4 ms·
The article is based on two false premises. First, it appeals to the idea that we should give Puerto Rico a pass because it’s poor. But Puerto Rico is not poor.
by rayiner 7y ago
The article is based on two false premises. First, it appeals to the idea that we should give Puerto Rico a pass because it’s poor. But Puerto Rico is not poor. Its GDP per capita is above Italy, and right below Spain and New Zealand.[1] It’s not a third world country where you can say there is a humanitarian basis why they shouldn’t have to pay back money they borrowed.
The other point in the article is simply that these funds are not the original debt holders. But what difference does that make? If your neighbor owes you $100,000, and refuses to pay, I might buy the debt at $50,000 in return for the hassle of collecting it. Is there something wrong with that? Should the debt be forgiven merely because of that?
The article overlooks that legal rules alter primary behavior. People alter their decisions about lending based on what might happen, legally, if the investment goes sideways. The original lenders, who put up money that allows Puerto Rico to pay for various things, did so within a legal regime where it knew Puerto Rico couldn’t declare bankruptcy. They might not have lent the money at all otherwise. Moreover, in general lenders make lending decisions knowing that they can sell bad debt to collection firms or third parties. Eliminating the legal rights of those third parties alters the lending decisions of the primary actors going forward.
[1] I’d go so far as to say that it’s doubtful the author would appeal to Puerto Rico’s poverty if this was a debt owed by Italy, because the reader wouldn’t be as sympathetic. Which frankly is not a very nice thing, viewing Puerto Rican differently than Europeans who are identically situated economically.
- unexpected 7y agoPuerto Rico is desperately poor. GDP per capita is a poor measure of income inequality. 45% of Puerto Ricans live below the poverty line. Italy's economy is literally 20x the size of Puerto Rico. If Puerto Rico was a state, it would be the poorest state in the U.S. It's unemployment rate is double the United States. Hurricane Maria has caused $140 billion of damages to a country with a GDP of $100 million. What would the U.S. look like if it had a natural disaster that cost $20 trillion in damages? It sounds like you need to make a visit and drive around. Some parts of the island still don't have power, even today.
- JumpCrisscross 7y agoOP’s point is the wealth is there. It’s just not being allocated to basic services or debt repayment. The reason seems to be corruption. The debate is around the balance between intrinsic and extrinsic corruption, with good arguments on both sides. Puerto Rico isn’t poor. But it is in a crisis. That discrepancy contains the problem and solutions.
- unexpected 7y agothe wealth is not there - that's the point I'm making. Hurricane Maria cost $140 billion. Puerto Rico's GDP is $100 billion. They need to repay $75 billion in bonds, and they have $50 billion in unfunded pension liabilities. Using GDP per capita (which is the wealth per person) is a very poor measure for the overall size of the economy. This is akin to saying a SV silicon valley engineer who makes $250k a year should be able to pay his $2 million mortgage when he all of a sudden gets hit with $300k in medical expenses because he got hit by a bus while riding his scooter without a helmet - fuck it, he's wealthy. He just needs to budget better.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Puerto Rico's GDP is $100 billion. They need to repay $75 billion in bonds, and they have $50 billion in unfunded pension liabilities. This is not a great ratio. But it’s not unmanageable. The GDP per capita implies there are tax raises and service cuts somewhere which would be feasible, alongside cutting debt and liabilities. Much of the population being in poverty is an inequality, not resource scarcity, argument.
- unexpected 7y ago...and this is where Puerto Rico's status comes into picture. PR's tax rate at the highest level is 33%. If you want to go higher, wealthy Puerto Ricans just decamp to Florida (no state income taxes!) and fly in as needed. The corporate tax base has also dwindled. Still, PR has raised taxes - across the board, but due to the wealthy's ability to decamp, these tax increases are disproportionately felt by the middle and lower classes. Additionally, the costs of goods and services is much higher than in the states. GDP per capita doesn't measure purchase power parity, and your dollars in PR don't go nearly as far as they do in the USA. Energy costs, water costs, shipping costs, are all much higher in other countries, and legislation (such as the Jones Act) that helps mainland USA hurts PR. PR is trapped, and has a perpetual brain drain of people escaping. It has a negative population growth of -2% a year (in a heavily Catholic country), and GDP growth has been negative for 13 years in a row. More austerity measures are not going to help the situation.
