2 ms·
In an effort to make sense of the phrase, what you are saying seems to boil down to "it's a veil as in the veil is protecting the investors". Who thinks the roo
by perl4ever 7y ago
In an effort to make sense of the phrase, what you are saying seems to boil down to "it's a veil as in the veil is protecting the investors". Who thinks the root cause was a conspiracy among the shareholders of FB?
- dredmorbius 7y agoThat's not quite what I'm saying. Or possibly more accurately, I don't think that's what I'm saying. 1. I'm still working through my thoughts on this. 2. The key point is not "corporate veil" but "legal and operational concept of corporate structure as a risk externalisation engine". Under that second, the "corporate veil" is a part, but not all, of the externalisation mechanism. And would make the short response to your reframing: "No". More subtly, it's not essentially necessary for the externalisation to be a deliberate strategy -- a conspiracy -- though that probably is often the case. There are emergent phenomena a and behaviours, and given that risk externalisation is, in both the short and medium terms, generally, profitable (that is, it decreases costs and increases revenues), there's a natural self-selection among firms, managers, and behaviours toward such structures and behaviours, and those who follow them, consciously or not. If you're looking at specific legal or risk concepts, you'll probably want to examine the notions of moral and morale hazard, attractive nuisance, negligence, malfeasance, and the like. The notions of willful ignorance and motivated reasoning as well. These issues get less play than they should, and comprise a major weakness to the market-capitalist model. Though of course they're also present in other organisational models of central control. Organisational models which are immune or resistant to centralisation and concentrations of power, ownership, and/or control would probably fare better, though these are difficult to arrive at and sustain. The reason this challenges the general notions of markets includes both generally understood principles, and possibly some that are novel, or at least less considered: - Moral and morale hazard -- changes in behaviours based on a changed individual risk profile. For a discussion see: https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/032615/what-difference-between-moral-hazard-and-morale-hazard.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/032615/what-differe... - The correspondence between wealth and power, best captured in Smith's uncharacteristically suscinct quip in Wealth of Nations: "Wealth, as Mr Hobbes says, is power." - The dual problems of principle-agent and regulatory capture. Though often viewed independently, I see these as largely the private- and public-sector variants of the same underlying behaviour: individuals acting for personal gain rather than institutional benefit. Corruption generally. - Classic informational asymmetries: At a given point in time, two (or more) agents having unequal amounts of information concerning a transaction or state of offairs. Akerloff, "The Market for Lemons". - Temporal informational asymmetries: The development of fuller understanding, particularly as concerns unforseen consequences, emergent phenomena, or latent (as opposed to manifest) properties or aspects, over time, to all agent (though also often with an imbalance between agents). Robert K. Merton, etc. - The risk-immunity of size. If an organisation has both resources and cost or operational structures to survive negative circumstances, then in a period of contraction, less-capable organisations will fail whilst the larger survive. Size does not always correspond to the capacity to absorb risks, but often does. - Motivated asset inflation or value assurance. The tendency of those holding some valuable or income-generating property or system, to seek to further appreciate its value in ways that reduce social wealth growth. Bernhard J. Stern's "Resistances to the Adoption of Technological Innovations" (1937), and NIMBYism, are key examples. - Various blame- and liability-shifting practices, including as described above. NDAs, non-competes, anti-poaching practices, and the like, would be others. - Practices generally seen as immoral, unethical, or illegal: coercion, product bundling and tying, exclusive dealing, product dumping, and the like. Sorry that's not a short answer, though I feel it's more accurate.