4 ms·
> A measurement process is mathematically speaking an operator which acts on the wave function in Copenhagen interpretation and the collapse of the wave functio
by lmm 7y ago
> A measurement process is mathematically speaking an operator which acts on the wave function in Copenhagen interpretation and the collapse of the wave function is a projection onto the eigenfunctions of this operator. What would you be missing here?
When and how does that projection (which is non-unitary and otherwise ill-behaved) happen? What causes it to occur or not occur? How do you explain the results of the quantum eraser experiment, where the exact same physical process retroactively turns out to constitute a measurement or not depending on what happens in the future?
> Besides that, there is one point I don’t get about many worlds and entanglement theories: assuming that “measurement is just entanglement”, there are many possibilities how the observer gets entangled with the wave function it observes. How is it decided which entanglement (or which world) is the one we actually observe?
No, there is only one possible way to get entangled with what you observe. If you observe a spin-half particle that's in state (1/sqrt(2))(|up> + |down>), then afterwards the you-photon system is in state (1/sqrt(2))(|up>|you after observing up> + |down>|you after observing down>), exactly as if you were a normal physical object obeying the normal laws of physics.
The question you can and should still ask is "what should we expect the subjective experience of being in this state to be like". And to a certain extent, why the Born rule applies is still something to be explained (though I'm not aware of any alternative possibilities that would be well-behaved). But that's a much smaller and simpler question.
- edna314 7y ago> What causes it to occur or not occur? Measurements cause it to occur. What causes entanglement to occur? > quantum eraser Not sure how it works, but Wikipedia says that it can be explained using Copenhagen carefully. > (1/sqrt(2))(|up>|you after observing up> + |down>|you after observing down>) After the measurement I’m not in a superposition of the two entangled states but in one of the two, because I do observe the photon in a particular spin state. Which one is it? And how is it decided?
- lmm 7y ago> Measurements cause it to occur. Ok, but what's the objective physical distinction between a measurement and a non-measurement? > What causes entanglement to occur? Various specific kinds of normal physical interactions, the details of which are an established part of QM. > After the measurement I’m not in a superposition of the two entangled states but in one of the two What would you expect to be different if you were in a superposition of two states? > I do observe the photon in a particular spin state Sure, because your state is entangled with its state. That's the normal, established behaviour of entangled states.
- edna314 7y ago> Ok, but what's the objective physical distinction between a measurement and a non-measurement? Various specific kinds of measuring devices the details of which are an established part of QM. > Various specific kinds of normal physical interactions, the details of which are an established part of QM. So, which is the interaction that causes entanglement? I was asking for this before. > What would you expect to be different if you were in a superposition of two states? Well, I would expect my measurement to also have all possible outcomes given by the superposition. > Sure, because your state is entangled with its state. That's the normal, established behaviour of entangled states. Only after a one of the entangled particles is measured. Either my brain must be measured or the result must be measured. In this sense entanglement doesn’t work without an ill defined concept of measurement either.
- lmm 7y ago> Various specific kinds of measuring devices the details of which are an established part of QM. They're not though. There's no generally accepted definition of what is and isn't a measuring device. And, as per the quantum eraser experiment, the exact same equipment might be considered as a measuring device or not a measuring device, depending on what happens in the future. > So, which is the interaction that causes entanglement? I was asking for this before. The only fully accurate answer is "look at the Schrodinger equation". But, broadly, interacting with an object in superposition in a way that depends on that superposition will cause entanglement. For example, if a particle's spin is in superposition, another particle interacting it in a spin-dependent way will cause entanglement, but interacting with it in a spin-independent way will not create an entanglement. I appreciate that this must sound exactly as vague as the definition of a measurement. But for those familiar with QM it really isn't. If you look at textbooks, even those written from a Copenhagenist point of view, they're very clear on which physical circumstances give rise to entanglement and which don't. If you go through any undergrad-level QM textbook you'll have a clear understanding of what entanglement is and isn't. > Well, I would expect my measurement to also have all possible outcomes given by the superposition. Ok, but what would the subjective experience of that look like? > Only after a one of the entangled particles is measured. Either my brain must be measured or the result must be measured. In this sense entanglement doesn’t work without an ill defined concept of measurement either. Not true. Just by looking at the wavefunction, one can see that the wavefunction is a superposition of two distinct Everett branches that don't interact with each other - not because of some mysterious "collapse" phenomenon, but just as an emergent property of that actual wavefunction. Finding yourself in one specific branch is somewhat mysterious, but each individual branch being consistent with itself and not interacting with any other branch is absolutely normal QM.