8 ms·
The hardest aspect of learning English as a second language
- tomcooks 7y agoRelated https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghoti https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghoti
- jcranmer 7y agoBut English pronunciation rules are regular enough to be able to say that "ghoti" should be pronounced "GO-tee". Word-initial "gh" is always pronounced as a hard g. The argument that "o" can be pronounced /ı/ comes from a vowel reduction rule in unstressed syllables. And pronouncing "ti" as /ʃ/ comes from the yod-coalescence that fricatizes /t/, /d/, /z/, and /s/ in certain cases, namely where the previous syllable ends in one of those consonants and the next one begins with a /j/ ("y") sound. Since "ti" is word final here, there's nothing to fricatize it. English spelling does have quite a few rules, and it follows them far more than people realize. The main real problem is our proclivity to borrow foreign words and insist on using foreign spelling and pronunciation for them. The other main issue is that we conserved the spelling of English from Middle English, so you have to map the pronunciation shifts to spelling rules--and some words ended up being weird exceptions to the pronunciation shifts (e.g., "father" went in a different direction from the other "-ather" words, like "lather" and "rather").
- kwhitefoot 7y ago>(e.g., "father" went in a different direction from the other "-ather" words, like "lather" and "rather"). In my dialect (north eastern corner of the West Country) all three sound the same except for the initial. Otherwise I agree with everything you said.
- josefrichter 7y agoNah, it's a small quirk, but it exists in many other languages. Phrasal verbs are the real trap. Keep up, keep off, keep out, keep on, keep out,... Rather uncommon in other languages and very easy to make mistake, sometimes very embarrassing one..
- xpil 7y agoMy words exactly. There's over 3000 phrasal verbs in English and memorizing them is pain in the hole (plus it makes no sense). The only effective way of learning them is to submerge yourself in the language by listening to plenty of audiobooks or moving abroad where English is spoken natively. I'm Polish myself and hit a hard wall with phrasals when I moved over to Ireland 13 years ago. I still keep discovering new ones every now and then despite living here for over a decade.
- StavrosK 7y agoI managed to learn the pronunciation and phrasal verbs, but prepositions still get me from time to time...
- V-2 7y agoWe kind of do the same thing, only in the form of prefixes (podać, wydać, zdać, zadać, oddać, poddać, nadać, przydać etc. and on and on it goes). Ultimately it boils down to the same thing - little syllabic bits altering the meaning of the verb.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoYes, It's exactly the same in German. So I guess I don't agree with this comment thread at all - It's just learning vocabulary. I never felt like this is a specific problem when learning English. I much more agree with the article: Spelling + pronunciation is just fubar and the greatest annoyance.
- josefrichter 7y agoYou are right, didn't realize we do the same in most Slavic languages and it's common in German too. It just always seemed to me that it's much more common in English. But I have no numbers to support that, so I might be completely wrong.
- ramblerman 7y ago> The only effective way of learning them is to submerge yourself in the language by listening to plenty of audiobooks or moving abroad where English is spoken natively. That's the only way to learn the quirks and idioms of any language really.
- Avalaxy 7y agoMandatory: English can be weird. It can be understood through tough thorough thought, though.
- tsukurimashou 7y agoit all depends from which language you're coming from, some will have it easy, some will have it hard, on different things
- StavrosK 7y agoNot really. Nobody will find English pronunciation/spelling easy, unless they're coming from English.
- sheepdestroyer 7y agoComing from French. I find English spelling easy. I mainly learnt by myself, reading stuff on internet and books. Could not care less about correct pronunciation though, and I have the thickest 'cliché' french accent. But which of the native English accents would be the correct one anyway? So I decided to consider mine not worse than any. H does not exist by the way.
- StavrosK 7y agoI'm not sure what you mean, you seem to conflate pronunciation and accent. How do you pronounce "bow", "tear" and "row"? When you say you find spelling easy, you mean you find it easy to spell an unknown word when you hear it? Because I'd really like to see that.
- sheepdestroyer 7y agoNot sure if the distinction between accent and pronunciation is very relevant here? I have a particular/personal 'French' accent that heavily influences the way I pronounce words. As stated, it mainly comes from the way I learnt : I often straight up applied french pronunciation (but with some basic informed knowledge of what could be the proper way) to what I read. So, to answer your examples, I pronounce those exactly like the french "beau", "tire" and "rot". For me, English has been a mostly literary language for years with most spoken forms coming to me with simultaneous subtiles. So, it's rare that I encounter a new spoken word that I haven't read before, but with time and familiarity you develop some kind of heuristics I guess (and enough of English comes from French that there is no need to be too lucky). I now live in Japan and used to guide, in English, foreign tourists in Kyoto. Amusingly only native speakers seemed to sometimes have difficulties to understand my strange pronunciation/accent.
- cgriswald 7y agoTLDR: Similarly spelled words are pronounced differently, like in an old Gallagher bit: https://youtu.be/X74j1wK_sa0 https://youtu.be/X74j1wK_sa0
- krige 7y agothat's small time. even identically spelled words are pronounced differently, see polish (shoe polish) / Polish (nationality)
- StavrosK 7y agoEven worse are bow, row, lead, etc. English is crazy.
