8 ms·
As someone who worked on videoconferencing for a while, there are four answers: multiple microphones, echo cancellation, background noise, and network issues.
by crazygringo 7y ago
As someone who worked on videoconferencing for a while, there are four answers: multiple microphones, echo cancellation, background noise, and network issues.
If everyone in a conference room wore individual headsets it would be great. But when you have 3 different mics along the table all of which are picking up different audio signals (to make sure people at both ends can be heard), you need to subtract background noise of construction and hallway chit-chat and people typing on their laptops, and also subtract everything coming out of the speakers (which has different delays in each microphone and is distorted by both the speaker response and microphone response)... and then it's 2:30 and your office upload link is saturated because everyone's starting a new remote meeting uploading HD video simultaneously?
That's why.
But the main culprits behind the "distorted, overly compressed" sound are echo cancellation and then noise cancellation. It's insanely hard. It's actually not low-bit at all, it just winds up sounding like that in the end. (Play with a noise removal filter in Audacity and you'll realize it will produce similar-sounding audio.)
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoIt would seem that much of this problem could be solved with microphone arrays and software. Bandwidth isn't that much a limitation, but latency is. I'm not sure of the state of the art in 3d positioned sound in a data format, but you could do that pretty easily. I thought of a startup back in 2016 for selling auto-transcripting, voice-signature tracking, meeting logging microphone arrays for businesses. Never had the capital to do it.
- crazygringo 7y ago> much of this problem could be solved with microphone arrays and software That's how it's done already. Beamforming mics have been around for a few years. They're definitely better, but still far from perfect. Because signal processing just isn't perfect. Incredibly smart engineers are doing their best on this stuff.
- ElKrist 7y agoBeamforming is actually already implemented in commercial products (both for microphones and speakers). You can look at the phones from a company called Invoxia. I know voice-signature tracking was also in R&D a few years ago so it might be available too
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThe true solution to remote conferencing is, everybody stays at their desk. A group in a conference room loses so much for everybody - others have trouble with who's talking, faces are tiny and far away, noise cancellation in a big room is hellacious. Stay at your desk and join the meeting. Everybody can share a document, look at any document share whenever they like, look straight at the camera with good focus, sound wonderful with a headset mic. Everybody knows who's talking instantly, with their name associated with the voice and face. The 'conference room' idea is a terrible one, and should quietly die.
- crazygringo 7y agoExcept that then I'm surrounded at my desk trying to concentrate and work while everyone's talking on their headsets around me. Ugh. No: if you want to be part of a meeting, everybody should be going to conference rooms or phone booths.
- clarry 7y agoEveryone should have an office. If you go remote, that kinda becomes affordable.
- intrepidhero 7y agoNo kinda about it. The cost savings is huge. I'm cheering for the bean counters to overrule the PHBs on this one.
- ghaff 7y agoA lot of people spend a large chunk of their days on the phone. Having to find a room for every call isn't practical. Companies should make an effort to segregate roles that involve lots of phone time with roles that tend to value quiet. But unless a company is giving everyone an office it's probably not reasonable to expect people not to be talking around you.
- ghaff 7y agoOne of the teams I work with has a rule that everyone is in a conference room together or everyone is on their own laptop. It's a pretty good rule though it's probably harder to convince people to follow it if it's a single person who is somewhere else.