4 ms·
It's a major embarrassment for humanity that we've created an astonishing library system – books in scanned or native digital format, inexpensive smartphones/e-
by musicale 7y ago
It's a major embarrassment for humanity that we've created an astonishing library system – books in scanned or native digital format, inexpensive smartphones/e-reader devices, and the internet – that could give billions of people on the planet the ability to read nearly any book ever published essentially for free, but for narrow business reasons we're doing the best we can to prevent that eventuality from ever happening.
To protect their own business interests, publishers (and their technical accomplices) have invented crippled digital formats that try to destroy the most fundamental and beneficial advantages of e-books: free transmission and duplication, and the ability of one library copy to be read by millions simultaneously.
We have built the library of Alexandria and made it big enough to serve the entire world, but instead of burning it down we just lock the door so that nobody can get in.
- LittlePeter 7y agoWeren't most of those books created to begin with for "narrow business reasons"?
- sam_lowry_ 7y agoNope
- mbar84 7y agoDo you believe in copyright law? Maybe you're part of the problem. https://questioncopyright.org/ https://questioncopyright.org/
- pjc50 7y agoSure, but how are writers to get paid? It's hardly the most lucrative business to start with.
- VvR-Ox 7y agoProbably like musicians and a lot of them use platforms to publish their songs to listen to for free to gain momentum and attract enough people who will be delighted to get a Vinyl (in case of books it would be a hard cover). When I personally used pirated stuff it was because I couldn't afford to buy it or there was no other possibility to get a digital copy that is easier to search and transport. It is only greed that is stopping our world from becoming something with all the good features of series like "Star Trek" including access to all those books for free. The greedy people think they can gain even more money by forcing poor people to buy their stuff by punishing them. The greedy who have money influence governments to make laws against this piracy and investigate against them with public money. In the end the poor can still not afford to buy the books, music etc. and will just be punished which costs more public money than giving them free access in the first place. This is just another thing that is very wrong in our world.
- dsabanin 7y agoI think you should become the change you want to see in the world and stop charging for your work. I wonder how that will go.
- leggomylibro 7y agoA lot of people on this forum probably are pretty happy-go-lucky with their negotiating. The difference between $200k and $300k is a lot, but I see a lot of unattached young people not really caring. Ironically, it seems much smaller than the difference between $20k and $30k. But most artists don't have people breaking their door down to compete for their time. And anyways, coding is a creative profession; I'm sure that plenty of techies are aspiring artists who didn't like their odds. I'm surprised that more people don't see exclusively 'ex post facto' rewards as a sort of corrupting influence on the creation of art, rather than a motivator.
- pjc50 7y ago> The difference between $200k and $300k is a lot, but I see a lot of unattached young people not really caring. In which context do you see that? > ex post facto' rewards as a sort of corrupting influence on the creation of art So ... Patronage only? Commissions only?
- VvR-Ox 7y agoIf the world was more like disney imagines it to be then this could be possible. Or your parents are very rich and you don't have to pay rent etc. for yourself. But in the end artists just like open source maintainers need money to pay their food and most of them can't afford to stop charging for their work. I would love to do that but I can't afford it so I won't. If the system changes and the government gives every citizen 1k $ / month we can start this discussion again because I would really much appreciate to do things that I like without having to take money for my work.
- Synaesthesia 7y agoI think it’s been found that people who pirate a lot of music, often buy a lot too, and just because libraries existed, people didn’t stop buying books, in fact it might even encourage it.
- Cephalopterus 7y agoIt's kind of like the insane amount of privacy of Adobe products is what gave them their current near absolute monopoly over the entire market. A huge number of today's graphic designers started off with pirated copies of Photoshop only to start using legitimate copies once employed, be it cause they purchased a license or because their employers paid for a seat. Without piracy, which was essentially a for education free trial of sorts many graphic designers would probably be using other free or cheaper alternatives
- Multicomp 7y agoI'm curious how long that state will continue, because after all with creative cloud, even students are having to pay an exorbitant amount of money in order to learn how to use the software. Pirating CS6 can only go on so long, right? After a while its ui will simply be too out of date compared to the current cc offering right?
- RandomBacon 7y agoInteresting thought. How is GIMP coming along these days? Any other open source projects people recommend?
- FreeFull 7y agoBlender is one of the best pieces of 3D modelling software on the market, and it's open source.
- Invictus0 7y agoSell paper books
- pjc50 7y agoThose are also pirated, even on Amazon itself.
- Koremat6666 7y ago> but for narrow business reasons we're doing the best we can to prevent that eventuality from ever happening. Authors are motivated to write books because of money. A lot of authors who are not make their books available for free in pdf and other formats. Almost all ORielly books are found as pdfs on internet too.