37 ms·
I'd be happy just if they were forbidden to change articles after publishing, and not say that. Because currently, they post some bullshit news and create some
by ajsnigrutin 7y ago
I'd be happy just if they were forbidden to change articles after publishing, and not say that.
Because currently, they post some bullshit news and create some random outrage. Then someone points at some bullshit claim in their article, and they just quietly change the article (remove the claim, add "allegedly", etc.), and act as nothing was wrong. Or in worst case scenario, they quietly remove the whole article.
- lbenes 7y agoI've seen this accusation thrown out there on social media a few times now. When I've asked for examples, no one been able to provide a list showing that this is actually a systemic problem. With resources like the Internet Archive it should be trivial to prove that this really a problem. Can you back up your claims? Journalists are people and make mistakes. But overall, respected institutions like NYT, WSJ, WaPo, and Bloomberg show good journalistic integrity and print retractions in both print and online. If you really are seeing this problem regularly, i suggest you find better sources for your news. Above all avoid getting it from social media. The actual fake news that is rampant there is a much, much bigger threat to our society than the few bad apples or mistakes behind the problem you are describing.
- fredophile 7y agoCheck out this twitter account for some examples. https://mobile.twitter.com/nyt_diff?lang=en https://mobile.twitter.com/nyt_diff?lang=en
- lbenes 7y agoLOL > fixtures on the Republican party --> "fixtures of" clutches pearls Did you even click on your own link? That twitter account does NOT show "a systemic problem". If you had, you see it focuses on one of the "bad apples", the Bronx Girl story with some minor headline tweaks. Sorry but fixing the Headlines to improve the grammar or accuracy is not a mark of bad journalism. Whoever runs that account clearly has an axe to grind against the NYT, and beyond the Bronx girl story their examples don't prove anything.
- ramblerman 7y agoThose institutions are not the ones they were 10-20 years ago. And with less and less revenue streams they have resorted to clickbait like the rest. I suggest you wake up to the reality of modern 'journalism'. WaPo just recently messed up completely with the death of Baghdadi (the isis leader). Titling the article about his assassination as "Austere religious scholar dies at 48" They had to change it 3 more times till they actually mentioned that he was assassinated. And that was just a mistake.
- Clubber 7y agoThis is absolutely correct, it's shitty that people are downvoting you for it. Matt Taibbi even said as much on Joe Rogan. Journalists aren't some deity to be put on a pedestal. They are employees that work for a corporation, usually a really big one. That corporation's business model is dying and they are cutting costs to survive and have been for 20 years.
- ht85 7y agoWhat about this [1] ? It is from "respected" WaPo, and this is one of the most mind blowing examples. You might not want to go through the 1h30 rant from Richard Lewis, so feel free to skip to 31:00 and 34:30 for the content of the original article. I really don't know what to make of this. I just can't imagine what would prompt people to write and then actually publish this. You can read the comments on the article [2], there is no errata on the article and I haven't seen any official response from the Washington Post. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fay_X1Cu9Uc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fay_X1Cu9Uc [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/obituaries/abu-bakr-al-baghdadi-islamic-states-terrorist-in-chief-dies-at-48/2019/10/27/0d004abc-663d-11e7-8eb5-cbccc2e7bfbf_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/obituaries/abu-bakr-al-... Edit: Actually there is an official response, at 39:20, a tweet (sigh) which might be even more scandalous than that headline
- viridian 7y agoYou cite the Wall Street Journal as a respected institution, but I know I've seen them do this. Part of the problem with this type of thing is that publications often go out of their way to erase the existence of an aritcle if they intend to delete it. Here's an example of an articles scrubbed from existence, including from the internet archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20170301000000*/http://www.wsj.com/article_email/hillary-clinton-vs-foia-1443136818-lMyQjAxMTE1NTI1NTkyMDU5Wj https://web.archive.org/web/20170301000000*/http://www.wsj.c... http://www.wsj.com/article_email/hillary-clinton-vs-foia-1443136818-lMyQjAxMTE1NTI1NTkyMDU5Wj http://www.wsj.com/article_email/hillary-clinton-vs-foia-144... It's also unavailable, but searchable via google. Google simply shows a 404 page from the WSJ as the top result. The WSJ has never formally retracted this either. Now since this is the WSJ, obviously the article was copied wholesale and pasted into blogs and the like regardless, so it can't be completely scrubbed. As a matter of fact, a search for: "The filing was a response to a FOIA lawsuit brought in March by conservative organization Citizens United" will bring up many blogs with the full text of the article, but that doesn't change the fact that WSJ silently scrubbed the article from the internet archive, their own website, and the google cache.
