7 ms·
Seems like evidence that our current climate change might be random. How do you rule out random climate variation scientifically? I'm curious, do we have enoug
by sillysaurusx 7y ago
Seems like evidence that our current climate change might be random.
How do you rule out random climate variation scientifically? I'm curious, do we have enough data to say one way or the other?
I'm hesitant to post this, since it seems like detached scientific conversation about climate change has been in short supply. But perhaps.
- Numberwang 7y agoIn what way is this evidence against man made climate change?
- sillysaurusx 7y agoIntense, world-changing climate change has been with us since long before fossil fuels. This is yet another instance. I am interested in the scientific methodology that rules out such variations and confirms that fossil fuels are in fact responsible. The time period is an obvious one: we seem to be seeing spikes in one century vs millennia. But the details of those spikes matter in comparison to our total historical record; hence the curiosity.
- prox 7y agoThis xkcd shows the long time graph into perspective with relevant notes : https://xkcd.com/1732 https://xkcd.com/1732
- Numberwang 7y agoYes it is important to look at the total historical record and have a scientific approach. But please look at the information graphed out and not just described as a set of anecdotes. And also take into account how the last centuries very dramatic changes relates to human fossil fuel consumption and changes in agriculture (both of which has an impact on the composition to the atmosphere). The scientific case for human impact is established. It is unfortunate bigger actions to mitigate the consequences will not happen. Whomever is alive in a 100 years time is likely to be born into a much more hostile world.
- bloudermilk 7y agoThe warming of our atmosphere is easily predicted by basic science related to greenhouse gasses and solar radiation. This isn't disputable as randomness any more than an object can be said to have randomly fallen to the ground when dropped. Here is one of countless sources you can find that explain this principle and the consequences: https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/climate-change-atmospheric-carbon-dioxide https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/...
- MrBeansForReal 7y agoyes, just listen to Greta, that's all the science good leftist like you should ever need.
- thepangolino 7y ago>In fact, the last time the atmospheric CO2 amounts were this high was more than 3 million years ago, when temperature was 2°–3°C (3.6°–5.4°F) higher than during the pre-industrial era, and sea level was 15–25 meters (50–80 feet) higher than today. Doesn't this mean that the correlation between CO2 levels and temperatures isn't that big?
- afthonos 7y agoI can come up with a couple alternatives to your explanation: 1. Our current carbon levels haven’t been high long enough for their total effects in temperature to be felt yet, given the size of the system they must affect. 50 years is a blip on geological timescales. 2. There are cascading effects to high CO2 levels that will take longer to manifest themselves and which will raises the temperatures further. Permafrost melting and releasing methane is a possible example.
- ImaCake 7y agoThe orbit of the earth around the sun, and the activity of the sun itself are also possible culprits. I'm sure actual climatologists have a better explanation.
- 7y ago
- jen729w 7y agoFor me – scientifically-minded layperson, but not a climate scientist – the issue seems to be that people have conflated & confused two issues. One: that the climate was, without argument, different in the past. Two: that we are now, without argument, influencing the climate due to the extraordinary amount of carbon dioxide that we are producing. One does not preclude the other. Was the climate different, often hotter and drier, in the past? Sure. Evidence shows that it was. But does that mean that we aren’t leading ourselves in to a short/medium-term catastrophe by dumping enormous amounts of CO2 in to the environment now? No. The two are unrelated. Imagine if we determined that the climate was on a natural cycle, such that the entire Earth would warm, fires and droughts would become commonplace, and that sea levels would rise as a result of global temperature. Would we just do nothing? I’d hope not. I’d hope that it would spur us in to action, to realise that our quality of life is about to radically change, that human migration will necessarily increase, that people living near the sea, or depending on water, will have their lives irrevocably changed. That has happened in the past. We just didn’t have such a complicated society at the time, so the impacts were less. If you count the extinction of the Egyptian society as “less”. It’s also happening now, except we are doing it. Voluntarily, with full knowledge of the ultimate result. That seems, to people like me, a bit silly.
- perl4ever 7y agoShouldn't the default assumption be that humans are affecting the climate and there is an underlying natural trend, and that adds significant uncertainty to the magnitude and sign of those two factors? People always seem to talk as though it's one or the other, but it seems to me essentially impossible that it's not both.
