4 ms·
I thought the Hydrogen thing was a ruse to kill battery electric vehicles, years ago, invented by fossil fuel lobbyists. It works like this: Hydrogen seems pla
by dboreham 7y ago
I thought the Hydrogen thing was a ruse to kill battery electric vehicles, years ago, invented by fossil fuel lobbyists.
It works like this: Hydrogen seems plausibly usable, but nobody is sure. It allows continued use of internal combustion engines so you can carry on as normal for now. Then in 10 years when nobody has figured out how to make Hydrogen work it's too bad we didn't focus on battery electric. And of course you can repeat and rinse because perhaps in another 10 years Hydrogen may be made to work.
We're two cycles in at this point.
- mcot2 7y agoIt also serves to preserve the current refueling experience from fuel delivery to point of sale. Electric cars are mostly charged at home and at work/parking areas which flips everything on its head. There are a lot of industries threatened by this.
- Gibbon1 7y agoOne consideration is the current world political order is built around supplies of oil. Battery powered transport dramatically changes that.
- taneq 7y agoThat was definitely part of it. There was an industry-wide push to work on a "hydrogen economy" as a stall to stave off the CARB regulation which was going to force a certain percentage of vehicle sales to be electric. It did make more sense in the late 90s when the predominant battery tech was NiMH. Fuel cells were actually competitive on price and performance, but can't really hold a candle to modern LiPoly or LiIon batteries. U.S. car manufacturers dropped fuel cells like a hot potato as soon as the CARB mandate was repealed, and crushed their BEVs to destroy any evidence.
- woodandsteel 7y agoBut the strategy failed because enough companies went ahead with battery electrics.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI always think of gasoline, hydrogen fuel cells, and batteries as chemical energy storage. Gasoline had the advantage of also being a primary resource. And can be pumped. And stored in a thin walled metal tank. The disadvantage is it requires a jankie otto cycle engine to convert that energy to mechanical power. Which was both unreliable and polluting. Hydrogen shared with batteries the disadvantage of not being a primary resource. And requires a heavy storage tank and a jankie temperamental fuel cell, batteries and an electric motor. Transport and fueling is sketchy with a capital E. Batteries while having lower power density and high costs had the advantage of being really simple. Which I think explains their original success and eventual return. Consider a lithium ion battery needs bulky cathodes and anodes. While hydrogen needs a heavy high pressure tank. Not clear which of those is a winner. Yet the batteries functional simplicity is a win hands down.