6 ms·
I know it's kind of a tangent, but I want to point out that Google is serviced by an army of workers that wear special uniforms, are not included in the major p
by carapace 7y ago
I know it's kind of a tangent, but I want to point out that Google is serviced by an army of workers that wear special uniforms, are not included in the major perks, are trained not to fraternize with the rest of Google's employees, and are of a markedly different racial and cultural makeup than the rest of Google's employees.
Also, remember that time that Google, Apple, and "dozens" of other companies colluded to prevent each other from hiring talent from each other, in large part to defraud their own employees of opportunities (to the tune of an estimated $8,000,000,000)?
So it seems like there's a small group at the top that does whatever the hell they think they can get away with, then a large group in the middle that is more-or-less exploited by the top group, and another large group on the bottom that are more-or-less totally fungible and who are almost completely ignored by design by the other two groups.
Most of the people in the "middle" group are either clueless about their exploitation, or complacent, and what we're seeing in TFA is a fraction of the former becoming the latter. I suppose a tiny fraction of people might actually quit Google over this.
(I worked at the Google-plex for a couple of years as a TVA, a kind of half-life role in between a normal Googler and a service staff. It was a very weird experience, and afterward it felt like I had been kidnapped by aliens and returned to Earth.)
- anarchodev 7y agoI really appreciate you connecting the struggle of the tech workers in google to those in other industries which don't enjoy a lot of the same freedoms. Understanding of this is severely lacking in tech, and once we develop it I think solidarity will build exponentially. It's high time google workers unionized, and that includes ALL workers -- not just those in the engineering org.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- LarryDarrell 7y agoI don't think Anand Giridharadas will be invited back at Google Talks. https://youtu.be/d_zt3kGW1NM?t=2900 https://youtu.be/d_zt3kGW1NM?t=2900
- carapace 7y agoI didn't watch the whole thing (yet) but the part that you link to is spot on: If the Google top brass or the rank-and-file wanted to give the service workers a better break they could do it overnight, it just costs money, and not enough people care or notice. The first comment on the video has some context (if you take it at face value): > Google initially decided, for the first time in its history, to not publish this video to its Talks at Google site here on YouTube after it was recorded. This presentation was given on the second week of September, note the publishing time lag. Giridharadas contacted Google to ask why, and his contact said "I'm not on that team anymore" and was blown off. He then leaked the story to a leading tech journalist, who started calling Google for comment because she was working on a story about why, for the first time ever, a Talks at Google video was not published. They published it the same week
- CydeWeys 7y agoFor what it's worth, Talks at Google talks are often enough not posted online. This definitely wouldn't have been the first, or unprecedented. For example, I saw an in-person Talks at Google with Doug Stanhope where he said a lot of offensive shit, swore a lot, and made the audience feel uncomfortable. That one was never posted online.
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoIf you could find that, I would absolutely love to see it. Doug is my favorite stand up and that sounds hysterical.
- CydeWeys 7y agoIt wasn't posted. There's nothing for me to find. It's not like I sat there recording it on my cell phone.
- weiming 7y ago> is serviced by an army of workers that wear special uniforms, are not included in the major perks Isn't this about government (IRS et al.) categorization of contractors vs. employees and not about GOOG specifically? IIRC there is a specific reason contractors cannot receive employee perks or even participate in team morale events.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ggm 7y agoDo you not think it says something, nobody much talks about google having worker-ants in uniforms? The IRS issue is why they have to wear a yellow star, yes. But the question is not that they wear the star its what the fuck is the culture which normalizes this
- seneca 7y ago> Do you not think it says something, nobody much talks about google having worker-ants in uniforms? No, not really. It says that people realize that low skill work isn't valued the same as high skill work. That's exactly what anyone with a basic understanding of economics would expect. It's not a human rights issue that people that are easier to recruit and replace aren't offered the same perks. > wear a yellow star This is so hyperbolic as to be offensive. Comparing people in a voluntary employment role to the victims of the holocaust is incredibly tone deaf and hysterical.
- ggm 7y agoIf a company insists a class of workers wear uniforms and a huge primary cohort do not, then the hyperbole is grounded in a fundamental problem. The uniform exists to mark them out. The function of the uniform is not to their benefit, it's to their detriment. The origin of the yellow star was functionally identical: mark the tainted that the righteous shall know them.
- 7y ago
- soup10 7y agoAnother way to looking at it is the upper-middleclass at google is riding a large wave of ad-tech/search money and have comfortable jobs for relatively little grind and risk compared to other companies.
- lanius 7y agoWhat is a TVA?
- carapace 7y agoYou know, I never actually knew what it stood for. It's the same dodge as the service contractors, but for programmers: You're technically an employee of a separate company that then contracts your labor back to Google. It's a big open secret loophole to pay less in taxes and in overall benefits. E.g. you work in the same buildings, ride the same buses, and eat the same food, but enough of a "fire-wall" is maintained between you and the "real" Googlers to satisfy the government that you're not legally an employee of Google. The project I worked on was so inefficient that I suspect that Google is simply big enough and rich enough to sequester talented programmers just to keep them from working for competitors.
- lonelappde 7y agoHow do contractors cost less taxes??
- drdeadringer 7y agoI wonder if "TVC" was intended instead, which stands for "Temp, Vendor, Contractor". If "TVA" is what was intended, I have no idea. This is the first time ever I've heard "TVA", let alone in relation to Google's unofficial workforce.
- carapace 7y agoOh, er, derp, yeah. "C", TVC. Sorry about that.
- d1zzy 7y agoFull time employees are around 100k with TVAs at around 120k. Yes, TVAs are more numerous and they enjoy different perks/benefits/etc (they aren't Google employees technically so that's not surprising) but we aren't talking about a 10% "elite" vs 90% "plebs" here.
- carapace 7y agoTo be clear, I left out the TVAs in the above breakdown (or lumped them in depending on your POV). So: ~0.1% elites, N% Googlers-of-the-line, M% TVAs, P% service workers, where N+M+P ~= 99.9%
- LIV2 7y agoI guess even in California rich privileged people like class seperation
- perl4ever 7y agoHow does this differ from other organizations? Places I've worked or interviewed at outsource things like cleaning offices or running the mailroom. Are you saying that Google has their own employees do that stuff, but they are a separate class/caste? Does Google also have significant numbers of temps from staffing agencies, or other contractors?
- carapace 7y agoThat's (part of) my point: Google isn't some egalitarian techno-utopia. You could, say, have a policy that the lowest-paid employees have a floor of 1/7th the pay of the highest-paid employees, like the janitor makes $100k and the CEO makes $700K, or whatever.
- perl4ever 7y agoIf they have low-paid employees in house where other companies don't, then their stats on inequality could look worse while in reality, there is less inequality.