5 ms·
>> Tax evasion has been labelled a "Greek national sport" and it was estimated in 2016 to cost the country's coffers up to €16 billion every year, largely throu
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> Tax evasion has been labelled a "Greek national sport" and it was estimated in 2016 to cost the country's coffers up to €16 billion every year, largely through fraud on VAT or income tax.
Although I've made this joke myself in the past, about tax evasion being our national sport, it's insulting to see it repeated by an Australian publisher. Personally, I've only had to pay taxes abroad, in the UK, where there was no opportunity to evade them (because they were directly deducted from my salary - I'm a PhD student now hence the past tense). I wouldn't really say I'm an expert tax evader.
That said, any discussion of taxation and tax avoidance in Greece as well as the rest of South-Eastern Europe must also take into account the sorry state of public services, which tax money is meant to support. It's a chicken-and-egg problem, but it's easy to see why nobody would want to be the malakas who pays their taxes properly only for their tax money to disappear down the black hole of corruption before having any chance to improve the national health service, education, our roads, etc etc. Taxation makes sense when it's spent to improve and maintain the commons - not to line politicians' pockets.
Of course, that's not absolving my fellow Greeks of responsibility. Corruption is high in Greece because we support corrupt politicians with our votes, and because we have done so for three generations since the "metapolitefsis", the change to democracy after the years of the military dictatorship (ended in 1974). To wit, Kyriakos Mitsotakis (the current prime minister, pictured in the article) is the second Mitsotakis to be prime minister, grandson of the first - and his mom is also an MP. And before him we had Papandreou I (in the '50s), II and III and also Karamanlis I and II to rule us (and all their friends and cousins as MPs). We keep voting the same "houses" in power and then complain that they suck us dry and destroy the economy. And then of course it's every man and woman for themselves.
It's a fucked up situation and we are very much guilty for our choices over the years. But silly jokes about national sports don't help to get to the heart of the issue, or convey its seriousness.
- zorked 7y agoNot saying it's right but Canada had Trudeau I and II, the US had Bush I and II, and the Clinton and Kennedy families, so it's not like political dynasties aren't common in many countries.
- inertiatic 7y agoWhat's more interesting is how many scandals those dynasties have been involved in and still remain in power.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI don't disagree but I also wouldn't say that I have a very high opinion of the US political system. I didn't know about Trudeau in Canada, and I confess I don't know much about Canada, either. I certainly haven't noticed the same kind of political dynasty in other EU countries. Not that there are no pathologies in their political systems. The thing is, in Greece, we could perhaps say that it's OK to be ruled by the sons and grandsons of previous PMs if things were going alright despite that. They are not though. And it's an easy correlation to assume between nepotism and corruption in politics.
- phenkdo 7y agoSingapore had Lee Kuan Yew & his son Lee Hsen Loong - and it has a squeaky clean model of governance.
- naniwaduni 7y agoI cannot tell whether this is sarcasm or not. Singapore's governance is well-oiled, but I wouldn't call it squeaky clean...
- phenkdo 7y agoTransparency Intl. ranks Singapore the 3rd least corrupt country [1] globally. BTW, this thread was about a possible link between political dynasties and corruption, and I was providing a counterexample. [1] https://www.straitstimes.com/politics/singapore-rises-to-third-place-in-annual-ranking-of-least-corrupt-countries-global-study https://www.straitstimes.com/politics/singapore-rises-to-thi...
- saiya-jin 7y agoYeah if dystopian bubble is your dream of governance then yes. They fared financially better than neighbors, but its a far cry of society I would like to live or raise kids in. Many things we consider progressive in the west are not upheld there, and people are definitely not equal in front of law. But as colleagues who worked there described it, you are on top of the pyramid as a well-hired westerner. So you don't have to give a fuck about tons of things that make decent human being, as long as you don't cross often draconian local laws and align. It takes a bit of specific personality to thrive there, but many do...
- xiphias2 7y agoI'm from Hungary, and like in some other countries, the change in politicians is coming on the city levels. While Orban is trying to be a dictator, Budapest now has an amazing mayor (Karácsony Gergely), fighting back against corruption with effective negotiation tactics. Budapest gets only a few percent of the taxes that people in Budapest pay, but even that will be enough to reverse some of the damage done in the last 9 years.
