3 ms·
I don't remember what section of the IRS code or regulations cover it, but there are rules to prevent disguising a dividend as a stock buyback. They provide a g
by tzs 7y ago
I don't remember what section of the IRS code or regulations cover it, but there are rules to prevent disguising a dividend as a stock buyback. They provide a good illustration of why the tax code is complicated.
(All numbers in the following are made up).
Some major company a long time ago was going to pay out a dividend, and then their accountants had a great idea. Instead of a dividend, they would first do 100 for 99 stock split. Then they would do a 1% stock buyback. The shareholders would be taxed at capital gains rates instead of ordinary income rates on this.
Note that for any shareholder, the result afterward is that for every 99 shared they owned before the split and buyback they still own 99 shares. No one's actual percentage ownership of the company has changed--but they have received money from the company.
The code and/or regulations were updated to fix this. But then buybacks that were not hidden dividends were getting classified as ordinary income, too, and so further code and/or regulation changes were made to further refine this.
What it eventually ended up with is rules that looked at how ownership was distributed among the shareholders before the buyback and after the buyback, and decided if it was a disguised dividend or a legitimate buyback based on how that distribution changed.
(I haven't followed tax law for several years. Anyone happen to know if this is still there after the Trump tax changes?)
This sort of thing is a large part of why tax codes and regulations tend to be big and complicated. Even if they start out fairly simple, people find holes like that split/buyback trick, and closing those holes adds complexity. The result is that you only generally will see either very simple tax systems (like sales taxes) or very complex systems. Systems that start out in between end up moving toward very complex.