Let's say there's two books in front of us. A and B. I have read both you have only read A. I argue that B is better because the plot was more intricate. Yo

Let's say there's two books in front of us. A and B. I have read both you have only read A. I argue that B is better because the plot was more intricate. You argue that A is better because you think the cover of book B is bad. Do you think these two judgements have equal value?