4 ms·
By that reasoning, abortion would also be illegal excepting maybe self defense (aka the pregnancy endagers the mother's life). I'm not weighing in either way,
by zdragnar 7y ago
By that reasoning, abortion would also be illegal excepting maybe self defense (aka the pregnancy endagers the mother's life).
I'm not weighing in either way, just pointing out that getting a rational, logical consensus on why some things can and cannot be done is next to impossible. Another example- us states where murder of a pregnant woman can be charged as two murders, yet abortion remains legal.
Trying to have it both ways often ends up meaning abandoning a pretense of logic.
- overcast 7y agoAbortion is a giant debate, and there should be SOME type of regulation as to how far you can go along with a pregnancy before you decide to just kill it. But this is about a human, intentionally giving another human HIV. Intentionally giving anyone HIV should be against the law.
- zdragnar 7y ago> Intentionally giving anyone HIV should be against the law. If you consider a pregnant mother transferring HIV to an in-utero fetus as a human giving another human HIV, then to be logically consistent you must consider abortion as one human killing another. The size of the debate is irrelevant. Whether you carve out exceptions is a different story (I.e. self defense from health complications) but that is simply a justification for the killing, not changing the act itself. Edit: To complicate matters more, if a parent passing on HIV were illegal, should people with Down syndrome be legally allowed to have children? After all, there is a very significant chance the parents would "give" the child the syndrome as well.