3 ms·
> But e and pi, despite being numerically distant, are in one sense "close" - related - via Euler's formula. So there's a "local closeness" - the arithmetic dif
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> But e and pi, despite being numerically distant, are in one sense "close" - related - via Euler's formula. So there's a "local closeness" - the arithmetic difference of pi and its neighbor - but also a "relationship closeness" where pi and e are intimately linked.
I don't understand how Euler's formula establishes a special relationship. You can compute a function of any two numbers. Where f(a,b) = a^{ib}, then f(e,pi) = -1, but why is that more meaningful than the fact that pi + e = 5.85987... ?
In Euler's formula in particular, the value e cannot be changed -- a complex number is necessarily represented as r * e^{iθ}. (Step one in processing e.g. 3 * 7^{i√2} is to normalize it to 3 * e^{i√2 ln 7}.) Pi is the angle between the vector (1, 0) and the vector (-1, 0). You could change that, and you'd have an equation saying that, if you rotate a unit vector by whatever the new angle is, the result is a complex number of unit magnitude and the angle you specified. For example, e^{2i} = cos(2) + i sin(2) = -0.416 + 0.909i. But I think the claim that this shows a deep, fundamentally special relationship between e and 2 is a hard sell. The cleanness of e^{i * pi} = -1 isn't telling you that pi is related to e -- it's telling you that pi is related to trigonometry.
- pfortuny 7y agoSo: e is the basis giving rise to a group homomorphism between (R,+) and the unit circumference. That is: e is inherently trigonometric. Not irrelevant.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoe is related to the complex numbers through trigonometry. And pi is related to trigonometry more directly than that. But e and pi are not related to each other; "being related" isn't transitive like that. Consider correlations. A correlation is necessarily "transitive" if the correlation values are very, very close to ±1, and not otherwise. If a correlates with b at 0.7, and b correlates with c at 0.68, the correlation between a and c might be 0.69, but only by coincidence.
- jcranberry 7y agocorrelations are not a good analogy, homomorphisms often preserve desirable properties or relationships.
- shrimpx 7y agoPut more simply, there's nothing special about -1.
- qubex 7y agoExcept that when discussing transcendentals (full-blooded reals such as e and π) integers such as –1 have measure zero and are therefore ruled out as freak coincidences.
- shrimpx 7y agoI'm a dummy I'll have to study your statement.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoSimplified: Integers make up 0% (the figure is exact, not rounded) of the real number line. (And from that perspective, if you do happen to see an integer, something pretty weird must have happened.)
- thaumasiotes 7y ago-1 has unit magnitude. It's pretty special. ;D e and pi are special too; nobody's questioning that. But they're not related to each other.