5 ms·
> The $2.93 trillion that the New York Fed will funnel to Wall Street over the next month consists of up to $120 billion each weekday in overnight loans through
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
> The $2.93 trillion that the New York Fed will funnel to Wall Street over the next month consists of up to $120 billion each weekday in overnight loans through January 14 and $440 billion in term loans ranging from 3-days to 32 days.
We're talking about an overnight loan of $120 billion (that is, a loan that is paid back the next morning, lent again the next night, paid back in the morning, etc. This article is treating it as a cumulative loan - that is, the second day, it's now $240 billion (never mind that the first $120 billion has been paid back by then), and the third day it's $360 billion (never mind that the first $240 billion has been paid back by then).
That's either incredibly stupid, or propaganda. My money is on propaganda.
- corporate_shi11 7y agoExcept it's not all overnight now. >"The $2.93 trillion that the New York Fed will funnel to Wall Street over the next month consists of up to $120 billion each weekday in overnight loans through January 14 and $440 billion in term loans ranging from 3-days to 32 days."
- wmf 7y agoSo that's still only $560B, right? It's not $2.93T.
- me_me_me 7y agoyes, only.
- cheald 7y agoThe point, more broadly, is that these are loans with a quick expiry baked in. The money comes into and poofs out of existence on a relatively short timescale (ranging from overnight to a couple of weeks); we aren't going to see an extra ~$3T in circulation. They're providing lubrication in the repo markets, they aren't just shoveling cash into the banks' vaults. Most people misunderstand this point when discussing repo operations, so it's worth emphasizing.
- thisisnotmyname 7y agoWhat happens if banks systematically are unable to pay these loans back?
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>What happens if banks systematically are unable to pay these loans back? And how would that happen exactly? But if it did, the Fed would extend the loan, or loan more. Not very complicated.
- bendbro 7y agoSo it's not a loan
- quickthrowman 7y agoThe lender holds the collateral for the duration of the repo loan...
- powowow 7y agoThe fed holds US treasury bonds as collateral. Would you be worried about default if you loaned me a million dollars, and I gave you a million dollars of treasuries as collateral? It blows my mind that people are getting all worried about fully collateralized short term interbank lending.
- me_me_me 7y agoMiddle class can handle that, they already have a lot of experience with this. Better to leave it up to them to clean that mess up.
- Bjartr 7y agoSo I guess then the question to ask becomes "Is there a point at which these short-term loans become problematic, and if so, what are the signs it's hit that point, and what are the consequences of failing to stop that point from being reached?"
- 7y ago
- irln 7y agoClearly you could read the headline as sensational. However, if you look at the fed balance sheet, it has increased significantly recently. [1] The increase in the balance sheet has been in overnight or short term repos. The question remains whether this will result in a longer term FR policy. That is, even though the maturity of the loans are overnight, if the policy remains for years than the cumulative effect is that the the longer term balance sheet has increased. [1] https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/ https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/
- qroshan 7y agoWelcome to HN, where the articles are never about hacking, but raging, virtue signaling and pitch-forking in a filter bubble they have created. Look at all the articles on the front page today. How many are improving your true hacker skills and how many are brain-washing your way of thinking?
- jstewartmobile 7y agoIf it is propaganda, who does it serve? And BTW, where's my $120B overnight loan?
- ww520 7y agoWhen you have $120B asset, the FED will gladly lend you the money. These are collateralized loans.
- MichaelApproved 7y ago"asset" Who values what the asset is worth? That was the key issue with the 2008 crash. Banks were making up what the assets were worth and rating agencies were rubber stamping them. When the music stopped, people realized those assets were garbage.
- quickthrowman 7y agoRepo loans are secured with US Treasuries and Agency Debt, which are priced by market participants as “risk-free” assets due to the creditworthiness of the US Government. Treasuries are the most highly liquid securities in the world. There are no toxic assets involved in the repo market.
- NovemberWhiskey 7y agoThe only things that are eligible for the Fed repo operations are Treasury securities, agency direct obligations (i.e. other US Govt debt that's not in the form of a Treasury) and mortgage-backed securities issued by Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac/etc.
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>When the music stopped, people realized those assets were garbage. They weren't "garbage"; they were worth less than expected at the time they needed to be liquidated. This caused major problems (obviously), and it's precisely why the Fed stepped in to provide liquidity. Many of those so-called garbage assets turned out to be great investments.
- dopamean 7y agoI cant get to the article right now but is this not just how commercial paper works?
- panarky 7y agoAlternate headline, equally true: "Wall Street Banks Will Funnel $2.93T to the New York Fed over the Next Month"
- NovemberWhiskey 7y agoThat's either incredibly stupid, or propaganda. My money is on propaganda. It seems every single article on that entire site (wallstreetonparade.com) is one part relevant fact, then one part unrelated fact with plenty of innuendo to invite you to draw spurious linkages between those. There's a fantastic amount of noise that various large banks are major shareholders of the NY Fed, for example. This despite the fact that being a shareholder of one of the Federal Reserve Banks gives no control over it; or that being a shareholder is effectively required by law. The overwhelmingly vast majority of Fed 'profits' are required by law to be returned to the Treasury rather than distributed as dividends. Similarly there's a lot of hullaballoo that James Gorman (CEO Morgan Stanley) is on the board of directors, despite the fact his bank is overseen by the NY Fed. OK, sure, but Class A directors (elected by the banks, and required to be bank representatives!) are only a third of the board and cannot participate in regulatory decisions.
- snarf21 7y agoEveryone should go listen to Bloomberg's Odd Lots podcast. They have lots of recent episodes that dive into repo markets very clearly. tl;dr Banks have money in the Fed that they normally loan each other over night. This is mostly money they are keeping in reserve. At quarterly period ends, taxes and other payments are due so the big banks can't provide the same amount of repo loans so the Fed steps in to do the lending instead. Non story, click bait.
- thomaskcr 7y agoThey're subsidizing risk in a cumulative manner. When you hold things on your books you're subject to overnight risk (i.e. a big move can happen when there is no liquidity to move something because markets are closed). This can be managed by position sizing, hedging, repo ops, etc. If you have ~~unlimited~~ consistently increasing/available, government provided repo money available, you get to take more risks and don't need to buy other forms of insurance. So there is some cumulative impact to argue the point, but like you said it's not the sum of the loans. That said, I don't think this bodes well if you're in the camp that thinks the bigger the bubble the bigger the pop.