4 ms·
I think it's prioritizing aesthetic beauty over function. This style of map is not intended to be used as a walking guide or you would be correct. They are fo
by mellosouls 7y ago
I think it's prioritizing aesthetic beauty over function.
This style of map is not intended to be used as a walking guide or you would be correct.
They are for determining the simplest way of getting from station A to station B once you are on the train.
I think you are aware of that so representing the other "walking" world within this one is essentially breaking an axiom of that intent, like asking for a 2D map that represents 3 dimensions.
- braindeath 7y agoMaybe he is aware of the existing maps ... and as he states “this isn’t an improvement”. Since the current NYC maps serves both purposes astonishingly well.
- Atheros 7y agoBut our goal isn't to get to a different station- it's to get from our origin to our destination. Previous studies of how people try to navigate have shown that people make heavy use of landmarks like parks which is why the MTAs map shows parks and major streets. Passengers also take into account how the train feels to be moving which this map doesn't convey. If the train obviously feels to turn left but the map doesn't show it, passengers get anxious. His current map version: https://www.inat.fr/metro/new-york/ https://www.inat.fr/metro/new-york/ There are other problems with this map that demonstrate to me at least that the designer simply hasn't put as much thought into the design as the MTA. Some examples: - Suppose I am on the Lexington Ave line and I want to know if my train (a 4 train) will stop at Astor place. I see a dot but no labels. So I start searching down the map for what the dot means. Eventually two green lines becomes one green line. What does that mean? I give up and start scanning upward and see that one line is for the 4/5 and the other line is for the 6. I finally have my answer. The MTAs map just tells me what trains stop at Astor place. - This map implies that there are free transfers to the Path train when in fact there is not. - This map implies that I can transfer between the 8th and 7th ave lines at Penn Station when in fact I can not. - Is my Q train going to stop at 49th st in Manhattan? No one knows. That's just a minor design problem that was caused by a lack of space. The lack of space was caused by the designer's decision to illustrate lines individually.
- Sniffnoy 7y agoThe map doesn't seem to show the free out-of-system transfers between Inwood 207th St and the nearby 1 stops, either. Edit: Although oddly it does show the one between Lexington Ave/63rd St and Lexington Ave/59th St. Huh. I figured the designer just missed the existence of out-of-system transfers, but no, they just missed that particular set of them.
- jkaplowitz 7y agoI once had a routine subway commute in NYC that involved an out-of-system transfer walking between two nearby stations. Walking proximity is relevant info.
- codyb 7y agoBrooklyn near the Barclay’s center by chance? I always wondered how that works, you just swipe again and it doesn’t deduct if you got on a certain subset of the lines and then swipe at certain stops within some time period?
- jkaplowitz 7y agoThis transfer was elsewhere in downtown Brooklyn, closer to Brooklyn Heights, but yeah that's another likely place. Most such transfers would be billed as two fares if paying per ride, since only a few specific subway to subway transfers are officially free, but most people who routinely commute by subway have a monthly pass and don't need to care about that. (The monthly price is wisely set just slightly above the fares one would incur in a typical routine commute over a month, meaning anyone who makes a small handful of personal subway rides each month on top of a routine commute is financially better off buying the monthly pass.)
- jagger27 7y ago> A 2D map that represents 3 dimensions You mean like a topographical map?
- mellosouls 7y ago:) Yeah, that thought occurred to me as I was posting my comment, but the point remains that a functional principle is being broken by the request. Incidentally there are "walking maps", so it can be done - but it subverts the original intent and frankly I find them pretty unusable. http://content.tfl.gov.uk/walking-tube-map.pdf http://content.tfl.gov.uk/walking-tube-map.pdf But at this point, if you are looking for a multi-dimensional requirement maybe its best to use something more convenient, like CityMapper or similar apps. https://citymapper.com https://citymapper.com