4 ms·
Where and why are you guys still seeing/using shortened URLs? I don't think I've personally made a shortened URL since Twitter built one into their service, and
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
Where and why are you guys still seeing/using shortened URLs? I don't think I've personally made a shortened URL since Twitter built one into their service, and I stopped seeing shortened URLs around the same time.
There are two exceptions:
• I still see service-specific short URLs, e.g. goo.gl, nyti.ms, etc. Because these can only be created by the service in question, they don't introduce security/privacy concerns.
• When a URL shortener is used to create a sort of vanity link to e.g. a Google doc. (OP's service could be useful for these!)
Outside of those times... why would you use a URL shortener? When are you limited by number of characters?
- kick 7y ago• I still see service-specific short URLs, e.g. goo.gl, nyti.ms, etc. Because these can only be created by the service in question, they don't introduce security/privacy concerns. This isn't necessarily true; I've seen companies that offer to do the 'custom shortlink' thing for various companies. It's safe to assume that there are privacy concerns with at least some of them.
- tyingq 7y agoBitly runs nyti.ms, so yes, you aren't trusting just the NYT.
- tyingq 7y agoI use one inside of a big corp so I can put memorable urls like myco.co/news on posters or email signatures. Especially when the real url is some terrible long thing I cannot control, like some internal wiki.
- Terretta 7y agoIf you use an tracker blocker, you’ll find a slew of app to app and site to site links and callbacks fail because they went through a tracker that sometimes is a short URL service, but often just a long URL redirector. These are definitely not curated by the service in question. On iOS, examples include: [business].app.link [business].onelink.me [hash].ulink.adjust.com [business].bttn.io branch.io etc... Link shorteners are a subclass of this, that do something useful (shorten link) while doing something unhelpful (obscuring the link). But it’s all the same problem.
- syrrim 7y agoSome subreddits use them to track which links people click on in their sidebar. /r/listentothis in particular.
- iudqnolq 7y agoI use them all the time to transfer URLs between devices that enxode a lot of state in a long url. For example, Firefox Send pits the password in the URL. Of course, I'd never do this with something I didn't watch associated with me.
- l1am0 7y agoLink shorteners are also used to ubfuscate tracking urls. E.g you can hide https://fb.com/?utm_source=hackernews&other_tracking_parameter=trackallot https://fb.com/?utm_source=hackernews&other_tracking_paramet... behind a nice looking bit.ly/fb url. In my research I also found that it is a quite nice thing for phishing to fool you into opening a shady website.
- type0 7y agoOn youtube every so often complementary materials are linked via shortened urls, but youtube also tracks those in turn via their redirect urls.
- BruiseLee 7y agoSMS spam.