3 ms·
This the first nonsense talk by Jeff Dean. AI doesn't help at all it battling climate change, only politics do help. The models are accurate enough for centurie
by rurban 7y ago
This the first nonsense talk by Jeff Dean. AI doesn't help at all it battling climate change, only politics do help. The models are accurate enough for centuries, AI would only help in hard forecasting in the usual 2 weeks window on local events. Long term on global scale there's no AI needed at all. So it looks like he ran out of topics to entertain himself. Or he went politician. Which would be a welcoming change.
- thundergolfer 7y agoI’d agree that Jeff there is a man with only a hammer walking around telling us that Climate Change is a nail. Engineers can’t fix everything. Of course the engineering is important, but politics is 1000% the road block on climate action and that is where efforts should be focused,
- natalyarostova 7y ago> that is where efforts should be focused Are all humans fungible? You don't think it's valuable to have some errant geniuses trying to think of weird and creative ways to solve climate change through unconvential engineering? It's not as though they'd be good politicians.
- thundergolfer 7y agoOf course yes, that's valuable. But the political focus shouldn't be lost in the messaging. Google needs to take a political stand on Climate Change, first and foremost. The engineering investment is secondary. We already have the technology to solve our climate problems. We don't need the fancy AI solutions. We just need to implement what we have already right now. That needs to be made abundantly clear to everybody. If Google is asked "what are you doing to address Climate Change?" and we hear predominantly engineering talk, then they're being disingenuous.
- panarky 7y agoPerhaps the Singularity can figure out how to clean up the political mess we've made.
- summerlight 7y agoDid you go the talk or have the slide/video? It looks like you know the details and I'm interested in this but cannot find its details yet.
- cyorir 7y agoI don't think AI has to be entirely useless in battling climate change. Dean has made other comments on AI and climate change: https://venturebeat.com/2019/12/16/ai-experts-urge-machine-learning-researchers-to-tackle-climate-change/ https://venturebeat.com/2019/12/16/ai-experts-urge-machine-l... "Dean said the company is thinking of including more information in Google search results to give users a predicted carbon output for choices they make, like ordering a certain product." An AI system that predicts carbon output for consumer choices and delivers that to consumers could be useful in battling climate change, even if only in a small way.