- ColinWright 7y agoOr entrance versus entrance, alternate versus alternate, refuse versus refuse, and more. Edit: Sorry, I should perhaps not leave that hanging. These depend on your emphasis. More specifically: * en-TRANCE (hypnotise) versus EN-trance (doorway); * AL-ternate (switch between) versus al-TER-nate (the other thing); * re-FUSE (to decline) versus RE-fuse (rubbish). Not to mention the multiple meanings of "lead", "set", "row", "bow", and more.
- saiya-jin 7y agoMeh, try learning french in your late 30s from 0 as your 4th (actually 5th) language. Of course the goal is not some basic grocery-shopping level but fluency and all the quirks that come with it.
- bausano_michael 7y agoUnfortunately this experiment excludes several groups from participating. Those past late 30s who didn't learn French as 4th/5th language, those knowing more than 4/5 languages, those who learned French as their 2nd or 3rd language, and French.
- saiya-jin 7y agoNobody said it would be easy to achieve, i am still in the process of getting there. Its more about that such things are in possibly all languages out there, this is normal. Definitely all I've encountered so far. Plus you forgot all other french-native speakers other than French nationals, which are much more numerous than French themselves.
- bausano_michael 7y agoThat is very true, I forgot about native speakers who aren't French! Good spot.
- musicale 7y agoFrench seems equally terrible - are there spelling bees in France? In any case, I shall blame French (and William the Conqueror) for much of the madness of modern English spelling.
- dublin 7y agoAnd of course, this granddaddy of all gripes on English punctuation, which was written 100 years ago now: https://www.learnenglish.de/pronunciation/pronunciationpoem.html https://www.learnenglish.de/pronunciation/pronunciationpoem.... (This link was chosen because it has audio links for each section of verse. The German speaker doesn't nail the pronunciation of all the words, but gets very close, to the point that most differences are possibly a matter of regional dialect.)
- vidanay 7y agoThis is interesting...while reading this line of the poem: "Tear in eye, your dress will tear." I could physically feel my brain rewinding and re-defining the leading "Tear" when I encountered "in eye". (I am a native speaker of American)
- StavrosK 7y agoThat's why garden-path sentences are easier in English, I guess.
- mlboss 7y agoProblem is English is not a phonetic language. There is not much you can do with only 26 characters. In my native language you pronounce what you wrote.
- digitalsushi 7y agoI feel like if we had rules in place from the start, we could do everything with half as many characters.
- bluGill 7y agoActually we need twice as manager characters, but we would need a lot less in any given words. Even decided Capital and lower case were different letters not different ways to write the same letter we would still need more symbols. However that wouldn't help either. As a Mid-westerner I pronounce "about" differently from someone from Boston (they do something like a-boat). We no longer can reform spelling unless we also reform pronunciation as well.
- MagnumOpus 7y agoGerman or Spanish manage to have extremely divergent dialects while still having phonetic spelling of the standard written dialect.
- StavrosK 7y agoThere are phonetic (or near-phonetic) languages that use 26 (or fewer) characters. Spanish comes to mind.
- hellofunk 7y agoHa! The number of letters has nothing to do with it, as evidenced by maaaany other languages that are phonetic with no more letters.
- dundercoder 7y ago"Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo" is a correct sentence in American English[0] [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_buffalo_Buffalo_buffalo_buffalo_buffalo_Buffalo_buffalo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_buffalo_Buffalo_buffal...
- bjourne 7y agoHow come the English never tried for a spelling reform? Such reforms were implemented both in Sweden and Germany to simplify spelling. Like the article says, bear really should be spelled bair.
- jcranmer 7y agoWe have tried spelling reform, at least a dozen times. They tend not to stick, however, perhaps in large part because radical changes that impact the spelling of nearly every single word tend to engender a lot of resistance. Smaller changes (such as changing hiccough to hiccup in American English, or through to thru) are more successful.
- gruez 7y agoGood luck getting the Americans, Canadians, British, Indians, and Australians to all agree on something.
- jsolson 7y agoI mean, we already disagree on spelling for some words, the name for the letter 'Z', and what to call dwellings in multi-family properties, so we're not off to a great start...
- bjourne 7y agoWhen the German spelling reform was enacted in the German Empire in 1902, German was spoken in many countries outside of it. In fact, it rivaled English as the Lingua franca for the scientific world.
- the_svd_doctor 7y agoMaybe because English doesn’t have a “central authority” as opposed to for instance French with the Academie Francaise? That makes reforms difficult/impossible.
- StavrosK 7y agoI disagree, "bear" should be spelled "bear" and "air" should be spelled "ear". "Ear" should be spelled "iar". Basically, a phonetic alphabet.
