3 ms·
The people behind this deal are ICANN insiders who know the rules intimately; in some cases they may have written the rules. It's hard to imagine that ICANN won
by wmf 7y ago
The people behind this deal are ICANN insiders who know the rules intimately; in some cases they may have written the rules. It's hard to imagine that ICANN won't approve the deal.
- kresten 7y agoIt’s probably all the same person, everyone involved.
- ardy42 7y ago> The people behind this deal are ICANN insiders who know the rules intimately; in some cases they may have written the rules. It's hard to imagine that ICANN won't approve the deal. If that's the case, maybe the US government needs to reclaim authority over ICANN, which it had until a few years ago, and assert that authority to reverse this decision. There needs to be some kind of effective oversight.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- giancarlostoro 7y agoWonder if the SEC needs to dip their toes into this one.
- cdmckay 7y agoYes, the US government is well known for its lack of corruption.
- AsyncAwait 7y agoThe majority of people don't live in the U.S. Why should the U.S. government hold such control? If the argument is that they invented the internet, (hardly entirely accurate), they certainly didn't invent the World Wide Web. I don't even agree with them having .gov, them regaining .org would be a disaster. If anything, some sort of multi-national, strictly non-profit charity should be setup for this, or if not, the U.N. as a last resort.
- delecti 7y agoIt looks like both ICANN and ISOC have their headquarters in the US.
- sct202 7y agoAs we've seen already with the current set up where they are a small non-profit charity these places can get corrupted when there's enough money dangling in front of the right people.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> Why should the U.S. government hold such control? Because they did until very recently. > If anything, some sort of multi-national, strictly non-profit charity should be setup for this, or if not, the U.N. as a last resort. That would take literally years, and would be too-little, too-late to deal with these shenanigans around the .org TLD.
- AsyncAwait 7y ago> Because they did until very recently. That's not an argument. Any regressive policy could and has been justified in those terms.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> That's not an argument. Any regressive policy could and has been justified in those terms. Yes, it is. The US government has an institutional history of overseeing ICAAN, so it's the most practical organization to take on that role on short notice. I think you're letting the perfect be the enemy of the good. Your preferred multi-national solution would likely take years to negotiate, which means it's not really even a solution at all, as far as .org is concerned.
- FDSGSG 7y agoSo why should ICANN hold any such control?
- tal8d 7y ago
- timwaagh 7y agoThen why didn't they just approve and get it over with. Seems they want to wait a while, see how their stakeholders feel about it in a few months and then either approve or not. Or they want to send the message to ethos that they want their cut as well, of course.
- unionpivo 7y agoMy take on it: They will in a month, or just after new year, issue a press release, that they studied/talked to all "relevant" parties (and information) and request one meaningless (in the long run) change in the deal and then bless it to go forward. It's damage control.