3 ms·
Always interesting to see Gell-Mann at work. My knowledge of public health is indirect, but my dad spent his entire career in that sector. The article's portray
by rayiner 7y ago
Always interesting to see Gell-Mann at work. My knowledge of public health is indirect, but my dad spent his entire career in that sector. The article's portrayal of the public sector versus the private sector is slanted.
Here is a fact that many people don't want to admit but is widely acknowledged within the public health sector: UN organizations like the WHO are indispensable, but also among the most bureaucratic, ineffective, and inefficient entities on the planet. There is a reason that the impetus for hiring McKinsey came from inside the WHO itself. Private-sector organizations like Gates Foundation have been welcomed into the field not only because of their resources, but because of their effectiveness and organizational capabilities.
The second point is that governments in developing countries are corrupt and direct aid money is quickly siphoned off and dissipated.
The third point, following from the first two, is that the United States' foreign aid efforts have always relied heavily on consultants and public-private partnerships, and have been extremely effective. Say, for example, USAID wants to address infant mortality in Bangladesh. It doesn't give money directly to Bangladesh. It gives money to a consulting firm, which hires "boots on the ground" (doctors, etc.) and secures supplies. USAID and the consulting firm then work closely with the health ministry in Bangladesh to execute the vaccine program. This structure works quite well: in Bangladesh, for example, it has been instrumental in reducing infant mortality and improving family planning.
The issue with McKinsey, etc., is not that they're "secretive" or "for-profit entities." It's that they have little experience in the sector compared to specialized consulting companies who have been doing that sort of work for decades.