- dylan604 7y agoBased on an NPR/Frontline report [0], it sounds like the debt Puerto Rico took on was a total financial market scam. The financial institutions schemed up some pretty crazy debt packages specifically for Puerto Rico that depended on PR's non-state status and specific rules/laws that it has applied to it. After learning about the scheming that occurred, I'm not so sure I'm not in favor of just wiping out that debt and making the financial institutions eat it. [0]https://www.npr.org/2018/05/02/607032585/how-puerto-ricos-debt-created-a-perfect-storm-before-the-storm https://www.npr.org/2018/05/02/607032585/how-puerto-ricos-de... edit: forgot the link
- darawk 7y ago> Based on an NPR/Frontline report [0], it sounds like the debt Puerto Rico took on was a total financial market scam. The financial institutions schemed up some pretty crazy debt packages specifically for Puerto Rico that depended on PR's non-state status and specific rules/laws that it has applied to it. a) I don't see anything in the article that implies the debt packages were particularly complex or manipulative. b) Even if they were, are you saying that the state of Puerto Rico was not competent to evaluate it's own financial decisions?
- dylan604 7y agoTo be honest, I originally heard the report on the radio, and did a cursory search for a linkable article. This might not have been the exact article I was thinking it was.
- jdkee 7y agoThe question then becomes: what did they do with the money?
- kingkawn 7y agoYour take completely ignores income disparity, and that the social services being cut deeply impact the poor
- bliblah 7y agoI mentioned this in another comment but i'll repeat it. Due to the complexities of Puerto Rico's status as a commonwealth (i.e. not a State) the island is unable to declare bankruptcy. If they could then this issue could easily be solved and would give the government some leverage as is the case in most cases involving financial institutions taking advantage of these loans like was the case in Detroit and NYC. To quote the wikipedia article on the topic [1]: "Puerto Rico or any of its political subdivisions and agencies cannot file for debt relief under Chapter 9, Title 11, United States Code because it applies only to municipalities on the mainland.[55"] [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puerto_Rican_government-debt_crisis#Bankruptcy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puerto_Rican_government-debt_c... Having lived in PR my most of life and most of my family being lawyers in both the Federal and the local Supreme Court the insight I get from the situation is that unless the White House gets involved or Congress simply amends that single line in the bankruptcy law then the government has really no leverage and these financial institutions (not lenders, but banks who bought the debt from lenders) will get mostly what they want and cripple the island.
- darawk 7y ago> Due to the complexities of Puerto Rico's status as a commonwealth (i.e. not a State) the island is unable to declare bankruptcy. If they could then this issue could easily be solved and would give the government some leverage as is the case in most cases involving financial institutions taking advantage of these loans like was the case in Detroit and NYC. Was Puerto Rico unaware of this when they took out the loans? Was the law changed out from under them after they had made these deals? If not, why should we care?
- bliblah 7y ago>Was Puerto Rico unaware of this when they took out the loans? The fact that it went to the Supreme Court of the US [1] means that it is unprecedented and required the highest court in the land to interpret the law means that no parties were fully aware of how Bankruptcy would hold. [1]https://www.oyez.org/cases/2015/15-233 https://www.oyez.org/cases/2015/15-233
- throwaway_tech 7y ago>I might buy the debt at $50,000 in return for the hassle of collecting it. Is there something wrong with that? Many would argue there is something inherently wrong (evil) with any interest bearing debt. Moving past that...yes, there is something wrong with reselling bad debt (maybe even reselling good debt). The only reason people buy bad debt is they have bad intentions, either they are trying to resell it themselves to a less savvy buyer (usually employing various means of fraud and misrepresentation) - even the biggest banks in the world engaged in this with their toxic loans - or they plan to employ unlawful collection methods. If you are an original creditor and you are going to resell a debt for pennies on the dollar, the at a minimum the debtor should have an option to buy out their own debt for the same price as a 3rd party. I know the original creditors would object, but as someone who seems to support the current system of buying/selling bad debt to 3rd party collection agencies would you object to the creditor having to give the original debtor an option to buyout their own debt at the same price offered by a 3rd party collection agency?
- matthewdgreen 7y ago> The original lenders, who put up money that allows Puerto Rico to pay for various things, did so within a legal regime where it knew Puerto Rico couldn’t declare bankruptcy These same investors also knew that there was a real possibility that Congress and the President could change the law at any time — which is very much part of “the legal regime” they should have considered when investing.