusive.
- corebit 7y agoIf those jobs existed then workers would already have found them.
- Retric 7y agoThese jobs do exist, their simply done by ‘contractors’. When every stripper is classified as a contractor, if they state says they must use employees then the strip joint is going to close or swap paper work. That’s the only option, they can simply drop all contractors without any other change.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoRight! This is twisting Capitals arm to pay the “true” cost of the labor it needs. ‘Cause if they didn’t need it, there wouldn’t have been contractors doing the job in the first place. I am extremely satisfied to see labor rights advocacy making a comeback.
- bpt3 7y agoHow is this "true" cost calculated?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoFully loaded cost of employees vs pushing the costs onto the “contractor”.
- bpt3 7y agoIn my field, contractors make more than employees, even after accounting for benefits, because the employers prefer the flexibility and are willing to pay a premium for it.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe jobs only exist if they're creating more value than it costs to hire someone. If you raise the cost of hiring someone, some of the jobs go away, either because the company folds or because it lets go some of the workers and dumps their workload on the remaining ones (who now can't quit because it's harder to find another job), or cancels shifts that had been only marginally profitable. This typically has the greatest impact on the least productive workers who have the most trouble finding another job, especially when the same requirements are imposed on all local employers.
- jandrese 7y agoIf the jobs go away who is doing the work the person was previously doing? Were they being hired unnecessarily because they were cheap, or are they going to make the remaining employees work twice as hard to cover all of the jobs? Or is stuff going to fall through the cracks. Aren't the number of jobs needed more dependent on the demand for your product than the price of hiring employees? It's like the fallacy of supply side economics: people are hired to fill demand, not because it's cheap to hire them. Now more expensive labor can make your end product more expensive which can reduce demand for it and cost jobs, but that's a second order effect and should be muted if everybody is affected by the same laws at once. The people who really get hurt are the ones competing with sweat shop slave labor in foreign countries, but most of those jobs are already gone and lazy Americans weren't willing to work 100 hour weeks for pennies anyway so competing fairly against them was Quixotic in the first place.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> If the jobs go away who is doing the work the person was previously doing? Nobody. You used to have two shifts, one that made a lot of money because it was peak hours and one that you could justify with a lower labor cost but not anymore. So now there's one shift and the business has shorter operating hours. > Were they being hired unnecessarily because they were cheap, or are they going to make the remaining employees work twice as hard to cover all of the jobs? Or is stuff going to fall through the cracks. Well yes, that's exactly what can happen. Stuff falling through the cracks has a cost. If the cost is more than the cost of hiring someone to prevent it, you do. If the cost of hiring someone goes up, the cost of the problems may now be less than what you have to pay someone to prevent it. > Aren't the number of jobs needed more dependent on the demand for your product than the price of hiring employees? A job exists when it creates more value than it costs to hire someone. If the value it creates stays the same and the cost to hire someone goes up, some of the jobs move to the other side of the line and disappear. You're basically assuming that all jobs at all companies have the same margins. The high margin jobs will stay but the low margin jobs don't. "Low margin jobs suck anyway" is little consolation to the people whose alternative is even worse. And if you gave them a better alternative then they would choose it even if you hadn't prohibited the worse one. > Now more expensive labor can make your end product more expensive which can reduce demand for it and cost jobs, but that's a second order effect and should be muted if everybody is affected by the same laws at once. If everybody is affected by the same laws at once it makes it easier to raise prices because your competitors have to do the same thing. But raising prices still reduces overall demand. And in many cases the competitors aren't affected because they're in other jurisdictions, and then raising prices really reduces demand in your jurisdiction because people just buy from the competitors whose prices haven't gone up. > The people who really get hurt are the ones competing with sweat shop slave labor in foreign countries, but most of those jobs are already gone and lazy Americans weren't willing to work 100 hour weeks for pennies anyway so competing fairly against them was Quixotic in the first place. That's just a lazy rationalization. It's the people at the margin who get hurt, but that doesn't mean they don't exist or that they don't get hurt.
- appleshore 7y agoLA and SF are both dominated by workers who can’t afford the products/services offered by the businesses they work at. Not high-end businesses, just regular places.
