4 ms·
If you stop insurance companies assessing risk then there will be no insurance industry.
by tonyedgecombe 7y ago
If you stop insurance companies assessing risk then there will be no insurance industry.
- teekert 7y agoIf you let them be free to do what they want poor people (or at least some people) will never be insured. But I guess that is the basis of the US healthcare system... how is that working out?
- jaredklewis 7y agoWhy is it the responsibility of private insurance companies to look after society’s most vulnerable? I think it is a much more sensible arrangement that insurance companies are free to operate as they see fit and that the government be responsible for the well being of its poorest citizens. Should grocery and clothing stores be required to feed and clothe the poor, respectively? To me, this feels like a shrinking of government duties onto businesses.
- teekert 7y agoI guess it depends on the market, healthcare is not a free market as you can never say: "Guess I'll die.", no rational human does that. Moreover, the single drug people require is often patented and thus monopolized. But people will say: "Guess I won't buy a Hugo Boss suit." I guess you can go the route of government sponsored insurance (and everybody know governments hardly negotiate as they can print money) or you make laws and keep tight control over what insurance companies can and can't do.
- klyrs 7y ago> Why is it the responsibility of private insurance companies to look after society’s most vulnerable? Because drivers are required by law, in many jurisdictions, to have insurance.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoShould you be providing them with free cars as well? Where do you draw the line?
- danShumway 7y ago> Why is it the responsibility of private insurance companies to look after society’s most vulnerable This sounds like an argument for nationalized insurance, which may have been the point you were trying to make. Was that the intention?
- shkkmo 7y agoThat doesn't mean you have to let them assess risk based on incidental information that should be private. Assessing vehicle accident risk on your driving record is fine, assessing it based on who your friends are is not.
- aianus 7y agoApparently we’ve decided it’s ok to assess my risk based on my penis or lack thereof. Oh and my wife or lack thereof too. What a joke.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI think there is an EU ruling that says insurance companies can't discriminate based on genitals. In reality it didn't work because there were many other variables that are correlated with gender such as profession or types of car driven. In the end the gap between prices has actually increased.
- bildung 7y agoIt would only be the end of riskless profits. The very point of an insurance is making high cost, low probability situations managable through the law of large numbers. Reintroducing individual factors is not needed per se, and also introduces both costs (you have to employ people assessing the risks/ building the models) and discrimination. As public health care systems in other countries show skipping the risk management part can actually be cheaper for the insuree, overall. Edit: This is also how the first insurances worked: as mutual insurance companies. In other words: This type of insurance actually was the foundation of the insurance industry.
- Pigo 7y agoI don't think that sounds too bad. There's very few things in modern life that bothers me more than insurance. Somehow humans used to get by, helping each other out when times were tough. I guess we're too bought in now to go back, but a healthy, single person can dream of not subsidizing teenagers livestreaming behind the wheel & overpriced medicine and unnecessary medical tests.
- Balgair 7y ago> Somehow humans used to get by, helping each other out when times were tough Not a big fan of history?[0] I've not run the grep on that data, but there aren't many years that didn't have an armed conflict going on (in just Europe). If anything, humans have only recently started helping each other to really any lasting degree. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Europe
- Pigo 7y agoI'm talking about when communities used to help individuals when they had a fire, a bad harvest, lost someone. Helping each other out on a smaller scale. That along with the church (which is why they had tax exemption) used to be our safety net. People still fell threw the cracks if they were in the wrong community, but a lot could be said for how poorly the system works now.
- Balgair 7y agoI mean, the lens of history is firmly nearsighted on the aristocracy, so we don't have a lot of good data on the normal folk. But smaller communities were not any more or less nice than the larger ones. People are still just people. One somewhat clear example is the Huguenot riots of France after the Medieval warm period [0]. Towns would routinely tear themselves apart. Another is actual Socrates. He was killed for teaching the youth 'bad' things, essentially [1]. I'm not saying that people did not help each other out in times of stress. But I am saying that they did fly apart and go all murdery too. The past was not less rosy than the present, as far as we can tell. That lesson is very important, it means we have have power in our own lives and that our choice, your's and mine, have a lot of effects on those around us. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huguenot_rebellions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huguenot_rebellions [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_of_Socrates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_of_Socrates