2 ms·
Amazon wanted to open an office in New York--not exactly the heartland, but it does spread out the jobs a bit. But there was resistance and they cancelled the p
by fortran77 7y ago
Amazon wanted to open an office in New York--not exactly the heartland, but it does spread out the jobs a bit. But there was resistance and they cancelled the plan.
How can you "drag jobs" out? Government ordered migrations of people? Massive subsidies?
- bdcravens 7y agoSubsidies and incentives is the most practical answer, though that's always a political minefield.
- jorts 7y agoAmazon is opening a new office in NY by 2021, just without the huge tax breaks that they were originally pushing for. The tax breaks were the main reason that folks like AOC were pushing back against them opening a new headquarters in NY.
- corporateslave5 7y ago1500 people versus 25k. A huge loss for nyc. Also lost tax revenue for nyc and the state.
- poulsbohemian 7y agoIf Amazon believes it is in their best interest to be in NYC, then they will eventually grow to that 25K number regardless. There's a long track record across the country of companies demanding concessions in promise of jobs, only to have the jobs never materialize. In many cases, companies are going to do what they want, so there isn't any real incentive for governments to play along.
- cooljacob204 7y agoWe will be more then fine without Amazon.
- Apocryphon 7y agoThe market will bring in other firms and other jobs to NYC, without the government intervention that a deal with Amazon would entail.
- microtherion 7y agoNYC "lost" on shoveling $2.8B in subsidies to Amazon. As for tax revenue, Amazon pays about $200M total in annual US state taxes, and negative federal tax in 2018. There's no way this would have ended up a profitable deal for NY.
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoMy home state is chock full of sweetheart deals that benefit nobody but the corporations. It has a freaking ton of heavy industry, but the people in the state end up subsidizing out of towners with money that should be going towards their own kids' education and healthcare. And they're PROUD of it.
- nooron 7y agoI don't think this is a fair characterization of the situation, regardless of whether one likes AOC or not. AOC cannot personally say no to Amazon opening an office because that is not how the government works. Amazon asked for large tax breaks for their offices. Empirical economics research is at best mixed on whether or not those tax breaks are a good choice from the standpoint of growth and overall tax receipts. AOC and other representatives said they were opposed to those tax breaks, not that Amazon couldn't open an office.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dontreact 7y agoThey ended up adding many jobs in NYC anyway, so there want much point to subsidizing their taxes there.