3 ms·
You know, I thought about this for a while before down-voting it. I very rarely downvote -- maybe I have downvoted ten times in the last year. Let's review: "
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
You know, I thought about this for a while before down-voting it. I very rarely downvote -- maybe I have downvoted ten times in the last year.
Let's review:
"Not hacker news" <- great comment
"One less fevered ego tainting our collective unconscious. Good." <- personal attack on someone you didn't know and who can't defend themselves in this forum.
That kind of brazen disregard for humanity is anathema to any organized conversation, in my opinion. I'd down-vote you again if I could.
As a political junkie, I like watching the Sunday-morning talkers. Yes, Russert was a democrat and had worked on several campaigns before joining NBC, but he was good at what he did and brought a joy to his work that was infectious. I'm sure he did a lot of good and bad things, but most of all he was a human, a human I spent several dozen hours watching over the course of my life. He deserves better than that comment.If it's not for the board, fair enough.
You know, it's quite possible to disagree with people, even hate their behavior, without demonizing the person themselves. "Powerful elites [using] his show to control the way they distributed propaganda"?? I feel like I need a shower after reading it.
This, friends, is why politics shouldn't be on HN. If you feel you need to launch into some tirade about multi-national corporations using mind control to enslave the population, take it somewhere else.
I don't think this story had to be political at all. Famous talking-head dies. What sorts of neat startup attributes did he have?
- robg 18y ago"What sorts of neat startup attributes did he have?" That, I think, is a great question. To me, Russert exemplified the best of his profession without sacrificing himself or his work. By all accounts, he was a great guy who did a great job (qualifications aside about the state of the American media, esp with regard to politics). If folks say the same of me when I'm gone, it will have been a life well-lived, indeed.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI remember in the 2000 election mess, Russet pulls out a whiteboard and on national TV starts sketching out some ideas about how things might play out. He was so absorbed in his work he was looking at "what's the best tool right now to get from point A to point B" not necessarily what the most or least telegenic thing to do might be. I believe he's the guy who gave us the entire concept of "red states" and "blue states" I'm sure he had a lot of faults, but it's obvious he was competing well at a national level, and having a blast doing it. If I remember, in the last year or two the network bought him some huge freaking interactive map to use on the air. He used it once and then went back to the whiteboard -- the whiteboard was just enough functionality to do what he needed and not any more. Lots of good startup lessons here -- or at the very least lots of good life lessons.
- robg 18y agoBy all accounts, "having a blast doing it" describes him perfectly. And he managed to not make many enemies, if at all. That's a quite a feat. It was fun first. EDIT: Funny to me that this comment and its parent just got voted down. That's some spite. See, bemoan the state of the American media all you want. But Russert was one of its shining stars - a force of good where most is trivial. We should all aspire to stand out similarly.
- LPTS 18y agoTo oblige you, here's your chance to downvote me again. :) I agree this shouldn't be here at all. But, given that it's here, we should say what's true about it, instead of letting the conventional wisdom be all thats heard. I thought divergent thinking about conventional wisdom is part of the whole hacker thing? I don't think not being sad about his death and keeping the harm he did in perspective is anathema to humanity. I believe the things and people he was part of enabling are anathema to humanity. There are hundreds of thousands of people in Iraq dead or maimed because of the way the mainstream media (which he was a leader of) protected and enabled the people who were lying in the run up to war. Hundreds of thousands of Iraqi people dead or maimed, thousands of American soldiers killed, tens of thousands more maimed or with PTSD or suicide risks, thousands of foreigners tortured under the US flag. Thats the anathema to humanity, and the people Russert was instrumental in enabling caused it. I don't think we should care too much if he brought infectious joy to his work in judging his life. What you are saying is basically "I was entertained by the way he was part of lying to me on the TeeVee, so he deserves better after he's dead." No. He got way better then he deserved. The ones who deserve better are the people still being tortured and that are dead or damaged for life that are consequences of the deception ho was part of. It should be how dirty these things are that make you want to shower, not me pointing them out.
- edw519 18y ago"That kind of brazen disregard for humanity is anathema to any organized conversation, in my opinion." We hackers often get so caught up in the little details of what we do, it's easy to lose the big picture. And the biggest picture of all, IMO, is other people. The bits and bytes are cool, but it's the difference they make in other people's lives that keeps me going. I don't know whether this thread is appropriate for hacker news, but I do know that some of the comments here are totally inappropriate in any forum. Frankly, I'm a little embarassed for our community (I'm glad he's dead - wtf?) Politics, religion, sports, and popular culture belong on other boards. But the few times they rise to the top here, could we at least act like the smart people we are supposed to be. Thanks, Daniel, for saying what a lot of us were already thinking.
- LPTS 18y agoYeah lets all keep our heads in the sand and only talk about how much dead propagandists loved puppies and eulogize them without mention of their flaws or extensive and subtle manipulations. That will show everyone how smart we are.
- crescendo 18y agoSaying that you're glad someone is dead is a lot different from simply refusing to eulogize him. The former carries a certain amount of malice that's not there in the latter.
- LPTS 18y agoYou are right. I do have a certain amount of malice towards him. Because he was on TV tricking america and laughing and playing and making people like the parent comment think he was all sunshine and jolly ranchers while at the same time he provided cover for people committing crimes against humanity. Having malice towards people who let people like Dick Cheney get away with hurting hundreds of thousands of people is part of a well developed, integrated sense of humanity. My hatred for people like him flows from a deeper place of great love for all beings. (BTW: For what it's worth, One less fevered ego... and the hate parts were based on bill hicks quotes I liked. I don't know if that changes the implication or not.)