- jen729w 7y ago> Shouldn't the default assumption be that humans are affecting the climate Yes. > and there is an underlying natural trend, Yes. > and that adds significant uncertainty to the magnitude and sign of those two factors? Ooh you were so close to the trifecta.
- 7y ago
- nitrogen 7y agoThere are plenty of resources on the topic and prior discussions on HN. People really don't want to rehash them because 1. it gets boring and 2. it leads to flamewars. You ask "do we have enough data". Well, the same data that gives us evidence of prior climate events is the same data that shows human emissions are climatologically significant. So if we have enough data to study random changes, we have enough to study the changes we are causing. If you want to take a stance against man-made climate change, you'll actually need to do your own research first and have a really good reason why it's wrong. Can you yourself list all the data sources that go into climatology and why they aren't adequate?
- sillysaurusx 7y agoI don't think I took a stance against anything. I think I asked a couple of questions. I had a longer comment prepared, but as you say, responding to accusations tends to get boring. If you want to have a conversation about this, though, it would be nice.
- pjc50 7y agoHow much of the IPCC reports have you read? It would indicate where the appropriate starting point for the conversation is.
- coldpie 7y agoFor anyone coming to this conversation now, the IPCC Summary for Policymakers Report[1] is absolutely required reading before you can have any opinion on climate science. It's not a hard read, put aside an afternoon for it, you won't regret it. It's written by actual climate scientists, for an audience of laypeople. [1] https://www.ipcc.ch/srocc/chapter/summary-for-policymakers/ https://www.ipcc.ch/srocc/chapter/summary-for-policymakers/
- jiggawatts 7y agoYou're on Y Combinator, not Facebook. It's not a conversation when you can educate yourself with literally any Google query on the topic. Your fingers aren't broken and your Internet works, so use the tools available to you. Try "climate change faq", "common climate change misconceptions", "evidence for anthropogenic climate change", etc, etc... Once you've read the top 10 results for each of those, come back and then we can have a conversation instead of an argument born out of wilful ignorance.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoHere's all the likely causes of warming - earth's orbit, sun, aerosols, volcanoes etc each overlaid on observed over the last 125 years as you scroll down. You decide. https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2015-whats-warming-the-world/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2015-whats-warming-the-wo...
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y ago> Seems like evidence that our current climate change might be random. To me, it seems like (strong) evidence that climate can change. And that there is a cause of this change, and that the cause that can be found. Maybe volcanic, meteoric, related to vegetation levels, or other? Which is, I think, the _opposite_ of random. It is understandable and predictable. > How do you rule out random climate variation scientifically? Outside of quantum physics, "it was random" is not a scientific explanation. Science finds causes. When applied to "our current climate change", the idea that climate can change and change a lot, in response to causes, well, that provides the opposite conclusion to yours doesn't it: we can see the causes this time.
- chrisco255 7y agoIt's not that it's random. It's that it is a non-linear, dynamic system. What that means is that if you have the perfect climate model (which, we don't) and you're off on your input of the parameters to that model by the slightest bit, the outcomes will veer off wildly from modeled expectations.
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y agoDoesn't that apply to weather much more than it does to climate?
- chrisco255 7y agoClimate is just the average of weather over a long period of time. It applies to both. The only difference is the units. There are hundreds of cycles and factors that influence climate. We don't have all of them modeled, nor quantified. So there are unknown unknowns.
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y ago> The only difference is the units Negative. It's quite possible (even likely) that the odds of a major hurricane hitting Florida next week are down to "a non-linear, dynamic system" and you're tying to predict which why the storm will "veer off wildly", while the average number and total intensity of storms over the next ten years is neither of those.
- tzs 7y agoWe can directly measure that there has been a large increase in the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. It's extremely well established both experimentally and theoretically how the responses of greenhouse gases to different frequencies of electromagnetic radiation lead to warming. We can probably also actually measure the energy coming in from the Sun, and with satellites measure the amount going out, to further verify that the greenhouse gases are behaving as expected. That allows us to reduce your question to how do we rule out that the increases in greenhouse gases are due to random variation? For CO2, we can answer that by looking at different carbon isotopes. CO2 in living plants, CO2 in long dead plants, CO2 in volcanic gas emissions, and CO2 from weathering rock all have distinctly different ratios of carbon isotopes. By looking at the isotope distribution on the carbon in the atmosphere, we can show that most of the increase is from long dead plants--in other words, from burning coal and oil.