4 ms·
Boeing is one of the pillars of the American economy and the market as well. Dumping the stock will hurt pretty much every fund that invested on it, plus Dow wi
by markus_zhang 7y ago
Boeing is one of the pillars of the American economy and the market as well. Dumping the stock will hurt pretty much every fund that invested on it, plus Dow will plunge just because of this one stock if it's getting dumped.
Boeing, as well as many other firms, are just too big to fail suddenly.
- olefoo 7y ago> too big to fail suddenly Also known as "a systemic risk". This is the downside of allowing the concentration of economic power in too few hands. It's like other large scale systems. Yes there's a lot of redundancy; but that redundancy serves a purpose.
- rodgerd 7y agoAll the central planning of the old Soviet Union, with none of the pretense to public good.
- hinkley 7y agoThere was a really weird moment for me about ten years ago when I realized Apple could pay cash to buy Boeing. I mean, obviously they wouldn't, but something is off about the scale of it all. Are we sure it's a pillar? Perhaps if you take all of the suppliers and partners it represents, sure. But by itself, I don't think it really look all that impressive. After The War, the US government was careful to keep domestic manufacturing 'healthy' which turned into 'fat and happy' which has now turned into I-don't-know-what, but I wonder if subsidies-as-defense-policy should be putting more energy into other industries.
- markus_zhang 7y agoYeah including all those peripheral dmg if it falls suddenly. I'm mean might be able to afford I'd it declines overtime, but a shock is going be very scary.
- gniv 7y agoInteresting comparison. I guess the difference is that the supply chain of Boeing is mostly in the US, whereas for Apple it's mostly overseas.
- kyrieeschaton 7y agoIt gutted "domestic manufacturing", it lavished largesse on the military-industrial sector specifically (and even there, the post Cold War consolidation that Warren Christopher specifically promoted is one of the reasons the aerospace sector is such a mess).
- ajross 7y agoA quick google says Boeing is the 28th largest US company by both revenue and market cap (interesting that they line up exactly), sitting next to "pillars" like the Home Depot and PepsiCo. We'll be fine.
- generatorguy 7y agoIt takes a lot less skill and knowledge to build another retailer or soft drink company than one that designs and builds cutting edge airplanes.
- ajross 7y agoArguably, sure. But it's not an engineering argument. The point was responding to comments like "Dumping the stock will hurt pretty much every fund that invested on it, plus Dow will plunge just because of this one stock if it's getting dumped."
- munk-a 7y agoHonestly, I don't know why Boeing has this image of being such a vital cog in America - America isn't wholly dependent on Boeing and if it was that'd be a generally terrible thing anyways. Also, who cares about the Dow plunging if it's for such a clear and explicable reason - it's usually used by politicians to gauge mysterious impacts on the economy, when you know the cog that broke to cause the numbers to swivel it's a pretty useless metric - you already know the thing. It's sort of like not wanting to go into maintenance mode to deploy a big infrastructure patch because being forced into maintenance mode is bad - yea, it is, and if you can avoid taking servers offline go ahead and do that - but if you can't then just eat the outage as it's probably better to upgrade things than to refuse to upgrade due to the fact that it will expose the fact that you had to upgrade.
- AlexCoventry 7y ago> Also, who cares about the Dow plunging if it's for such a clear and explicable reason The enormous fraction of people who have their retirement savings tied up in the stock market, that's who.
- rpiguy 7y agoWho cares if the Dow plunges? The largest block of active voters, retirees and those near retirement who live off or will be living off their investments.
- hackerbabz 7y agoIs this why they should have 90% or more of their fund in bonds by now?
- ddalex 7y agoChina has 90% of their funds in US bonds by now (called dollars), and what good does that do them ?
- hackerbabz 7y ago