2 ms·
I also it turns out have ~20 years of blog content. There's a bunch of gaps in the middle for various reasons of data loss (some of which were probably more use
by WorldMaker 7y ago
I also it turns out have ~20 years of blog content. There's a bunch of gaps in the middle for various reasons of data loss (some of which were probably more useful than others), but beyond that I've tried to maintain as much as possible my internal links. At this point I have redirects in place to support link structures going back across two blog migrations (from a Drupal install to a custom Django blog to a much less custom Jekyll site). That's about where I feel my responsibility for link rot ends. I've done the best I can that if for some reason you find a /node/somerandomnumber link somewhere you still get redirected to whatever blog post that leads to even though I haven't used Drupal in over a decade. I've not been perfect in maintaining such redirects (there were some complex CMS sections I once had in Drupal I never bothered to migrate or became entirely new things; plus the aforementioned losses of data prior to that Drupal blog and whatever I'd managed to migrate into it from the other Drupal blog and crazier custom blogs that proceeded it, some of which back before blog was even a word), but I've tried my best. The onus the web asks for site admins is that we all collectively try our bests. It's not my responsibility to worry about external link rot out from my blog posts. I'll still lament it, as sometimes there are great losses, but I'm not the one that broke that link contract.
When I get a spammer asking me to fix a broken link I sometimes cry about whatever the web lost that they are bringing to my attention, but generally my only response is to suggest to the spammer that they file a Pull Request to my blog so I can more properly code review the suggested change. (Unsurprisingly, no spammer has actually bothered to take me up on that offer. It's unlikely I'd actually merge such a change in, but I'd love to see one try.)
- gwern 7y agoIt may not be your 'responsibility', whatever that means, and it would be nice if there was less link rot, but the fact remains: you provided those links because you thought they were relevant & useful for the reader; many of them are going to break; are you going to fix them, or not? You have decided you do not care enough about your writings or your readers to invest the effort to fix them. That is your decision, and I don't know enough about you, your writings, or your readers to criticize it. I have decided differently.
- WorldMaker 7y agoI was not criticizing your decision, simply trying to offer a differing viewpoint. I briefly considered doing something similar to the path you are traveling down, but realized that I was happier taking a different path. I provided those links because I thought they were relevant and useful to the reader at the time. I can't fight time and I can't fight entropy for all of the web or even just my own tiny corner. I salute you for trying. I set my border at the end of domain names that I control, because I know I have responsibilities there and I'm able to also in good conscious end them there, otherwise I'd feel so much guilt for how the web has shifted and changed in > 20 years of posting webpages to it. My blog captures moments in time, and just as I don't go back and fix rotten opinions that haven't aged well in some of them, I generally don't go back and fix broken links. I would hope that anyone exploring my past archives would give past me the benefit of the doubt and contemplate such archives from the context in which they were written and the very different person that wrote them and sometimes the very different web that they were posted to.