- geomark 7y agoMaybe you can verify this story that I was told. On a few vacations to Greece I wondered why so many buildings of all shapes and sizes had some re-bar sticking out somewhere, usually at the top of a post. I was told that it is about evading property taxes by never completely finishing construction, that taxes were not due on unfinished buildings. So they were never finished. The buildings were all occupied and fully livable but I guess the owner could point to the re-bar sticking out and say it was not really finished.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoSorry, I can't verify this. I don't know it to be either true or false.
- pure-awesome 7y agoNot Greek, but here's an economics Stackexchange question which handles this: https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/27662/do-greeks-evade-taxes-by-not-finishing-their-houses https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/27662/do-greeks... tl;dr of the accepted answer: It's not for tax evasion, it's to make later expansion cheaper. They don't count as "Unfinished buildings". If the house has power (empty or not), or someone lives inside (with or without electrical power), the owner must pay the full 100% of the normal property taxes.
- orestis 7y agoCan confirm -- people (used to) build apartments with extensions in mind, so you would get a permit and plans for a 3-story building, then only build the first two floors. The third floor would then be built 10 years later for children/grandchildren. Greek private citizens are still very allergic to getting huge loans, land ownership is still very fragmented, and tall tower blocks are virtually impossible due to earthquake activity and permit limitations.
- itismetheidiot 7y agothe permit to build might allow you a building with three floors at given/approved surface. You dont have to build 3 floors now, you can build 2 or 1 and later you can build up to the allowed limit.
- peterwwillis 7y agoOn the contrary, the joke very clearly expresses to the rest of the world that Greece has some truly ridiculous tax problems. It's like saying Russia is an oligarchy; of course the Russians would be offended by it, but it illustrates the reality succinctly.
- duxup 7y agoIt sounds like a vicious cycle. I don't pay taxes because services suck... so there isn't enough money for services.
- seibelj 7y agoYou act like you are the only country with inefficient and corrupt government bureaucracy and services. Huge amounts of people in every country believe the same thing. You pay your taxes and advocate for tax cuts and government reform to prevent further waste. But an entire country whose logic is to just stop paying taxes as political protest is pretty funny!
- giarc 7y ago>take into account the sorry state of public services, which tax money is meant to support. It's a chicken-and-egg problem, I would argue it's not a chicken/egg problem, the money has to come before the public services. The government isn't going to borrow a ton of money to improve services on the off chance that it's citizens will voluntarily start to pay taxes at a proper rate.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoInterestingly enough, they probably could. Their most recent bond yields were negative, very different from days not so long ago when their yields would be above 20%. However, I'm not sure if they have agreements with the ECB that might prevent them from issuing more debt.
- mitsakos 7y agoThe argument that corruption is very high on Greece and hence people prefer to not pay taxes makes intuitively sense but it's probably also (at least partly) confirmation bias. Note that per https://www.u4.no/publications/exploring-the-relationships-between-corruption-and-tax-revenue.pdf https://www.u4.no/publications/exploring-the-relationships-b... there is currently no literature concretely correlating the two. The link suggests more research to be done in this area. Per https://www.transparency.org/cpi2018 https://www.transparency.org/cpi2018 Greece is ranked 67 out of 180 countries in the corruption index with the admittedly not high score of 45/100. 100 is not the top at the score, Denmark is at first place with 88/100. So, relatively speaking, corruption exists all over the place, and Greece ranks mildly ok compared to the world. It also ranks better than all of it's neighbouring countries. Compared to the US or the EU, there's a lot of room for improvement of course. So there's probably more facets to the problem that just corruption.
