4 ms·
That's an interesting take on both Trump's and Bernie's campaigns. To at least some degree, I think it fits. But I was thinking about several percent of the c
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
That's an interesting take on both Trump's and Bernie's campaigns. To at least some degree, I think it fits.
But I was thinking about several percent of the country marching in the streets. That's not something we've seen yet.
- m0zg 7y ago>> several percent of the country marching in the streets Unlikely to happen here seeing that unemployment is at a 50 year low and wages are rising.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoBut some of those protests are in prosperous places. The economy has been getting better for a long time in Chile. Hong Kong isn't hurting, either - or at least wasn't until the start of the protests.
- m0zg 7y agoYou're right, these events are often triggered by a combination of factors, and repression of freedoms is often a factor. But I don't see any repression of freedoms either. But also consider that it is not necessary for things to be _uniformly_ bad to trigger a large protest. E.g. France is "prosperous" on paper, yet a substantial segment of its population is really hurting, and they blame the "progressive" policies of Macron et al for that.
- nopriorarrests 7y ago>Hong Kong isn't hurting I read some opinions about HK protests, and they were saying, basically, that HK youth has no chance to buy an apartment and live a good middle class life, hence the revolt. This is something that is not captured in GDP growth metric. To me it makes perfect sense. What is the point of, say, 5% GDP growth if you pay 1/2 of your salary as rent and will never accumulate enough dough for downpayment?
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoHmm. By that standard, chunks of the US are also tinder waiting for a match - the coastal cities because costs (housing in particular) are too high, and the heartland because incomes are too low.
- dragonwriter 7y agoHence, the rise in both authoritarian and progressive populism in the US.
- m0zg 7y agoIn what way is Trump "authoritarian"?
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago"Authoritarian" and "progressive" are not mutually exclusive. See, for example, Venezuela.
- dragonwriter 7y ago“Authoritarian populism” and “progressive populism” are widely-used names of particular political ideologies. While their etymology of course relates to the more general sense of, respectively, “authoritarian” and “progressive” in denoting political ideologies, in both cases the definition is not a simple combination of the general sense of one of those terms with the general sense of “populism”, but much narrower. Authoritarian populism is a particular subset of right-of-center populism and progressive populism is a particular subset of left-of-center populism, and they are, in fact, non-overlapping even if, arguably, “progressive” and “authoritarian” are not. (Similarly, “authoritarian populism” arguably is not even a subset of “authoritarianism”, though it at least overlaps with it.) > See, for example, Venezuela. “Progressive” and “socialist” aren't mutually exclusive, but neither does the latter imply the former; “progressive” and “authoritarian” might overlap, but Venezuela's government isn't an example as it isn't progressive.
- larnmar 7y agoThat’s the great thing about democracy, though — you don’t have to march in the streets to effect change, you can simply vote for it.
- davidw 7y agoUnless someone is fiddling with the election.
- CM30 7y agoTo some degree, the Trump and Bernie campaigns set back that sort of reaction. By offering alternatives that involved voting for a new type of candidate rather than marching in the street. If nothing much changes in terms of the status quo because of those politicians or their campaigns however, that's when you'll probably see the marches in the streets, protests, etc.