2 ms·
I'm 1 kyu. I don't have any problem winning against two 6 kyus (I saw some experiments like that in the past.) There are simply too many things they overlook.
by pmontra 7y ago
I'm 1 kyu. I don't have any problem winning against two 6 kyus (I saw some experiments like that in the past.) There are simply too many things they overlook.
And two 1 kyus (or a room of them) won't win against a 4 dan. We're playing different games.
What happens is that the weaker players become a little better at don't making reading mistakes and at finding possible moves. Unfortunately they don't get any better at evaluating moves and the unknown unknowns are still unknown. The better player finds moves that none of the weaker ones would think about or be able to explain.
I can imagine that the knowledge about the game of two 11 kyus have a smaller intersection than the ones of 6 kyus. This means they become much better together.
However two 1 kyu have about the same knowledge, so they could be at most 1 dan together, probably still 1 kyu.
- reagent_finder 7y ago1k as well here. I don't see it as much about knowledge of the game, more about avoiding mistakes and less pressure that lets you look at a game more in-depth. That, and two people will probably coalesce towards something like honte anyway. Add to this the player opposing is under pressure because he HEARS the discussion. Can he take advantage of knowing plans? Should he? I'd say this is a nice learning tool, and honestly, anything that keeps you interested and makes learning and playing a bit more fun is fantastic. I've played 5-in-a-row go, pair go, 3-player go, 1-colour go, 3D go and tried different board sizes like 38x38 or 19x19 infinite (sides 'joined'). I've never run across this variant! Seems fun! Making guesses about what a 2-player team's strength is is a losing proposition, though.
- jefftk 7y ago> Add to this the player opposing is under pressure because he HEARS the discussion. Can he take advantage of knowing plans? Should he? Since we knew the opposing player was listening we mostly didn't discuss plans, at least not in a way that would have hurt the plans. Mostly we suggested moves to each other, and pointed out problems with the other person's suggestions.