4 ms·
The problem is that generally people use these kinds of articles to extrapolate from group to individual--and that's generally not a good idea. Individuals bre
by bsder 7y ago
The problem is that generally people use these kinds of articles to extrapolate from group to individual--and that's generally not a good idea.
Individuals break "typical" all the time.
If I'm interviewing you for a job, I shouldn't apply "group stereotype" as I'm specifically looking for your individual traits that break the norm. I don't want the "average" from your group--I probably want someone far from it.
So the arrow from individual to aggregate group is generally strong. The reverse arrow from aggregate group to individual, however, has nowhere near the same strength.
- travisoneill1 7y agoThe article seems to say that the difference here is strong enough that you can do that: > To put this number in context, a D= 2.10 means a classification accuracy of 85%. In other words, their data suggests that the probability that a randomly picked individual will be correctly classified as male or female based on knowledge of their global personality profile is 85% (after correcting for the unreliability of the personality tests).
- elyobo 7y agoThe article suggests that you can do the opposite of that (use traits of the individual to reasonably accurately infer that they're male or female). The parent's concern is that, given you know someone is male or female, you will make further assumptions about them based on their group membership rather than their individual traits, something that is not supported by the article. > I am a strong believer that individual differences are more important than sex differences.
- travisoneill1 7y agoBut the only case where you would rely on group membership is if the individual traits are unknown. Obviously generalization will never be as accurate as individual knowledge. Why would anybody be worried that people would act otherwise?
- elyobo 7y agoAssuming things about individuals based on group membership is a key part of racism, sexism, etc. Why would anybody be worried? Because people do it all the time.
- CuriouslyC 7y agoStereotypes exist because there are statistical patterns in groups of people. Those stereotypes are useful cognitive tools while they remain accurate. It certainly isn't fair to people in those groups who don't fit the stereotype, but as long as the stereotype accurately describes the majority, there's nothing to be done about it. Would you run up to a lion or a tiger in the wild and try to hug and kiss it? I'm guessing you have a stereotype of big cats as dangerous predators, and you'd steer well clear, even though there are countless friendly lions and tigers in captivity that have never hurt anyone.
- emmelaich 7y agoAre you saying that with a high accuracy, you'd feel comfortable treating an individual according to their group? I don't want to appear too argumentative; it's just not exactly clear what you mean when you write > .. difference here is strong enough that you can do that
- falcolas 7y agoDo you not do that? When you are first approaching someone you don't know, do you not take their expressed gender into account in how you make the initial greeting? Would you offer a woman the exact same handshake you'd offer a guy? How would you approach someone who doesn't fit the norms - for example a male bodybuilder in drag? Does your brain hiccup for a moment when considering how to greet them? Mine does.
- emmelaich 7y agoI'm sure I do act a little differently, but I try very hard not to. Especially if I work with them or have some influence over their future.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoThis is a poor excuse, and I do not buy that people “generally” do this. It’s plainly obvious what people mean when they discuss averages and trends, and this hypersensitivity and paranoia that they might also hold those beliefs as universally applicable to every member of a group, and thus must be silenced, is not something we should accept.
- tchaffee 7y agoIf you put it in historical context it's neither hypersensitive nor paranoid. People did and do hold beliefs as universally applicable to every member of a group. Women were not allowed to vote in the USA less than 100 years ago. Only in the 1960s did it became illegal to request a specific gender in job advertisements. And it was only in 1974 that it became illegal to discriminate using gender in credit matters, including being able to obtain and use credit cards. Plenty of people still use average and trends as an excuse to claim a gender (or race) is not as capable at some skill or career. It's not even that hard to find. Probably pretty easy actually in the US states that require creationism to be taught in public school. > and thus must be silenced Where did the parent comment say discussing averages must be silenced?
