4 ms·
I worry about this too; admins of popular ActivityPub instances have far too much power to silently censor things from tens of thousands of people. I think fed
by sneak 7y ago
I worry about this too; admins of popular ActivityPub instances have far too much power to silently censor things from tens of thousands of people.
I think federated systems might be the least bad of the available models, though. Technically, we just need to make it easy to switch hosting, like email with your own domain. Swapping out your email host is straightforward.
- fhennig 7y agoBeing able to migrate away from a service requires a common protocol (as it is the case for email) or it would require a lot of individual migration processes for all the intricacies of the different providers.
- sneak 7y agoActivityPub is the common protocol. We just need better server software support so that you can migrate your id to a new host without that new host getting confused by the inbound messages from federated instances trying to talk to your old host.
- fhennig 7y agoIf facebook and twitter would support ActivityPub that would be great!
- sneak 7y agoIt is not in either of those platforms’ interest to allow others to interoperate with them, or to allow users to leave their apps and use those of others. Instagram goes so far as to ban links in everything except one field on your bio. They intend to own your connections to your friends and customers, and extract rent over it. It’s a terrible thing.
- clarry 7y agoI think the answer should be closer to P2P. As in something that anyone can spin up like torrents on a seedbox or $2.5 VPS or some old PC in the corner, with no accounts or anything tied to the server.
- buboard 7y agohome internet router/modems running a minimal server with some sort of publishing program to seed the content would be ideal
- cjslep 7y ago> admins of popular ActivityPub instances have far too much power to silently censor things from tens of thousands of people. This is a tired line of argument. Centralized systems are no better. ActivityPub is not FreeNet, and if you want censorship resistance then you're using the wrong network on ActivityPub. ActivityPub is about being able to build communities that still interact with other communities. And if one community doesn't want porn, hate, gore, and ideology X to be federated with it, and that instance becomes popular, perhaps it's popularity is because of the censorship, not in spite of it. So who are we as outsiders to dictate its members and its admins are ethically wrong for systematically censoring only from their community ideology X when building their specific community? We have as much of a moral right as to demand that church communities discuss the proper usage of BDSM rope knot placements for safety and maximum pleasure. That is: none.
- MayeulC 7y ago> perhaps it's popularity is because of the censorship, not in spite of it. I'd argue that content curation is usually seen as a plus, and censorship is a form of curation. What's missing in the equation is a distributed/federated reputation system, which I know Matrix gave a lot of thoughts about without finding an answer, and which twitter famously just launched a working group on. Reputation such as the karma and up/down votes we get here are one of the ways to approach curation (tagging like #twitter does can be part of another approach).
- sneak 7y agoThe difference between local and remote in most AP software is minimal. Admins defederating is more a parental powertrip about which domains their users can or can’t read than anything. If this sort of thing were really valuable and popular, we’d see browser extensions that do it. For the most part, those only block spam and trackers, and don’t break HTTP along ideological grounds. I think it’s the “free hosting” part that is popular, not so much the “admin powertrip” part. They also aren’t only censoring from their community. They are censoring their own users’ posts from the entire set of users on the instances they have blacklisted. The censorship cuts both ways. If anyone with any sizable audience were using AP, they would not tolerate a hosting admin deciding who is allowed to follow them.