- mumblemumble 7y agoForvo can help with this. Recorded pronunciations for words and phrases, crowdsourced from native speakers, with information about their gender and home region. (Useful for fine-tuning your pronunciation and intonation.) It has an app, and, if you're the flashcarding type, the website lets you download MP3s. Beyond that, I think all I can offer in consolation is that English orthography does have an internal logic; there are guidelines you can use to tell when "ea" is pronounced /ɪ/ and when it's pronounced /ɛə/ or /e/. It's all subtle enough that it's useless to try to actually learn them - thinking about that stuff will just slow you down, which is worse than making the occasional pronunciation error. But, over time, you will develop an instinct for it, and it will all eventually start feeling natural. Same for stress accent.
- dqv 7y agoPronunciation consistency is pretty important too. "I deer you to slap the beer" does make sense because both /ɛr/s (?) have been remapped to /ɪr/s (?)
- Grue3 7y agoIt's definitely not the hardest aspect. Just learn each word and its pronounciation independently. The spelling is just a mnemonic. If you can remember the gender of each word in your native language, or where the stressed syllable is, you can remember how to pronounce each English word as well. For me the hardest part is using articles (the/a/none) which don't exist in my native language. I still don't understand the exact rules of their usage and usually just insert whichever article sounds the best.
- mumblemumble 7y agoFor what it's worth, that's how native English speakers deal with articles, too.
- zeveb 7y agoAmusingly, in my dialect 'ear' is pronounced like 'eer', not like 'EE-ur.'
- nkrisc 7y agoAmerican Southeast?
- AlphaGeekZulu 7y agoThe Chaos Of English Pronunciation by Gerard Nolst Trenité: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1edPxKqiptw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1edPxKqiptw
- ubermonkey 7y agoLately, my favorite comments about English as a second language come from Finnish comedian Ismo, regarding his take on the most complicated word in the English language: Ass. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAGcDi0DRtU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAGcDi0DRtU (Reasonably SFW; the set is from a normal TV talk show.)
- jscholes 7y agoI think the most difficult aspect of learning English depends on (A) the learner and (B) the goal. If your aim is to learn the language to a sufficient degree that you can handle business customers at an upscale hotel in a non-English speaking country, you're going to have different concerns to somebody trying to emigrate to and fit in with a community in the north of England.
- Balanceinfinity 7y agoOne of the anomalies of English is the spelling bee. I can't really speak any other language, but I've been told that the idea of such a bee in most languages wouldn't make any sense because everything is spelled - if not exactly how it sounds - then with a consistency that makes the spelling simple. Here, all we have (even for English speakers) is brute force memorization. If you don't know how vacuum is spelled, then good luck guessing.
- musicale 7y agoI concur on spelling being the Achilles' heel of English. We actually subject children to contests ("Spelling Bees") in which they must spell English words without recourse to automated correction or a dictionary. Because native speakers commit spelling (along with typographical and grammatical) errors so frequently, automated spelling and grammar checkers are an essential feature of word processors and text entry systems. Dyslexia seems to be more common among English speakers vs. speakers of more phonetic languages. I doubt spelling is a competitive sport in saner languages, though I imagine that character writing (and reading) contests could be a thing in languages with large numbers of written characters. Like long division, both spelling and character recall can be delegated to technology, but I'm not sure what I think of this as a general principle. I use spelling checkers and I like phonetic character input methods, but I dislike grammar checkers.
- ColinWright 7y agoThat's fine until you need to distinguish between your/you're, to/too/two, their/they're/there, its/it's, and similar problems. Maybe people think it doesn't matter, or that it won't matter, but it always disrupts my flow when I see errors like that. Clear, effective communication is best when there are no, or at least very few, grammatical errors to distract the reader, and in the cases given above, and more, spell-checkers don't help.
- spaced-out 7y ago>That's fine until you need to distinguish between your/you're, to/too/two, their/they're/there, its/it's, and similar problems. Maybe people think it doesn't matter, or that it won't matter, but it always disrupts my flow when I see errors like that. That only matters to you because you were taught different spellings for those words. Consider the word 'read'; it's pronounced like 'reed' when used in the present tense, and like 'red' when used in the past tense, but spelled the same in either case. Does that disrupt your 'flow'? I'm willing to bet it doesn't, because you were taught the same spelling for both those words (and they are different words!) Now consider the word 'about'. It can mean 'almost', as in "I'm about to arrive", or it can me 'regarding', as in "This book is about...". If you were taught the 'regarding' definition of 'about' is spelled 'abowt', I'm sure you would have added 'about/abowt' next to 'to/too/two' as something that disrupts your flow when misused.
- 8bitsrule 7y agoOne of my favorites is the 'silent e'. Bear and bare. Pronounced the same. Bar, car. Bear care. And then there's the 'f' sound. Comes in many disguises. Fish, tough, cuff, cough, phone. Spanish, as a second language, is such a relief.
- RickJWagner 7y agoFrom childhood, the baffling 'ghoti'. It's pronounced 'fish' [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghoti https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghoti
- AtlasBarfed 7y agoSince english is so massive at this point with its absorption of so many other language subsets, has anyone ever tried to standardize a base vocabulary subset that matches a "bare minimum expression" of another language but selects words for consistent conjugation and pronunciation?