11 ms·
This is why privacy and regulating information asymmetries is so important. Consider ML model that picks 1,000 people for every 10,000 and 99% of those sele
by nabla9 7y ago
This is why privacy and regulating information asymmetries is so important.
Consider ML model that picks 1,000 people for every 10,000 and 99% of those selected are false positives. Insurance fee is $100 and average payment is $50,000.
Rejecting those 1,000 people is $100,000 less revenue and saving $500,000 in payments. It's no brainier to reject people and let there be statistical accidents.
Insurance companies can make profit using models that have huge number of false positives. If your insurance company or bank is allowed to use all data it collects to make model of you, it leads to Kafkaesque world.
"Why my insurance premium jumped 200% and I can't afford it anymore?" Nobody knows that the reason is your dried out flower in garage widow visible to the street.
"Why I can't get mortgage?" You have too many Facebook friends with risk of defaulting and one has criminal record. Select your friends better.
- londons_explore 7y agoWill you lend me $1k? Probably not - you don't even know me. Would you lend a close friend $1k? Maybe, if they really needed it. This is an example of you discriminating based on what you know about me/them. Should such discrimination be made illegal?
- shkkmo 7y agoMaking such "friend-to-friend" lending a major part of the financing infrastructure in the US, it would clearly lead to strong economic and racial disparities. You don't have to make that kind of stuff illegal, but you also need to make sure that you don't base important parts of your economic systems on such biased processes.
- tclancy 7y agoOne has nothing to do with the other. A corporation has no friends.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoIf you stop insurance companies assessing risk then there will be no insurance industry.
- teekert 7y agoIf you let them be free to do what they want poor people (or at least some people) will never be insured. But I guess that is the basis of the US healthcare system... how is that working out?
- jaredklewis 7y agoWhy is it the responsibility of private insurance companies to look after society’s most vulnerable? I think it is a much more sensible arrangement that insurance companies are free to operate as they see fit and that the government be responsible for the well being of its poorest citizens. Should grocery and clothing stores be required to feed and clothe the poor, respectively? To me, this feels like a shrinking of government duties onto businesses.
- teekert 7y agoI guess it depends on the market, healthcare is not a free market as you can never say: "Guess I'll die.", no rational human does that. Moreover, the single drug people require is often patented and thus monopolized. But people will say: "Guess I won't buy a Hugo Boss suit." I guess you can go the route of government sponsored insurance (and everybody know governments hardly negotiate as they can print money) or you make laws and keep tight control over what insurance companies can and can't do.
- klyrs 7y ago> Why is it the responsibility of private insurance companies to look after society’s most vulnerable? Because drivers are required by law, in many jurisdictions, to have insurance.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoShould you be providing them with free cars as well? Where do you draw the line?
- danShumway 7y ago
- sailfast 7y agoA more realistic scenario is "why is my insurance more expensive than the new lower rate that everyone else is now getting? I used to pay the same amount as everybody else." If the models improve, you get lower costs provided there is robust competition in the industry. That's why people let insurers drive in their cars now with them via an app to get lower rates. That said - the main issue that creates the Kafkaesque world you speak of is poor correlation analysis. In the short term the insurer doesn't suffer due to false positives. Over time, however, to grow their market base you would expect that they start to test whether their analysis is actually reducing risk. With ML this presents a problem because they may not actually know why profiles are high at some point. Denying financing is different than not lowering insurance rates, to be sure, and would also be looked at differently. I'm having trouble deciding where the slope starts getting slippery here as I hate the idea of some bad week of lawn care causing financial stresses for so many reasons - but insurers also already do all of this with a smaller dataset. I wouldn't assume net rate increases - but I'm not sure if that should impact our overall thinking on the problem. EDIT: > The paper abstract itself calls out where it gets slippery: "From this perspective, public availability of house images raises legal and social concerns, as they can be a proxy of ethnicity, religion and other sensitive data."
- mrandish 7y ago> If your insurance company or bank is allowed to use all data it collects to make model of you, it leads to Kafkaesque world. I reflexively agreed with what you wrote then I started thinking more about it, playing some likely scenarios through in my head, and now I'm not sure it necessarily ends in too bad of a place. My reasoning: Ultimately, risk estimation has to actually reflect reality to be economically sustainable. Insurance is a highly competitive marketplace with low switching costs and relatively low barriers to entry. I've been driving for several decades and have only been involved in a couple of accidents, none of which were remotely attributable to me. I think I'm very low risk, yet I pay what seems to be fairly high premiums. I suspect low-risk drivers like myself are subsidizing higher-risk drivers due to the expense and inaccuracy of more accurately pricing forward risk. So, taken as a general concept, more accurate risk assessment done more efficiently enables the actual risk component of insurance priced more fairly and higher efficiency actuarial estimation reduces the overhead cost of providing the overall insurance 'product' to a consumer. Broadly speaking, these are net positives. In terms of how it's done, I think that the market will react to pricing changes such that there will be insurance companies who promote the fact that they don't use XYZ risk estimation process, much as some Las Vegas casinos advertise that they only use single decks in blackjack vs six decks, increasing the appeal to card counters.
- nabla9 7y agoCounterargument: Imagine insurance company with perfect foresight. Private insurance makes money by managing risk. But must be a limits of how they manage that risk in consumer markets. Insurance is pooling the risk so that it's manageable. There is equilibrium. Trying to argue that insurance companies should be allowed to discriminate any way they can make profit is not a good idea.
- cardiffspaceman 7y ago> Counterargument: Imagine insurance company with perfect foresight. To put too fine a point on it, imagine insurance is a risk-free business. The only reason to try to buy it is to see if you have a risk. If they reject you, plan your finances accordingly, I guess.