4 ms·
So much of the current "home automation" products appear to me to be more parlour tricks than actual automation. Having to ask for something to happen is such
by BLKNSLVR 7y ago
So much of the current "home automation" products appear to me to be more parlour tricks than actual automation. Having to ask for something to happen is such a high technological cost for such a tiny change in convenience in the age of already being able to remote control a bunch of stuff with your phone.
There are actual proper home automation products out there, and some of them can interface via these privacy invading microphones masquerading as speakers, but the microphones themselves aren't "home automation" by any useful definition, they're just another alternative remote control.
I wonder if they use the term "smart speaker" because "microphone" just brings up thoughts of Banksy artwork?
- therein 7y agoIf you think about it, it is clear that Amazon and Google put a lot more R&D into the microphones than the speakers in these things. Yet they insist on calling them smart speakers, not smart microphones. It would be like if you took a device with a camera and called it a portal or something.
- asdff 7y agoThe real rub is there's hardly any incentive to make things play nice with eachother for a while. You buy a garage door opener, it works for 30 years. You get one that can interface with your smart speaker, and both are unsupported in a few years. You end up paying far more, way more often, for something vaguely more convenient than the old method. A clap light. On the flip side, with the expansion of IoT comes creativity for people willing to tinker. We are pretty lucky to have resources like github, raspberry pi, self hosted services, just options from the mainstream consumer ad spam crap if you are willing to stick your head under the hood.