3 ms·
Not sure why there are so many replies about this being dismissive. It is just pointing out people likes to reinvent technology every once in a while with 95%
by ksec 7y ago
Not sure why there are so many replies about this being dismissive.
It is just pointing out people likes to reinvent technology every once in a while with 95% of the same thing. And it is not apparent whether those doing the "reinvention" knew what the constrain or trade offs or limitation the previous technology had.
Sometimes these sort of Full Circle makes me wonder if software has really moved forward at all.
- mr__y 7y ago> And it is not apparent whether those doing the "reinvention" knew what the constrain or trade offs or limitation the previous technology had. I'm quite sure that very often the "reinvention" is literally a reinvention - that is not based on previous invention, but an independent solution that just happens to be similiar to something created earlier (without the reinventors knowledge of the existing previous invention). With an abstraction level high enough, many concrete problems become one abstract problem with a few abstract solutions, and sometimes only very few "obvious"[0] solutions. This leads to a situation when many independent persons/teams come up with a concrete solution to their concrete problem that coincidentally happens to be very similiar to other solutions. If one of those solutions where created in the past, and others where rediscovered later, we then retrospectively call those later solutions as "reinventions" regardless of them being literal or just figurative reinventions.[1] [0] in this context "obvious" defined as "most likely to be independently found/created by any sane person" [1] "literal reinvention" being a solution that was consciously based on some previously existing invention and a "figurative" when it just happens to be similiar to something created in the past but the inventor did not (consciously) base their work on something already existing
- afiori 7y agoThis is like the reaction people had to Dropbox on this very site [1]. Even if wasm was literally the same bytecode copied from an old mainframe the possibilities that this new use allows are enough of a novelty and an invention in and of itself. I would find a comparison of wasm with older bytecodes very interesting as for sure none of them are perfect. But this kind of reply is clearly dismissive. It contains no criticism and it offer no insight over why some failed and other succeeded. I essentially see it as lamenting that another similar technology was/is treated unfairly. Which is a fine comment, since many technologies meet a unjust or undeserved demise. It is still irrelevant as essentially boils down to "how dare you succeed where others have failed". This is even worse than just saying that it is bound to fail miserably the same way Java applets did. There are for sure negative sides to wasm, the fact that many parts are similar to past ideas is simply inconsequential on the merits. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863
- zzzcpan 7y agoWASM is not a startup, it's a very niche tech and pushing it to other niches as a "platform" needs a lot of investment and buy in from professionals and management working in those niches. Not that the idea itself of an intermediate representation is bad, it's just WASM is not necessarily good and the odds are definitely against it. HN top comment on dropbox wasn't really wrong either. Triviality proved to be a valid point. Plenty of companies made similar software once they saw there was a need for it. I mean who still uses dropbox today?
- afiori 7y agoI surely am missing something, because I have no idea why you think wasm is niche. It is niche today the same way javascript-rich interfaces where niche during the reign of PHP. I don't know how to answer the rest of your comment... I don't think we have enough common ground to understand each other.
- zzzcpan 7y agoThere are maybe a few hundred people on earth who are in a position to embed wasm into something, how is that not niche?
- afiori 7y agohere embedding can mean just plugins. This very article is about a framework for robotics. Another extremely plausible option is simply to sandbox mods for games. There are even projects for allowing userspace modules to run safely inside the kernel similarly to EBPF. This last one in particular is something entirely new. Without even considering the obvious application of allowing photo editing in web interfaces with reasonable performance. Or on the other side of legality many people will try and use the new performance to have better cryptomining botnets. Just by considering plugins (with dynamical loading and safety) and number crunching in-browser I would say that 'few hundreds' becomes a significant understatement.