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoThose examples are not indications that people hold beliefs as universally applicable, especially those that were 100 years ago. Also, most auto insurance still discriminates against men, especially young unmarried men, and we know for certain that’s not because every actuary with authority at every insurance company is under the impression that the increased risk is applicable to every single member. Likewise for life insurance that asks about age and smoking. In case it needs to be said, there is a major difference between believing traits are universally applicable (which nobody believes) and believing that because something is true on average, that this is valid justification to discriminate against the whole group. If someone makes the claim that a given trait is true on average, and therefore discrimination against a group is justified, only then should the discussion focus on that. Otherwise, it’s logically inconsistent, hypocritical, and even a little ironic to suggest or even suspect that individual’s line of inquiry is in any way connected to them suggesting or even suspecting a diminished capability from you (or any other specific person) as an individual. > Plenty of people still use average and trends as an excuse to claim a gender (or race) is not as capable at some skill or career. It's not even that hard to find. I’ve never seen this claim being made personally, and I don’t believe it happens with any significant prevalence, at least in the US. I could be wrong of course. I have seen many cases of people claiming that someone said it, only for the truth to come out that they actually did not.
- amluto 7y agoI think that as a policy matter (what interviewers should do or should even be allowed to do), a stronger claim can be made. Suppose there are some groups A1 and A2 (men vs women, different races, etc — there could be A3, etc). Then I would argue that, regardless of whether the groups have substantial differences affecting qualification for the job, group membership or perceived group membership should not be allowed as a substitute for individual qualification. So, as an extreme example, if a job requires heavy lifting and short or contained hair, then an applicant should not be preferred because they’re male. Obviously there are nuances here. If the groups are actually job qualifications (hiring a singer based on vocal range, for example), then none of this applies. There are surely plenty of gray areas, too. Gender doesn’t fit cleanly into a pair of groups. Sometimes it might be very hard to measure actual aptitude, and proxies of various quality are needed. College admissions are an example of the latter — you can’t measure how well someone can do, so admissions departments use proxies of varying quality and social acceptability. As for gender differences, if I’m hiring someone, I believe that it doesn’t matter whether one gender is likely to be more qualified for any reason — if I’m hiring, I have an obligation to consider the applicant as an individual regardless of gender.
- falcolas 7y ago> if I’m hiring, I have an obligation to consider the applicant as an individual regardless of gender. Since it's illegal to hire based on the results of an IQ test in the US, we have to come up with other proxies for it. So, we use stereotypes that are associated intelligent individuals as filtering criteria. Gender provides one of those stereotypes - in both directions. Men have traditionally not been considered for jobs like nursing or caretaking. Women have traditionally not been considered for jobs which require physical strength or analytical skills. But back to your original premise: when you're evaluating hundreds, or thousands, of applications for a single opening, you're going to fall back on stereotypes, because it's too much work to do otherwise. Gap in employment longer than a few months? Skills have expired. Lots of job hopping after 6-18 months? Unreliable. Only has worked for companies known for their physical labor? Not capable of working in an office. A short job history with no college? Not smart enough. Even though every single one of those is potentially wrong, it's also potentially correct. If you need to weed 100 applications down to 10 for phone interviews in the next hour, can you really afford to give each of the 100 applicants the benefit of the doubt? EDIT: Removed "intelligence", replaced with "the results of an IQ test", which is what I meant originally. Apologies.
- mpweiher 7y ago> generally people use these kinds of articles to extrapolate from group to individual As the article quotes: "People might be more reasonable than you think" Or in other words: Citation needed. Please check out Lee Jussim's work on Stereotype Accuracy[1]. His research shows that not only are stereotypes highly accurate (according to him one of the strongest effects in social psychology), but people only use them when they have no other information available. As soon as they obtain information about the individual in front of them, that information takes precedence over the stereotype. [1] http://www.spsp.org/news-center/blog/stereotype-accuracy-response http://www.spsp.org/news-center/blog/stereotype-accuracy-res...
- int_19h 7y ago> The problem is that generally people use these kinds of articles to extrapolate from group to individual--and that's generally not a good idea. Conversely, people assume that any studies or discussions that even tangentially touch upon this are meant to encourage extrapolation from group to individual (even if they explicitly state the opposite, this is dismissed as lip service).