6 ms·
This is indeed (as quoted up in the article) very exciting, but as well as very frightening. I notice comments on this thread already ignore the causal aspects
by gumby 7y ago
This is indeed (as quoted up in the article) very exciting, but as well as very frightening. I notice comments on this thread already ignore the causal aspects (I presume Nature figures its readers will have that in mind).
The scary and lazy eugenics argument of course is that some people have an inherent “inferiority” due to their genetic inheritance.
But evolutionary pressure at each step applies to local advantage only so the causal chain more likely runs the other way: that 200 years of increasingly centralized industrialization encouraged expression of genes that would favor certain behavior. Plus the reduced cost of transportation would encourage offspring for whom that was not an advantage to move away.
Super fascinating. But if seized upon by the modern day phrenologists it could be super dangerous.
Edit: a couple of typos
- SamReidHughes 7y agoExpensive eugenics babies (maybe just embryo-selected) will get outbred by traditionalists anyway. What will make things really weird is artificial womb tech.
- shillremover 7y agoVery interested in why anyone would downvote this, it seems obviously true.