2 ms·
> You’d have to inspect every packet on the internet to make sure it wasn’t using strong encryption keys. You’d have to ban every kind of decentralized network.
by rayiner 7y ago
> You’d have to inspect every packet on the internet to make sure it wasn’t using strong encryption keys. You’d have to ban every kind of decentralized network.
Upfront bias: I’m against encryption backdoor. But the article is arguing against a straw man. Nobody is proposing to ban encryption. (That would be a first amendment issue.) They’re proposing to require companies to include encryption back doors in commercial products. That doesn’t regulate speech, it regulates the design of products.
“Speech” within the scope of the first amendment protects the communication of a message or idea. That is broad, but the thing that is protected is the communication of a message. Thus, the government cannot ban you from encrypted speech. But it can certainly ban Apple from making iPhones that contain encrypted communications features, for the same reason it can ban cars without seatbelts. While code can be speech, in that context the code isn’t communicating a message but rather providing functionality.