- datashow 7y agoFunny, I searched "The filing was a response to a FOIA lawsuit brought in March by conservative organization Citizens United", and the first result in google is from here: https://www.wsj.com/articles/hillary-clinton-vs-foia-1443136818 https://www.wsj.com/articles/hillary-clinton-vs-foia-1443136... Aslo, if you search "url:http://www.wsj.com/article_email/" http://www.wsj.com/article_email/" , you won't find any active link at all. It seems they have changed their website structure.
- viridian 7y agoStrange, the first result for me is the one I linked. Same if I search the name of the article. Google doesn't show me yours at all. Happy to admit I was wrong about this though. I only remember this article because it came up in a thread about Internet Archive removing content sometimes without any explanation.
- excursionist 7y agoI see this happening pretty much every day for political news. I don't keep track of a list, but here is a recent example: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/13/us/politics/bernie-sanders-cenk-uygur.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/13/us/politics/bernie-sander... > Mr. Uygur, a longtime supporter of Mr. Sanders, has also disparaged former President Barack Obama on his show, argued that bestiality should be legal and hosted white supremacist figures, including David Duke. In one clip that circulated on Twitter, Mr. Duke ends an interview by saying, “I am not, what you call a racist,” to which Mr. Uygur replies sarcastically, “No, of course not.” They added the word 'sarcastically' and also added this after: > Mr. Uygur called the clip a “complete smear” that had been taken out of context from a combative one-hour interview in which he pushed back on Mr. Duke. In reality, NYT published a smear about Cenk Uygur, claiming he was supporting and agreeing with this white supremacist David Duke. This was a straight up lie, since Cenk spent the entire interview criticizing and arguing with David Duke, not agreeing with him at all. This caused an outrage among Cenk's supporters, and NYT quietly updated their article so that now it says almost the opposite of the original! Also, note that the smear was published after Cenk decided to run for Congress and the reporter knew that the clip used to support the 'Cenk agrees with David Duke' smear was out of context. [1] [1] https://www.mediaite.com/news/ny-times-corrects-report-on-cenk-uygur-after-criticism-for-framing-of-david-duke-interview/ https://www.mediaite.com/news/ny-times-corrects-report-on-ce...
- manfredo 7y agoThe Cenk Uygur situation is part of a broader trend I observe where traditional media outlets have a highly negative bias, to the point that it often ventures into the realm of fabrication, towards news and people in new media. News distributed via YouTube and social media and similar are an existential threat to the traditional news publications, and the thus there exists a fundamental conflict of interest when the latter covers the former.
- bragh 7y agoRetractions are kind of a bandaid. They should not even be needed if journalists did their due diligence. Worst case I personally saw was a claim by a journalism lecturer that a small news site was alt-right from its inception and wrote a long screed lambasting the site - no, it wasn't, it got sold to a different owner a couple of years after creation because the original owners could not monetize it. They even got the year of the creation of the site wrong. So, a person teaching journalism didn't even bother running a WHOIS query and spending 2 EUR to run a query against business registry. If that is the level of the teachers, then what can you expect from the people they taught?
- Defenestresque 7y agoYou mentioned WaPo. Here is an article[0] about WaPo publishing a story about "Russian hackers infiltrating a US electrical grid." In addition to the article being inaccurate, WaPo edited the copy several times to correct major errors of fact without adding an editorial note and refused to explain what led them to their incorrect conclusions. The article is a bit too long to accurately summarise, but essentially WaPo published a story under the following headline: “Russian hackers penetrated U.S. electricity grid through a utility in Vermont, U.S. officials say.” >The lead sentence offered “A code associated with the Russian hacking operation dubbed Grizzly Steppe by the Obama administration has been detected within the system of a Vermont utility, according to U.S. officials” and continued “While the Russians did not actively use the code to disrupt operations of the utility, according to officials who spoke on condition of anonymity in order to discuss a security matter, the penetration of the nation’s electrical grid is significant because it represents a potentially serious vulnerability.” This is at best a deeply misleading intro. The malware was found on a laptop not connected to the grid. The allegation that "Russian hackers penetrated the electrical grid" because they found tools which once may have been developed by Russians is about as accurate as me concluding that a hypothetical murderer was American because the murder weapon was an American-made AR-15. There are several more concerning parts to the story but alas, I'm on mobile and have slacked off long enough. I don't buy into the "MSM are knowing purveyors of fake news because profit!" but humans make mistakes and the desire of mainstream newspapers to beat bloggers in timeliness and pageviews can ultimately lead to standards slipping even among writers who would never knowingly publish a false story. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/kalevleetaru/2017/01/01/fake-news-and-how-the-washington-post-rewrote-its-story-on-russian-hacking-of-the-power-grid/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kalevleetaru/2017/01/01/fake-ne...
