4 ms·
I guess having done AI and security for 20 years means none of this fazes me. Of course they record what you say, and of course a human is listening to it. Ho
by jedberg 7y ago
I guess having done AI and security for 20 years means none of this fazes me.
Of course they record what you say, and of course a human is listening to it. How else would they train their models?
I also believe Amazon when they say that it isn't recording unless the blue light is on, and that only comes on when it thinks you said "Alexa".
I mute the device when I'm having a private conversation. If it activates otherwise, I'm pretty aware of that.
I guess it just doesn't really bother me. I have a pretty good idea of what it's recording.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoOmg stop applying rationality to the conversation you devil!
- PavlovsCat 7y agoHaving paid attention for decades to people who have been paying attention for way longer than that, these reactions neither surprise nor faze me, either. It's all been thoroughly weighed and found too light before 99.9% of us were even born. > Yet another circumstance must be mentioned which proves favorable for the Nazis and their immensely powerful apparatus of oppression: the development of modern technology gives the rulers, as has long been insufficiently understood, an advantage over the ruled. The more effective the weapons become and the less you can protect yourself against them, the more the armed is superior to the unarmed. The Bastille could not be successfully stormed in the age of airplanes and tear gas. Rifles equipped with rifles have no chance against motorized police forces; it makes no sense to build barricades against a government that has tanks. And in the event of a revolution, it is not only weapons development that favors those in power, the state over the individual: modern technical development and the associated sophisticated organization work in the same direction. Traffic has led to the countries becoming small and easy to monitor. How many hiding places there were in a country a hundred years ago! At that time, every power hit natural barriers! Today there is no loophole and no hideout for the rebel anymore. Even the thoughts that are able to penetrate the walls have become "controllable" because they are tied to the mass distribution of news, to radio, film and the press. How long will it take before every house has its own microphone and every private word, like every telephone call today, can be heard? The ant state is at hand. It may not be a coincidence that states like Germany and Russia have elevated technology to the status of a religion. Conversely, this development of modern technology makes the preservation of freedom a human task that is more urgent than ever. -- Sebastian Haffner, "Germany: Jekyll & Hyde (1939 - Deutschland von innen betrachtet)" > I cannot tell why the spokesmen I have cited want the developments I forecast to become true. Some of them have told me that they work on them for the morally bankrupt reason that "If we don't do it, someone else will." They fear that evil people will develop superintelligent machines and use them to oppress mankind, and that the only defense against these enemy machines will be superintelligent machines controlled by us, that is, by well-intentioned people. Others reveal that they have abdicated their autonomy by appealing to the "principle" of technological inevitability. But, finally, all I can say with assurance is that these people are not stupid. All the rest is mystery. -- Joseph Weizenbaum
- fabrice_d 7y agoDo you also have a good idea of what is recorded when you're at someone else place? Do you ask them to mute their devices?
- utopian3 7y agoDo you ask people to turn off their smartphones when you’re at their house? Or at dinner? Or in public?
- dredmorbius 7y agoThat is a practice adopted by some, yes.
- utopian3 7y agoAre you speculating here, or is this something you’ve observed?
- dehrmann 7y agoI'd assume everything between "Alexa" and the response.
- dehrmann 7y agoThe headline (I blame Bloomberg on this) would be much less clickbaity as "Silicon Valley Records Your Digital Assistant Requests."
- saagarjha 7y ago> I guess having done AI and security for 20 years means none of this fazes me. Unfortunately I'd have to guess that many of the people not doing AI and security for 20 years would be considerably more surprised.
- Balgair 7y ago> I have a pretty good idea of what it's recording. Like an 8 year old girl?[0] Yeah, it's a Ring doorbell camera thingy, but Ring has been an Amazon product for just shy of two years now. Sure we can blame the mother for setting it up 'wrong', or for using an old password, or some other very common problem that <99% of all user will have. But creeps have shown that it's not just straightforward, but easy, to get into these devices. It's better to just not have them in the first place. [0] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/man-hacks-ring-camera-8-year-old-girl-s-bedroom-n1100586 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/man-hacks-ring-camera-8...