4 ms·
I think that as a policy matter (what interviewers should do or should even be allowed to do), a stronger claim can be made. Suppose there are some groups A1 a
by amluto 7y ago
I think that as a policy matter (what interviewers should do or should even be allowed to do), a stronger claim can be made. Suppose there are some groups A1 and A2 (men vs women, different races, etc — there could be A3, etc). Then I would argue that, regardless of whether the groups have substantial differences affecting qualification for the job, group membership or perceived group membership should not be allowed as a substitute for individual qualification. So, as an extreme example, if a job requires heavy lifting and short or contained hair, then an applicant should not be preferred because they’re male.
Obviously there are nuances here. If the groups are actually job qualifications (hiring a singer based on vocal range, for example), then none of this applies. There are surely plenty of gray areas, too. Gender doesn’t fit cleanly into a pair of groups. Sometimes it might be very hard to measure actual aptitude, and proxies of various quality are needed. College admissions are an example of the latter — you can’t measure how well someone can do, so admissions departments use proxies of varying quality and social acceptability.
As for gender differences, if I’m hiring someone, I believe that it doesn’t matter whether one gender is likely to be more qualified for any reason — if I’m hiring, I have an obligation to consider the applicant as an individual regardless of gender.
- falcolas 7y ago> if I’m hiring, I have an obligation to consider the applicant as an individual regardless of gender. Since it's illegal to hire based on the results of an IQ test in the US, we have to come up with other proxies for it. So, we use stereotypes that are associated intelligent individuals as filtering criteria. Gender provides one of those stereotypes - in both directions. Men have traditionally not been considered for jobs like nursing or caretaking. Women have traditionally not been considered for jobs which require physical strength or analytical skills. But back to your original premise: when you're evaluating hundreds, or thousands, of applications for a single opening, you're going to fall back on stereotypes, because it's too much work to do otherwise. Gap in employment longer than a few months? Skills have expired. Lots of job hopping after 6-18 months? Unreliable. Only has worked for companies known for their physical labor? Not capable of working in an office. A short job history with no college? Not smart enough. Even though every single one of those is potentially wrong, it's also potentially correct. If you need to weed 100 applications down to 10 for phone interviews in the next hour, can you really afford to give each of the 100 applicants the benefit of the doubt? EDIT: Removed "intelligence", replaced with "the results of an IQ test", which is what I meant originally. Apologies.
- s1artibartfast 7y ago>Since it's illegal to hire based on intelligence in the US, we have to come up with other proxies for it. Where are you getting this from? Mental disability is a protected class but not the same as intelligence.
- falcolas 7y agoI should have worded it better - it's effectively illegal. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co TL;DR: It's hard to defend an IQ test against a discrimination lawsuit. Unless there's an explicit business need to concretely identify someone's IQ, a business is at risk of being called out as using the IQ test to discriminate against some protected group, since that protected group is potentially disadvantaged while taking the IQ test by any one of dozens of (legitimate) reasons.
- cdh 7y agoIt is almost certainly legal to hire based on assessments of intelligence. If I insisted in a job interview that 4+9=12, the moon is simply a sky-reflection of the lights from Manhattan, and that I can’t stand to be in the same room as tall people since they affect gravity in disturbing ways, you would draw conclusions about my intelligence. Would you then avoid hiring me? IQ tests might be illegal under some circumstances, but I would point out that they are not a reliable measure of intelligence anyways, making this all a bit of a moot point.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoInteresting read, as was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ricci_v._DeStefano https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ricci_v._DeStefano I'm glad I don't have to worry about hiring. Seems like employers are caught in a catch-22.
- tchaffee 7y agoIt's not effectively illegal. That's a mis-characterization of both current law and that lawsuit in particular. The court ruled that "the company's employment requirements did not pertain to applicants' ability to perform the job". And it was more specific than that. If such tests disparately impact ethnic minority groups, businesses must demonstrate that such tests are "reasonably related" to the job for which the test is required. That does not make IQ tests effectively illegal. Demonstrate that anyone with an IQ lower than X cannot perform the job in question, and you're good. The actual "problem" is that other tests are far better at determining if you will do well in a job role. So companies use the better tests. If there were a job for which IQ was highly related to being able to do the job, then companies would surely use IQ as the test for that job. To give a concrete example, why would I give a programmer an IQ test when I can give them a programming test? I'll take it further: an extremely high IQ is a deficit for many developer roles. Most of the genius programmers I personally know write code no one else can maintain, and are often condescending - usually without even knowing it, which hurts team moral. I love those guys and they often inspire me, but many of them would make bad employees if the job required writing average business programs on a large team. A programming test would reveal that when you see their code is very clever, and also includes an internal compiler so they can write the solution in a high level language they invented... There is good reason my very smartest programming friends are often unemployed. When a genius programmer is called for though, boy do they shine. So it's not a case of companies avoiding the use of a good test due the law and replacing that good test with less effective proxies, as you first suggested. The real effect of that ruling and the law is that companies use tests that can be proven to demonstrate whether or not you can perform the job. That's better for everyone.