- caseysoftware 7y agoI'll suggest an alternative theory. You know how absurd and wrong the Russia/powergrid story is specifically because this is your industry. If this wasn't your industry, you would read it, not have the understanding and experience to critique, and therefore probably believe it.. even if it was later retracted. The same applies to us reading about other fields. My wife was a Capital Hill reporter in DC. Quite often, she had an hour or two to turn around a story on a hearing that just occurred on a topic she didn't know. Now multiply that by 4, 5, or 10 times each day. It doesn't take maliciousness, just incompetence and/or ignorance at scale. Michael Crichton named this: "Briefly stated, the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect is as follows. You open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well. In Murray’s case, physics. In mine, show business. You read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues. Often, the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward—reversing cause and effect. I call these the “wet streets cause rain” stories. Paper’s full of them." Ref: http://larvatus.com/michael-crichton-why-speculate/ http://larvatus.com/michael-crichton-why-speculate/
- blackflame 7y agoHere is an article from CNN criticizing NYT on their terribly botched Kavanaugh story recently. https://www.cnn.com/2019/09/16/media/new-york-times-kavanaugh/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/09/16/media/new-york-times-kavanaug...
- danso 7y agoI am as journalist-sympathetic as anyone on here, but even I would agree with the previous commenter's sentiment. Minimization of errors is an old and persistent problem in journalism, and the reasons for this can be relatively innocuous – e.g. general incompetence and complacency; not only in making the error, but also not having a system in place to collect and evaluate feedback/complaints from readers, nor to adequately disseminate a correction if one has been made – to outright dishonesty and cowardice (errors are generally a stain on a journalist's professional career). The best argument that this is a systemic problem is to simply point out the lack of systemic accountability: as people have pointed out, no major news site has a diff/version history (even though most content management systems have some kind of version tracking), which would be the bare minimum (and best return on value) for digital publishers who prioritize accountability. (The closest thing is newsdiffs.org, but that's an independent site [0]) If you want a real, recent error that illustrates the low importance of media corrections, I can give you one from this past week: when the New York Times erroneously reported that the Trump administration issued an executive order that would "define Judaism as a nationality". Here's a relevant excerpt from the earliest Internet Archive version of the article [1]: > Mr. Trump’s order will declare that Judaism may be considered a national origin. To say that this article caused a violent orgasm of Twitter fury and shock would be a vast understatement; you can search for tweets quote-tweeting the original @nytpolitics tweet to see for yourself. [2]. A few hours later, the NYT article had been significantly updated [3], with no correction or comment by the main NYT social media accounts, or by the individual reporters' Twitters (which are both very active). This is how the aforementioned excerpt was changed (and how it currently is as of today): > Mr. Trump’s order will have the effect of embracing an argument that Jews are a people or a race with a collective national origin in the Middle East, like Italian Americans or Polish Americans If the significance of the change isn't self-evident, then this tweet thread+article goes into detail about how big of a clusterfuck the original NYT article was [4]. To my knowledge, the NYT has said nothing about the mistake or the silent correction. Neither have the reporters. And as much outrage as the original article caused, it was all quickly forgotten (even faster than usual) because the mass shooting at the kosher market [5] and the UK elections the next day. To me, this incident is emblematic of how their accountability is systemically lackadaisical. It's undeniable that the NYT does make corrections, but we only know of the errors that were noticed and were officially corrected. By definition, we can't easily know the errors that were never noticed, or were silently fixed. In this situation, we have an error that is as egregious and infuriating as one can imagine in today's politics (Trump + executive authority + anti-Semitism + Israel v. Palestine). But also, this is a serious error that ultimately had no consequences, because the original report was attributed to anonymous sources (i.e. no reputation damage) and the error involved matters of abstract policy and political grandstanding. If the error did cause damage, such as defaming a public official, or causing an angry protest that turned into a riot, then I'm certain the NYT would issue a correction, just as it did recently with its misleading report re: Cenk Uygur and David Duke (albeit after 3 days of complaints from Uygur and his supporters) [6]. But regardless of whether there are aggrieved parties, news organizations should be making corrections solely because they value truth and accountability. That the NYT has so completely and brazenly refused to acknowledge its massive, noticeable fuckup (which, besides the error, indicates a real flaw in sourcing) means that their correction policy should be regarded as arbitrary and unserious. tl;dr: if they didn't make a correction for an error this big and noticeable, imagine how reluctant they are to issue corrections for errors much less noticeable and/or controversial. [0] http://newsdiffs.org/ http://newsdiffs.org/ https://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/01/opinion/sunday/article-changes-are-shown-in-a-tool-created-by-outsiders.html?