- mitsakos 7y agoThe article btw is really really shady. Barely at the beginning of it: "The scheme is a radical attempt to cast some light on Greece's huge shadow economy, the world's largest" and let's look at https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/shadow_economy/ https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/rankings/shadow_economy/ wow.. wait, Greece is barely at place #86 out of 158 countries. Hmmm someone did not do his due diligence here. Then we have the following. "Greece also has one of the lowest internet usage rates in the EU at 72 per cent". Per https://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm https://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm it's definitely not great. Trailing by at 45/54. We can remove Vatican City, San Marino, Isle of Man, Svalbard and Jersey (all have lower rates) and say that's true. But it's written way more sensationalist than it is. The mean is at 87.7% so there is definitely room for improvement. At least the suggested result is pointed out like that, i.e. "This suggests that some in the country could struggle to meet the 30 per cent target". Not sure why, but anyway. And then we have a repetition of the argument above "Southern Europe, particularly Greece, have booming shadow economies. A study by the Institute for Applied Economic Research in 2017 found that Greece had the largest in the world, being equivalent to 22 per cent of gross domestic product." Wait, which country's Institude for Applied Economic Research? It's not at all mentioned. Googling it, it turns out it's Germany and the actual research is at http://www.iaw.edu/index.php/aktuelles-detail/734 http://www.iaw.edu/index.php/aktuelles-detail/734. The actual number of countries studied? 20. Not sure what the criteria for their selection were. Out of a planet with 195 countries that's barely enough to justify the above (and the original research does not make such sensationalist claims) never mind the fact that countries like e.g. Thailand have double that rate. Overall, kind of meh.
- cmurf 7y agoIn effect it's an oligarchy posing as a democracy. When Rome devolved from a republic into an empire, it retained the veneer of democracy for over 250 years. Yet in no meaningful way was it one. The principate. A long time ago all of those Greek families should have been destroyed for having pillaged their own country. They don't care about the country. They care about their family. Fine. Let them care for their families without a country, and the country would be better off without them. And by far it's not the only country that has done this, is doing this, or will do it again. It's actually quite ordinary. Romanticizing feudalism, and classism: everyone has their proper place, and responsibilities and privilege. Family name and bloodlines are a real thing, and some people are better than others. It's an indisputable fact. And better people have more money, to buy more and better things including better personal security, education, health care, clean water, justice. Those things aren't rights everyone gets. Equality is an obscenity. It is a wealthy person's right to afford better lawyers with which to buy justice as a product. And for royalty to have no need for lawyers at all because they are the law. They're closer to god after all. And who dares challenge god's will? Besides, it makes it easier to keep a boot on everyone else's forehead when they can't afford a lawyer. Justice is a product. And security and violence are a product too, which is the purchase of private police and mercenary forces, and even goon squads to intimidate anyone who disagrees with the proper way of things. The mandate from heaven, the concept that kings and queens were the manifestation of god, or at the least had an imputation of godliness to them, is foundational for feudalism and monarchies. Of course countries will have oligarchies when just enough people haven't rejected these old organizational ideas, and let a few people step on everyone else. So it's actually not so fucked up. It's part of the natural inclination of mankind for a very very long time to worship a god, and by extension any man who convincingly speaks on behalf of that god, and his immediate family, and then his friends, as he corruptly lowers the ladder of power to a select few. Democracy is trouble because it relies on all too many people giving a crap about their own aspiration, having imagination and ambition, and trust that the rules apply to everyone. Which they tend not to. Damaging trust in equal application of law, and competent institutions creates an environment in which corruption and oligarchies flourish. The U.S. isn't immune. There's a significant minority who believe in prosperity theology, pushed by pastors as ostensibly Christian even though it's directly contradicted by the book of Job. The idea is the closer to god you are, the more you'll be rewarded with wealth. And thus wealth indicates a person has been rewarded and thus is closer to god so you should mimic their behaviors - hero worship. And it's also idolatry but you wouldn't ever hear that suggested as a bad thing, of course you should worship your pastor and make a proper donation, then god will reward you five fold (or whatever). A more common variation on this is celebrity worship. Of course they should have all this money to pay accountants and tax lawyers who can help them pay lower tax rates. Because paying fair taxes is not actually fair. What's the point of being wealthy if you can't buy a lower tax rate as a product? Higher rates are for the peons who can't afford an accountant! Put the money into the coffer, and god will reward you with more. You'll see. It's the same. It's all the same.