2 ms·
Is this a proper understanding of superdeterminism? I may be totally off base but my understanding is the analogy is more like Craps. Two dice with fair odds
by jayd16 7y ago
Is this a proper understanding of superdeterminism?
I may be totally off base but my understanding is the analogy is more like Craps. Two dice with fair odds create an uneven distribution such that 7 is more common. The dice have "conspired" to bring 7 up more often than 2 because their states interact in a non-linear way.
- caf 7y agoAhem, there isn't anything more linear than the sum of two variables...
- jayd16 7y agoIts just an analogy. Something to show that a distribution might appear interesting but is actually not. The point is that Bell's theorem relies on the assumption that a linear distribution must be expected and the paper is arguing that that has not been sufficiently proven. At least that's my understanding of the paper's argument.
- akvadrako 7y agoBell's theorem does not rely on that.
- jayd16 7y agoCan you explain how? Wikipedia states: >With the measurements oriented at intermediate angles between these basic cases, the existence of local hidden variables could agree with/would be consistent with a linear dependence of the correlation in the angle but, according to Bell's inequality (see below), could not agree with the dependence predicted by quantum mechanical theory, namely, that the correlation is the negative cosine of the angle.
- akvadrako 7y agoWhat that sentence says is: Bell's theorem predicts the linear dependence of the correlations angles - or at least it's consistent with such a model. It's not an assumption of the theory. Also keep in mind we don't observe linear correlations - at least one of the assumptions of Bell's theorem must be wrong.
- knzhou 7y agoNo, not at all. That is a simple consequence of ordinary probability theory that is used in almost all interpretations of quantum mechanics. As I said, superdeterminism is much much much more radical. Here is a more appropriate analogy. Suppose I'm playing a shell game with you and you have to guess where the prize is. You guess the wrong position a million times in a row. Something analogous to this happens when we try to test quantum mechanics. Other interpretations of quantum mechanics explain this by saying, e.g. that the prize doesn't have a definite position to begin with, so the act of checking where it is can't be interpreted as just revealing a preexisting fact. The superdeterministic explanation is: "well, there's nothing to explain. You were simply determined to lose by the initial conditions of the universe. It couldn't have gone any other way."