3 ms·
> This is criminal behaviour, and people need to go to jail. Yes. > The MAX should never be allowed to fly again. No. Even at 20x the failure rate, flying i
by lisper 7y ago
> This is criminal behaviour, and people need to go to jail.
Yes.
> The MAX should never be allowed to fly again.
No. Even at 20x the failure rate, flying in a Max -- even with an unmodified MCAS -- is still vastly safer than driving on a per-distance-travelled basis. Part of the problem is that commercial aviation has gotten so ridiculously safe that we've lost all perspective on risk assessment. The Max is actually fundamentally a safe plane. What made it unsafe was the totally fucked up attempt to make its flight characteristic the same as the old 737 so it and its pilots would not have to be re-certified. The right answer is to re-certify. That's expensive, but a lot cheaper than scrapping an entire fleet of brand new planes. Grounding the entire fleet forever is throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
- rossdavidh 7y agoWell, given that other models exist that accomplish the same job (albeit perhaps not from Boeing), it's going to be a steep climb to get European authorities to agree to certify it, I expect. So, the correct comparison would not be to driving, but to flying in other planes with similar range that are already available. I am no expert, but I do not get the impression that it is looking good in this respect.
- lisper 7y ago> it's going to be a steep climb to get European authorities to agree to certify it No doubt. > the correct comparison would not be to driving, but to flying in other planes with similar range that are already available Yes, but the correct comparison is the recertified Max, without MCAS, and with re-trained pilots. That is the alternative to scrapping the fleet.
- 3JPLW 7y ago> is still vastly safer than driving on a per-distance-travelled basis I did the math one time with very conservative numbers (thinking it'd be an easy win) and got shockingly close: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19983686 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19983686 If you have an alternative reference or more exact numbers I'd love to see them!
- caconym_ 7y agoI don't know if the per-distance-traveled basis is really that meaningful. If air travel didn't exist, people would simply not undertake these trips under the same "cheap" circumstances they do now, and our attitude toward long distance travel would be very different as a result. It's not like, if I want to go to Europe for a week, I'm choosing between flying and driving. I'm flying or I'm not going at all.
- Piskvorrr 7y agoPerhaps sailing is starting to look interesting again? (yes, yes, that's a 10+ year in the future, I guess)
- boatswain 7y ago> Even at 20x the failure rate, flying in a Max -- even with an unmodified MCAS -- is still vastly safer than driving on a per-distance-travelled basis. I don't think people are making the comparison of Max vs driving. They are making the comparison of Max vs other air planes.
- pdonis 7y ago> The right answer is to re-certify. By "re-certify", do you just mean the pilots? Or do you include the plane itself? The original problem was that the FAA requirement for how the stick force has to vary with angle of attack could not be met, because of the new engines having to be so far forward: instead of the stick force continuing to increase with higher AoA, it started to decrease at some point because of the pitch up moment due to the engines. The simplest way to fix that would have been to increase the ground clearance so the engines could be moved back to where they were on previous 737s. That, of course, would have had to be done in the design stage, before planes started being built. I'm not sure if it would be possible to retrofit existing 737 MAX planes to do this. If the physical airframe stays the same, then there has to be something in the flight controls that compensates for the pitch up moment of the engines at higher AoA in order to meet the stick force requirement. MCAS was an attempt to do that while keeping everything "close enough" to previous 737s. If that constraint is dropped, there might be a way to keep within the FAA stick force requirement without having the same failure modes as the MAX does, but that would still require a new type certification for the plane.
- lisper 7y ago> By "re-certify", do you just mean the pilots? Or do you include the plane itself? Both. > the FAA requirement for how the stick force has to vary with angle of attack could not be met No, that's a myth. There is no such requirement for aircraft in general. Many aircraft do not have this characteristic. But it happened to be true for the old 737, and so it had to be true for the Max in order for it to operate under the old 737's type certificate. The Max could easily be certified as-is without MCAS as a new aircraft type (assuming no further nasty surprises turn up of course). That will be neither cheap nor easy. If it were, Boeing would have just done that in the first place. But it will be a hell of a lot cheaper than scrapping the fleet.
- pdonis 7y ago> that's a myth. There is no such requirement for aircraft in general. 14 CFR Part 25 Subpart B contains a number of requirements for stick force and gradient of stick force. In particular, section 25.255(b) says the stick force vs. g curve must have a positive slope and that the direction of the primary longitudinal control force must not reverse. IIRC that's the one that bit the MAX, but, as below, I'll have to go dig up references to see. It's true that this is not the same as stick force vs. AoA, but under the conditions for which MCAS was intended, stick force vs. g works out to be basically the same thing. It's been a while since I looked up references for all this, so I'll have to go back and see if I can dig up where I got the info that because of the pitch up moment of the engine the MAX could not meet one of the stick force gradient requirements without some kind of modification.