_r=1 https://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/01/opinion/sunday/article-ch... [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20191210221006/https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/10/us/politics/trump-antisemitism-executive-order.html https://web.archive.org/web/20191210221006/https://www.nytim... [2] https://twitter.com/search?q=https%3A%2F%2Ftwitter.com%2Fnytpolitics%2Fstatus%2F1204533600537972736&src=typd https://twitter.com/search?q=https%3A%2F%2Ftwitter.com%2Fnyt... [3] https://web.archive.org/web/20191211010003/https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/10/us/politics/trump-antisemitism-executive-order.html https://web.archive.org/web/20191211010003/https://www.nytim... [4] https://twitter.com/Yair_Rosenberg/status/1204834065062514688 https://twitter.com/Yair_Rosenberg/status/120483406506251468... [5] https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/12/12/jersey-city-shooting/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/12/12/jersey-city... [6] https://twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/1206722302416687110 https://twitter.com/nytpolitics/status/1206722302416687110
- fauigerzigerk 7y agoThis could be an area where the much hyped block chain technology actually makes sense. But don't ask me what the incentives would have to be for journalistic organisations to adopt the technology.
- stoicShell 7y agoFirst thing would be to de-correlate this 'news blockchain' entirely from any sort of 'coin', 'token', whatever 'currency' thing — a blockchain is a distributed database, period, 'crypto-coins' being just one application for this storage. There are several ways to do it then but a standard would likely emerge, as in: "we <publisher> commit to mirror-publish our content to ThePressChain." You'd likely store only text (say the raw html) on the blockchain though, so using links for pictures etc; which implies your CDN is archived publicly for later retrieval (I suppose a deal with archive.org or equivalent is in order to bolster such a paradigm).
- DSMan195276 7y agoWhat you're describing already exists - just have news groups publish to `github` or some other `git` server (They could even host their own), and then anybody who wants can clone it.
- trickstra 7y agoThey are not really eager to provide such searchability, but we can always scrape them and save in a git repo ourselves.
- blawson 7y agoAgree with this! I’ve been thinking it would have to start with publications that aren’t the massive sources, using this as an advantage, and see the reward of subscribers as big publications get caught for these sorts of practices.
- stoicShell 7y agoI think it's the same when we ship beta software to users and then expect the first batch to essentially debug it — then comes the proverbial ".1" patch which fixes most glaring issues. (as if they weren't obvious in the first place) Now why do we do that in software? because "agile", cost, "let's ship and risk breaking some things and see what happens? We'll fix things later in some update, on a need-to basis" Well I think journalism has gone the same road: "let's publish first and risk breaking some truths and see what happens? We'll fix things later in some update, on a need-to basis" Can't really blame the business entities themselves. I wholeheartedly agree with GP though, there definitely needs to be more regulation and parent's point is one of the most salient target for that — it's disingenuous at best to silently update/remove, not to mention actually false from a documentation standpoint, it skews history basically. Very dystopian. News articles should be versioned exactly like git, we should be able to diff each public update.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- trickstra 7y agoYes, but you can still find the .0 version in the github. I'd be totally OK if the news were on github and I could easily see how the article looked a while ago (extra credits for git blame feature).
- davvolun 7y agoIt immediately irks me that I'm defending agile here, but part of the point of agile is that the developer doesn't really know what the end user needs, so it's, in theory, better to get a minimum viable product out that meets the user's need, then refine on subsequent releases, rather than spend years working on releasing something perfect that it turns out doesn't fill the user's need. From a similar perspective for journalism, I think there's an argument that can be made that it's better to get most of the information out right away, even if some of it is inaccurate, and then correct the inaccuracies later, rather than wait until every piece is confirmed and edited perfectly to release the information. Argument to extremes, think of a hurricane or volcano explosion.
- logfromblammo 7y agoIt'd be fine if published journalism had source control. Just look at the revision history.
- ryanmercer 7y agoOr better, make them leave the original text and include the correction. Publications that were repeat offenders would quickly build a bad reputation.