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoThis was done as a do-gooder bill and not something that actually took into account the wellbeing of freelance journalists. Suppose I'm a journalist that specializes in recreational fishing for a particular region. Not only am I a journalist of what happens locally by keeping my ear to the ground, but I'm also an SME of both the types of fishing being done and also of the areas to fish and the conditions in which they bite. How easy do you think it would be for a person like that to get a full-time paying gig somewhere with benefits? Probably very hard. But a person like that can make a decent living for himself by writing for fishing magazines, sports magazines, outdoor journals, newspapers, etc. Not only does it limit opportunities for a writer like this, but it also diminishes the overall quality of all publications in an area. Because now he can't be that expert on one topic, he probably has to straddle a half-dozen fences in order to justify his continued employment. I think that this is a unique situation among vocations and it's a shame that the politicians didn't listen to the people actually being affected.
- tssva 7y agoThere is nothing in the law that would require said journalist to become a full-time employee. The said journalist could continue to produce content for as many publications as they like on a freelance basis. If they were to produce more than 35 in a year for one particular publication they would have to become a part time employee for that publication which would not have to limit their ability to still work freelance for other publications or if need be become a part time employee for another publication. If the journalist produced regular content regarding current fishing conditions they could offer the content as syndicated content to multiple publications and those would not fall under the 35 work limit.
- dimator 7y agoNot to mention that this works out to almost 3 fishing articles per month. I would wager that that kind of throughput for fishing articles is already very rare.
- ghaff 7y agoI certainly know freelance writers who have been doing it for a long time and they don't consider their jobs abusive. Some of them even have pretty well-known names within their areas of coverage. There is also certainly a lot of really poorly paid piecework in a lot of places but freelancers in media actually have a lot of history behind them that long pre-dates the "gig economy."
- jandrese 7y agoIf the freelancers aren't around who is going to write the articles? Or is journalism just going to give up and die? Or maybe we'll instead only get corporate written propaganda pieces masquerading as citizen journalism from people pulling down a steady paycheck.
- ghaff 7y agoOf course freelancers aren't the only ones being cut. There is no shortage of stories about newsroom staffs being massively cut too. So, yes, with a small number of (mostly national/global/specialty) exceptions, there's far less news coverage requiring significant legwork and story development, especially at the local level. I live in a fairly small town and there's basically no coverage of town events since a sort of labor love small newspaper shut down a number of years ago when the publisher got ill. The business models are tough and you see it here when every story from a paywalled source is posted and someone posts a way to bypass the paywall. (But paywalls are tough too. I subscribe to The NYT and The Economist but that's probably about my limit. And most people don't even do that much.)
- faet 7y agoThe issue is many industries don't have any exemptions. You can write 35 articles for a company before you need to be hired. There is no exemption for musicians. Say your drummer is sick and your band is performing. You'll need to hire that drummer as an employee for the 2hour gig. Or said drummer will need to pay Cali $800/yr to form an LLC and perform contract work. Music venue? Same thing. Either hire the performers as employees or the band needs to form an LLC and pay cali $800/yr.
- rchaud 7y agoWouldn't a drummer just be paid cash for a one-off 2-hour gig? The music industry isn't exactly renowned for ethical accounting and there is no union for session drummers that would enforce the rule you're describing.
- mrkstu 7y agoThen the venue is opening itself to legal liability when any of the past drummers decide to sue.
- gamblor956 7y agoIf you can't afford $800/year, you don't have a business. You have a hobby.
- mlindner 7y agoGreat, you now just cut the bottom rungs off the ladder of how people turn their hobby into a business. The higher the start up cost the less likely they exist in the first place. This is about harming the poor in favor of the rich and nothing else. "Let them eat Cake" ring any bells?
- UncleEntity 7y agoMy bro-in-law has been quite happily doing piecemeal editing work for at least 15 years after his old job got killed by the internets. If he has to get a "real" job then he'll have to do something he probably won't like as much because the internets -- which is highly likely as he's in California and lives somewhere there aren't a whole lot of jobs.