5 ms·
I'm not sure if everything being deterministic is an abhorrent, invalid option, but I also don't see why reality has to be local. I mean, the limitation of ligh
by perl4ever 7y ago
I'm not sure if everything being deterministic is an abhorrent, invalid option, but I also don't see why reality has to be local. I mean, the limitation of light speed is something that exists to make a consistent theory, not something that somehow has value in itself...?
My problem is probably not just a lack of math, but a lack of taste.
- trevyn 7y agoAgreed. I think it becomes clearer when you start to look at the human dynamics of group belief systems, and the process of changing those beliefs and consequent turmoil. The fact is, we don’t have enough evidence yet to decide one way or the other, but there is a commonly accepted interpretation that is quite strongly cemented in the minds of practicing physicists, which works well for their purposes. When challenged by a fringe group, they will naturally defend their beliefs in ways that are both scientific and human-reactionary. Being scientists, they will be open to changing beliefs given enough evidence, but being human, they will instinctively defend their existing beliefs, even if poorly supported, until sufficient evidence arrives. I suppose the perfect Bayesian physicist would hold a superposition of beliefs, and use this set to decide on the most promising allocation of research resources. Of course, having incomplete information, there is always the chance of a hidden dynamic that, to uncover, requires chance investigation of an unlikely theory. :-)
- GoblinSlayer 7y agoEvidence for locality is theory of relativity, which has practical applications too. Evidence against locality are vague feelings (not Bell's theorem), that have internal theoretical problems. What would be taste here?
- tsimionescu 7y ago> I mean, the limitation of light speed is something that exists to make a consistent theory, not something that somehow has value in itself...? The limitation of causation to a constant speed is well proven in experiments, and seems to be a fundamental aspect of the universe at large scales. If this same limitation doesn't hold at small scales then either: 1. There must be some cutoff between large scale and small scale, and small scale events can't influence large scale events. 2. Instantaneous action at a distance exists at large scales as well, and so our theories are wrong (we need a new theory to explain the observations of the speed of light etc.). This is all not to mention that we have not noticed any particle moving past the speed of light, and that we have measured the same constant speed of light at quantum levels as well (a photon measured from a moving detector has the same speed as one measured from a static detector). So that way lies nothing good. On the other hand, rejecting local realism doesn't mean that QM rejects the speed of light being constant - quantum entanglement can't carry information, so it can't produce actions at a distance. Also, note that the most common interpretation of QM is neither local nor 'real' - that is, it implies both that particles have no definite state until they are measured, and that QE propagates at infinitite speed. That is, when you fire two entangled photons, neither of the photons has any value for polarization until they are measured; however, when one is measured, it acquires a particular spin, and the other one also acquires the corresponding spin instantaneously, possibly on the other side of the galaxy. Now, one problem with all this is that it is extremely non-intuitive, and does not apply to the large-scale world (an apple is red whether I look at it or not). Related to the second issue, there is the problem of measurement: in a theory which rejects realism, the act of measurement has a fundamental physical effect, but there is no explanation for this mechanism, it is simply postulated. Note that a photon interacting with another photon is not measurment, they will each retain a superposition of states until a measurement happens.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThanks for the explanation. It really is non-intuitive and hard to get especially just from informal texts. What I don't get at all is the bit about quantum entanglement not carrying any information. Apparently, that has to do something with the fact that the collapse of the wave function is a random process? But, if you have probability then you have information, yes? What's the explanation?
- lmm 7y ago> But, if you have probability then you have information, yes? What do you mean by that? Suppose you and I are far apart in space and are each going to toss a coin, but we somehow magically know that one of us will get heads and the other will get tails. Can we use this pair of magic coins to communicate information? Actually no.
- GoblinSlayer 7y agoThe suggestion is to abuse information whether you get tails with probability 100% or 50%.
- lmm 7y agoWhat do you mean?
- tsimionescu 7y agoI don't know the full maths behind it, but the most important aspect is that you can only perform one measurement on the superposition state - after your first measurement, the particle acquires a definite state, and any subsequent measurements are guaranteed to show that same state. If you are the first one to measure the state of any of the pair of entangled particles, your measurement will cause both particles to take on a definite state. But even if you are the second one to do the measurement, and the particle has already acquired the definite state because of the other measurement, you can't tell that your measurement result was already guaranteed, since you can't perform another one on the same state to compute the distribution.