5 ms·
This isn't quite the same thing, but can I talk about something related? For the past month, I've been on a bit of a quest to downgrade my my life to OS X 10.9
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
This isn't quite the same thing, but can I talk about something related?
For the past month, I've been on a bit of a quest to downgrade my my life to OS X 10.9 Mavericks, which came out in 2013. It's something I've wanted to do for years, for a variety of personal reasons, and it should be able to do everything I need.
My primary issue has not been software compatibility per se, but actually obtaining the software I need. The trial version of NetNewsWire 4 looks beautiful on my Mavericks install, but I can't buy a license key because BlackPixel no longer sells them. Ditto for Scapple, and Day One, and Parallels, and many others.
I had to hunt through the Internet Archive to find the last compatible versions of Intel Power Gadget and Kaleidoscope. I had to manually download and test each version to figure out where they dropped compatibility.
These are all fully offline apps, so there's no reason I shouldn't be able to buy and download old versions. I'm not asking for support or development time—I totally expect to be on my own—but please, developers, just give me a way to obtain what you previously created.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoYeah "what's the last version that runs on X" is a tough question in many cases, even old Windows versions. In case you run a blog or are member of some public forum, news group or anything that's indexed by search engines consider dumping your findings there. Someone might try to do the same in a decade or so. For your license key issue, did you try to just contact the vendors? Maybe some are even willing to make these old versions free now, they might just not have seen the point in it...
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI definitely need to do a larger writeup somewhere when I'm "done" with this project. > For your license key issue, did you try to just contact the vendors? Yes, I have! I've received some very nice responses, but none that actually helped. Which I kind of get, I guess, but it feels like this shouldn't happen. Where possible, I've actually turned to pirating stuff—I normally hate doing this, but if you're not going to sell to me, I don't think it's wrong for me to find another way. I finally found a copy of NetNewsWire this way, after a lot of searching. P.S. This isn't an offline app, but shoutouts to Bitwarden for the stupidest problem. The old version of their desktop app keeps helpfully replacing itself with the newer, incompatible version, which then won't open. If I mark the app read-only, Bitwarden just endlessly asks for my admin password.
- the_pwner224 7y agoCould you share why 10.9 is so appealing to you? I am not a Mac user so very curious.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoMavericks is the last version before Apple did a huge visual makeover, to bring everything more in line with the visual style of modern iOS. I could rant for a while about why I dislike the new visuals, but my single biggest issue is the lack of contrast, which I find physically tiring on my eyes. Old OS X has a wide range of tones and well-placed accents, which make everything easy to scan. In some ways, I actually see the advent of dark mode as Apple recognizing this problem—and papering over it with a bad solution. Old OS X was neither light nor dark to begin with. (Particularly circa-10.5—after Snow Leopard they began slowly brightening everything). Separately from the visuals... this is a bit more opaque because I'm not a developer, but Yosemite introduced a lot of instability, and I'm convinced that Apple has never fully recovered. El Capitan (10.11) and High Sierra (10.13) were pretty stable by their final releases, but 10.9.5 is just really rock solid.
- marcoperaza 7y ago10.9 hasn’t received security updates for three years and a half years. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201222 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201222 Running an old version of an operating system that’s not actively getting security updates, let alone gotten any at all for over three years, is crazy. It’s one thing to run it offline or heavily firewalled for a limited purpose, like running some important application that doesn’t work on current versions. But to actually use it day to day is absolute madness. I hope you’re not handling any information that you have a duty to someone else to keep safe. Putting it on such an old OS release, through intentional and tedious effort on your part, would be outrageously negligent. Even logging into work email through that setup would be irresponsible. Or accessing any email account to which someone has sent private information (so just about any email account you actually use). It’s negligent with regards to your own data too of course, but at least that’s just your problem.
- jdsully 7y agoI hear this a lot but never with any actual quantification of the risk. The population still running 10.9 has to be so low its just not worth attacking.
- marcoperaza 7y agoThe burden of using the current version is so low (op is in fact expending significant effort to not make the safe choice), that imposing any additional risk on others is unjustified. That kind of analysis—the burden of caution vs. the risk of not taking it—is how the law measures negligence. I’m not giving legal advice of course. But the law tracks the morality of negligence pretty closely in my opinion.
- jdsully 7y agoMy 2011 macbook is already not supported by new versions and Mac hardware are not backwards compatible with older OS versions. It's extremely likely that they can't even run newer versions even if they wanted to. If not now then in the near future. I think trying to make any moral argument in this situation is pointless as the risks are so minuscule. But should we go down that road the environmental benefits of keeping older hardware in use for longer far outweighs any security risks they may impose on others.
- jtreminio 7y agoI've got an original iPad and an iPad Air (I think 2nd gen). Both still have great battery life and screens are still responsive ... but I made the mistake of wiping both to give as gifts for some nieces in El Salvador, and you can't actually install anything on them anymore. They come with Safari and the other baked-in Apple apps, but that's it. None of the most common apps in their store have versions available for the iOS version the devices are limited to. What the hell am I supposed to do with two fully functional (hardware-wise) devices?
- rtkwe 7y agoMount them as interactive views for a calendar page or something? I'm not sure how far behind their web browser is but that's the last real use for them I know of.
- homarp 7y agoif you have an existing account that downloaded a particular app already, you can download the old version of an app. https://support.apple.com/en-ca/HT201377 https://support.apple.com/en-ca/HT201377 or you jailbreak...
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoAnother tip: If the same app is still available on the store, but the newest version isn't compatible with your old OS, you won't be able to buy the that app on your old OS. However, if you can log into the same Apple account on a new OS, you can buy the app there (pressing "get" on a free app counts as buying for our purposes). Once purchased, you'll be able to install the last compatible version on your old device. This also works on the Mac App Store. Beware of situations where what's currently available on the store isn't actually the same app. If the developer released a new version as a separate app at one point, this process won't work.
- merb 7y agoiPad Air 2nd still gets updates. It's probably a iPad Air 1st gen