3 ms·
I bought a home and the previous owner used Z-Wave for everything. The whole thing worked irregardless of internet working or not. Whatever they invent if it is
by giancarlostoro 7y ago
I bought a home and the previous owner used Z-Wave for everything. The whole thing worked irregardless of internet working or not. Whatever they invent if it is useless without internet access its a step back from something that has already worked.
All my home automation / smart home integrations will have to be Z Wave compatible or I will not use it. If my internet goes out will all my things be useless without it?
- ogre_codes 7y agoFirst, personally my philosophy is to have any smart home type stuff have a dumb backup. You never know what might happen to your smart hub or whatever so having physical switched lights/ appliances is important. Second, hopefully this doesn't come across as patronizing but based on your post it sounds like you aren't sure about this. IP is not "The Internet". You can have your own little private IP network which runs without the internet. If this is an open standard there should at least be the option to create a local only hub which only requires your local network is online. That's not guaranteed considering who is backing this project, but it should be possible.
- what_ever 7y agoJust a nit - it's regardless not irregardless.
- Lendal 7y agoZ-wave takes less time to get working and once it does it stays working. I've bought Wifi switches that worked for as little as 2-3 months before dying. I've never had a Z-wave device die. Zigbee maybe be open but if it can't penetrate walls then it's just not worth the hassle.
- delfinom 7y agoSadly, the lunatics at Amazon, Apple and Google live in their tech company campuses where internet is vast and plentiful. 99% of the country however has shit internet. Among many many other reasons.
- akvadrako 7y agoZigbee works fine without internet. And Z-wave is proprietary - only one company makes the controllers.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoI didn't realize Z-Wave was proprietary. It is useful though, I can control things around my house with a USB adapter and a Rasbperry Pi.