6 ms·
A few years back I got a new manager and this was her first people manager role. She was awful. Micromanaged about useless things, bother you at odd hours for
by refurb 7y ago
A few years back I got a new manager and this was her first people manager role. She was awful. Micromanaged about useless things, bother you at odd hours for not very important topics. Her whole team would usually just sit around and say “I can’t believe how bad she is.”
I got a feedback request from her boss, so I listed 3 things she could do better. Pretty sure her boss wouldn’t follow up.
Had my 1-on-1 with her and she asked “Any feedback?”. I thought for a second, then just went “what the hell, let’s do it”, and spent the next 10 minutes telling her all the things she does wrong.
She was incredibly thankful for the feedback as no one else was willing to give her direct feedback.
She didn’t change overnight, but we had an absolutely great relationship after that. If I didn’t like something she did, I told her right away.
I even blew up at her about a year later because she kept cutting me off on a big presentation. She apologized and it never happened again.
It was a gamble, but it paid off.
- duxup 7y agoAges ago I was a crappy manager at a crappy job and honestly too young to manage myself even. It was one of those places where managers saw themselves as little hall monitors or police looking at what people had on their desk and I'm ashamed to say I played along. So one day I'm talking to this guy who was fed up and labeled a problem and he says something like: "Does any of this even matter, do we do a better job because of it or do any of us get paid more?" Everyone complained bickered about the rules, but nobody has said it like that...I didn't have an answer. I suddenly realized, yeah this is all just pointless aggravation for everyone. So I quit enforcing dumb rules and we all had a better time... the managers above me talked about these rules and sent out all sorts of emails and directives to enforce them, and somehow me not doing it wasn't even noticed. The place didn't get any better, but at least if you were on my team you didn't get hassled about stupid things.
- option_greek 7y agoIt's like tragedy of commons for management. The manager gets nothing by enforcing corporate rules on his team. But not enforcing them usually doesn't cost them anything while improving team morale, good will and in most cases retention, productivity. I see many managers strictly follow up on logging leaves or restricting work from homes or enforcing release deadlines as if it personally costs them something while usually enforcement is just discretionary. The managers who have figured this out usually have happier teams.
- number6 7y agoSounds like mismanagement in the higher echelon. The team leader should lead up the chain to ensure deadlines are realistic and hindering restrictions are dealt with. How does he do this? By complying with corporate rules to show good faith and intervene when necessary. It's also important that he understands the rules and communicates them to the team. The team manager should be on good terms with upper management and the team. This is hard and requires skill.
- koonsolo 7y agoA great manager shields off their team from all the bullshit, so good job!
- arethuza 7y agoI have heard it said that there are two kinds of managers: shit funnels and shit umbrellas.
- jotm 7y agoWe've had the same reply at a previous company. The answer was "this comes straight from the general manager, so we must do this". I'm 100% sure the GM had no idea what's going on, so, yeah, terrible manager right there refusing to budge.
- faeyanpiraat 7y agoI would be careful with selectively dismissing rules if I were just beginning a management career, as I would potentially be opening up myself for liability in case something goes wrong. It takes lot of experience and wisdom to accurately distinguish between useless and seemingly useless but critical rules.
- duxup 7y agoYeah I was careful about what rules I "ignored". First of all I still communicate those rules so everyone knew what the folks above me were talking about. Second any rule that had real world impact, other teams, involved other people's expectation and experience we totally complied with. It was very much calculated rule ignoring.
- sli 7y ago> ..., and somehow me not doing it wasn't even noticed. This strikes me as a big ole red flag that hints at the true nature of those rules.
- StavrosK 7y agoMy opinion is that if you give direct, honest feedback that's about the thing-that-is-done rather than about the person who's doing it, you do the other person a service. If they're offended about it or don't take it well, that's on them. It matters a lot how you say it, though. I like the shit sandwich a lot, where you do compliment-criticism-compliment, but that's just a method of ordering the feedback, you shouldn't lie about it.
- krallja 7y agoShit sandwiches don't work. People can still tell when they're being fed a load of shit.
- StavrosK 7y agoDo you think it's better to start with the shit and end with the compliments, or to start with the compliments and end with the shit? I think it's better to sandwich the shit in-between, so yes, shit sandwiches don't work, but they work better than the alternatives.
- GhostVII 7y agoWhen I see people using the "sandwich" method on me it is usually pretty clear that the only reason they are giving compliments is just to soften their criticisms, so I would rather just get the criticisms on their own. Not every criticism or set of criticisms needs to be accompanied with something positive. If there are many points of feedback, some positive and some negative, I think they should be split into logical categories, mixing together positive and negative feedback, rather than trying to completely surround criticisms with compliments.
- slowmovintarget 7y agoThis depends on culture actually. However you order it, though. Be honest and direct, and include corrections to give them a path forward. That's the best way to end on a positive note.
- cabaalis 7y agoEveryone is attempting to rise to the level of their competence and ambition. I've had the opportunity of dealing with a few billionaires, and their teams. It showed me that we are all just trying to navigate a difficult world.
- shantly 7y agoThe more exposure I get to folks way “above” me in business, or riches, or whatever, the more convinced I am that very few people at any level are really much good at what they do and most of what goes on is just very serious role-playing and play-pretend, which realization is at least as horrifying as it is comforting.
- nomel 7y agoDon't we all want to be in a position that puts us at the edge of our comfort and abilities, with doing something new? I know that's my goal.
- brnt 7y agoHonestly, I think most want an honest wage, or as much as they can get, and then having work that doesn't interfere with their lives outside of 9-5 too much.
- RaceWon 7y ago> Had my 1-on-1 with her and she asked “Any feedback?” Tangentially, there was a time when I believed if you had a great idea your boss would be delighted to hear about it. Sadly, that was a long time ago. My current bosses are all the smartest people that they have ever met. Here I am not bragging, I only mention this to give credence to my argument: I have performance reviews that would knock you down they are so good; 400 points out of a possible 400 points on 3 out of 6 sections, with 347 ponts being my lowest score for an overall average of 370. That puts me in the uppermost category. Clearly I'm appreciated... Any idea I have is not. These folks only want yes men. Recently I saw my direct supervisor watching the department director doing something that I know my supervisor knew was wrong--yet he never said a word. I did though. Incidentally my Supervisor was recently promoted by the Deptarment Director. Personally, I can't Not say anything when I see people doing the wrong thing. For sure I try to be tactful, but there it is. I'm glad things went your way!
- cheez 7y agoJesus Christ you couldn't pay me enough (or maybe you wouldn't want to) to live by point systems.
- VRay 7y agoI dunno dude, you can make some pretty good money working under a bullshit FAANG point system ( levels.fyi )
- badfrog 7y agoThis crazy points system doesn't sound like anything I've ever heard of at FAANG.
- kevinventullo 7y agoFacebook does not have a point system, and I'm fairly sure none of the others do.
- deleted 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]